Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi
by dang on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @05:39PM
(#11905537)
If you want to, it's actually pretty easy to respond substantively to the wrongness in another comment without calling names or attacking the commenter personally. Besides being easy, it makes your response more credible. So I don't think there's a tradeoff here—just bad habits that we all need to grow out of.
What civility does demand is a willingness to forego the pleasures of venting and lashing out at what (and who) one dislikes. That can be hard to do when something we read sets off a pre-existing opinion or emotion. But doing it has a vast effect on discussion quality, so it's necessary.
> Indeed, in many of these recent observances of "personal attacks", what I view as actually happening is silently assenting to the worldview of an original poster/article and protecting that worldview.
It's hard to respond to a generality like that but I'm pretty sure that we're not assenting to or protecting specific worldviews when we ask people to be civil on this site. It's tempting to see the moderation that way because the cases you dislike are the ones you'll tend to notice more. But getting moderation right requires asking everyone to hold to the same standard regardless of what we personally happen to agree with. We're not perfect at that but we do try hard, and hopefully improve with practice.
What civility does demand is a willingness to forego the pleasures of venting and lashing out at what (and who) one dislikes. That can be hard to do when something we read sets off a pre-existing opinion or emotion. But doing it has a vast effect on discussion quality, so it's necessary.
> Indeed, in many of these recent observances of "personal attacks", what I view as actually happening is silently assenting to the worldview of an original poster/article and protecting that worldview.
It's hard to respond to a generality like that but I'm pretty sure that we're not assenting to or protecting specific worldviews when we ask people to be civil on this site. It's tempting to see the moderation that way because the cases you dislike are the ones you'll tend to notice more. But getting moderation right requires asking everyone to hold to the same standard regardless of what we personally happen to agree with. We're not perfect at that but we do try hard, and hopefully improve with practice.