News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by avn2109 on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @07:54PM (#11913021)
It is surprising that nobody in this thread has mentioned what I thought was the most widely-acknowledged argument in favor of firearms ownership in the United States.

In my (rural, libertarian-leaning) home state, firearms owners often explicitly cite some variant of "capacity to resist totalitarianism" or "to defend the American people's liberty against the government" as reasons for having guns.

If, like me, you regard the encroachment of an unconstitutional American surveillance/police state as the primary threat to the way of life and values of the American people, this is a strong argument indeed. In fact I would like to see heavier, more military-flavored weapons proliferate for just this reason, especially since there are diminishing marginal returns for some types of arms escalation. E.g. armor piercing anti-tank weapons or surface-to-air weapons designed for hunting helicopters are not any more useful for shooting up a school than light guns chambered for NATO 7.62. But they have vastly different deterrent effects for a state actor contemplating violence against the populace.

You might argue that this is stupid because if the situation ever devolves to the point of violent oppression, they will just drone strike dissidents' houses invisibly from the sky. But I like to think the main effect of an armed, freedom-loving population is to deter the country's leadership from instituting that level of violent oppression in the first place.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by erichocean on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:05PM (#11913080)
> In my (rural, libertarian-leaning) home state, firearms owners often explicitly cite some variant of "capacity to resist totalitarianism" or "to defend the American people's liberty against the government" as reasons for having guns.

That's because the individuals who wrote the US constitution gave exactly that justification—though people (of course) argue whether or not it is still relevant.

From my perspective, the 1st amendment had a similar justification, so if you really don't buy that _guns_ can keep the gov't in check in any kind of realistic way, clinging to "free speech" as something we absolutely need—for the exact same reason—rings hollow; it doesn't seem like a principled position to me to reject one and embrace the other.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by hackuser on Thursday June 16, 2016 @12:43AM (#11914042)
>> In my (rural, libertarian-leaning) home state, firearms owners often explicitly cite some variant of "capacity to resist totalitarianism" or "to defend the American people's liberty against the government" as reasons for having guns.

> That's because the individuals who wrote the US constitution gave exactly that justification

The only explanation they gave was "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State". It's a bit ambiguous, despite attempts to insist otherwise.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by tracker1 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @12:51AM (#11914079)
But you only need to look at the first militia act to see that by "militia" they mean every able bodied man of age, and they should have a firearm of their own.
Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by hackuser on Thursday June 16, 2016 @11:26AM (#11916757)
First, you must know that many people have may opinions on this; yours is not the only legitimate one. Welcome to democracy!

Also, the militia act isn't the law, the Constitution is.

The Constitution isn't scripture, written by gods and prophets for whom citizens should try to guess their superior, divine wisdom and intent. It's a political document, written by people as human as we are - well-meaning and flawed; earnest, careless, and horribly corrupt; etc. - just like current politicians. The wording is a compromise among those people, who certainly had many intents. (What is the "intent" of a law passed Congress? To find semi-ambiguous wording that can get a majority of votes.)

Most fundamentally, the U.S. is a democracy (and if you care for the founders' intent, that's clearly a big one), not a secular theological state ruled by the will of dead philosopher-kings. Current U.S. citizens decide the law and what the words mean, majority rules.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by DefaultUserHN on Thursday June 16, 2016 @11:08PM (#11920477)
The Constitution defines 4 types of powers.

Powers that are granted by the Constitution to the government (for example, Congress ability to pass law).

Powers that are implied to be given to the government (for example, the President's cabinet).

Powers that are left out and to be decided by the states and the people at a later time (for example, any new laws that are not in conflict with the Constitution).

And finally, powers that are DENIED to the government (these are powers the government must NEVER have).

Now, let's read the 2nd Amendment: ...the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

>shall not be infringed

In other words, the Constitution specifically DENIED the government the power to regulate arms. The government does not have that power. The government was NOT given that power.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by hackuser on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:18AM (#11920658)
If it seems that cut and dry, the argument is missing many things.

One thing to consider is that nothing is a literal absolute in the law; it's not an algorithm. For example, nobody denies the government's right to regulate arms as far as background checks, denying them to criminals, and until very recent history, much more stringent bans on possession - until recently, centuries of American jurists interpreted the law differently, and many still do; were/are they all illiterate? So easily dismissed by online amateurs? Also, government can outlaw advanced arms such as anti-tank and anti-aircraft weapons, and fully automatic weapons.

The government also can't regulate speech according to the text - except that it can: Dangerous speech (shouting fire in a crowded, dark movie theater where there is none, or inciting someone to murder), false commercial speech (lying in your ads), slander, etc. are all illegal.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by tracker1 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @07:06PM (#11919604)
The militia act was the law[1] enacted under the constitution, and given the timeframe, I'd say it accurately represents the intent. I'm not saying that the constituion is scripture, or anything of the sort, I only said you only need to look at the militia act to see what was meant by the 2nd amendment.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_Acts_of_1792

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by hackuser on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:19AM (#11920663)
You may say so but, with due respect, that's not evidence any more than my subjective claims. The U.S. government enacts many laws, often within the same day or hour, with vastly different intents and authored and supported by people with vastly different interests.
Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by gonvaled on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:25AM (#11914761)
"Well regulated"
Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by tracker1 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @11:12AM (#11916658)
Militia Act, not the article... if you look at the militia act, it specifically states that every able bodied male of age is part of said militia, and to provide their own arms.

And you also miss the phrase "In order to" as in for example... it was only one of the reasons why the right to bear arms should not be infringed, not the only one. The bill of rights was at the time argued as superfluous as some felt that most people understood that those were inalienable rights and didn't need to be spelled out. Others felt otherwise (with foresight) and wanted stronger provisions, many of which were in the original Articles of Confederation the country was founded under before the Constitution.

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by bbradley406 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @09:57AM (#11916098)
Misconstruing the phrasing of the amendment is a weak way to argue against it. At the time it was written, "well regulated" was commonly used to describe something that worked well, was in good repair, etc.

A militia being "well regulated" (in modern English) by the government that it might need to fight is the opposite of that.

http://www.constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by loukrazy on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:23PM (#11913152)
I definitely do not agree that the first and second amendment have similar functions. In practice it is the restriction on free speech that is a much more effective and pernicious way of controlling a population. If you have a heavily armed population, that does not dissuade a repressive government from attacking you, it just gets more and more people killed- see Syria.
Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by erichocean on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:29PM (#11913180)
> If you have a heavily armed population, that does not dissuade a repressive government from attacking you, it just gets more and more people killed- see Syria.

Syria is a great example—for the exact opposite belief that a lack of guns is a terrible way to deal with a repressive regime, and will get you and your family killed.

Syrians are NOT "heavily armed", not even close. Syria is ranked 110th out of all countries in terms of "number of guns per capita".[0] USA has 28.8x (!) as many guns per person as Syria.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Number_of_guns_per_capita_by_c...

Re:Ars Technica founder on the AR-15 by tracker1 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @12:50AM (#11914072)
By the same note, I don't see a handgun as being particularly less destructive in this instance... non-hollowpoint ammo fired into a crowd is more dangerous than full-jacket bullets... more deadly to those hit, but less to the people behind them.

For me it's all about personal freedom. And since most people think the police and military are the only ones that should be allowed guns... I can't think of a reason, outside military training, that anyone in the police or military should have a gun that doesn't apply to someone being attacked in their own home.