Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by majewsky on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @05:32AM
(#11908104)
> You then have one leader truck driven by a human, with a line of self-driving trucks follower trucks.
We have had these for over a century. They're called trains. :)
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by shkkmo on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @01:30PM
(#11910701)
And if the rail system extended as widely as the road system, we wouldn't have had semi-trucks in the first place.
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by douche on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:58PM
(#11911247)
Well, at one time it did[1]. A hundred years ago, I could have walked down to the train station down my street, hopped on a train and gotten off in my home town, 150 miles away, having taken a nap or read a book on the way. Now I've got to drive myself that distance in a hurtling chunk of metal, constantly on the alert for all the other crazy people darting around in their high-velocity chunks of metal, and arrive exhausted.
Ain't that some progress
[1] http://users.humboldt.edu/ogayle/Hist%20111%20Images/RR1890....
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by antisthenes on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:44PM
(#11911150)
The trucker jobs would have never existed then, and the rail could have been already automated by today's date.
I wonder how different the US would have looked if that was the case. It might have also slowed down climate change somewhat, since trains are much more efficient than trucks (about 3x in terms of mile-ton per unit of fuel).
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by tptacek on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:27PM
(#11913170)
Australia already uses trucks as trains.
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by Udik on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:28AM
(#11907500)
As cool as the concept is, no, I don't think so. A line of self driving trucks can break up for any reason (cars getting between two trucks, messy junctions, an isolated accident or malfunction). At that point you need again full autonomous driving, as you can't stop a whole column of trucks on the emergency lane, run to the one that got stuck (and the rest of the column behind it) and make it catch up with the rest.
Re:As Tech Evaporates Jobs, “The Tipping Point Will Be Drive...
by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @06:18PM
(#11912577)
AI-controlled trucks can drive nearly bumper-to-bumper, because there needn't be any reaction-time delay. If the lead truck hits the brakes, every other truck in the column can brake instantly, and with exactly the same pressure. It effectively becomes a single road train with no space in between. Messy junctions can be avoided as long as you stay on the highway proper and don't pass through cities; with this plan, you'd have short-haul truckers at either end for the first-and-last mile work, with the AIs handling the cross-country part.
As for accidents or malfunctions--why can't you stop a column of trucks in the breakdown lane? I'm assuming that the trucks would have at least limited self-parking ability, since that seems to be at least as easy as highway driving for a development standpoint.
When the problem is restricted to self-driving on the interstate highways on fixed routes it is a lot simpler than the problem of general self-driving so we'll get that solved a lot sooner.
Furthermore, there is an even simpler intermediate step, which is to have self-driving trucks that just know how to follow another truck. You then have one leader truck driven by a human, with a line of self-driving trucks follower trucks. This simplifies the problem dramatically, getting rid of almost everything that is hard about self-driving vehicle technology. The limiting factor on when truck trains will be commercially available will be regulatory, not technological.