I didn't think it was 'dismayingly nasty' or bilious; I thought it was mildly snarky and made an important substantive point which was not lost.
Btw I didn't threaten to ban. I try to be careful that way, and this was a "please don't", not a "we ban accounts that do this, so please don't".
You cannot have meaty discussion amongst people with diverse points of view from diverse backgrounds without an expectation of civility and respect. If that isn't enforced, then minority viewpoints have no hope of being taken seriously. It becomes an echo chamber and the oxygen gets sucked out of the community. This can also drive away your most valued contributors and/or make their contributions toxic in a way they can't stop.
There is all kinds of problems with saying that it is okay to express a valid point in a nasty fashion.
Please don't comment like this here. Whatever substantive point you might have is lost amid the snark and bile, and those are two acids we need less of.