I don't think a shift like this is precipitated by exceeding some limit on free parameters. It's precipitated by a new discovery not fitting with current models. When the Higgs was discovered, it was just a confirmation of what the SM already predicted; it filled in another free parameter in the SM (the Higgs mass, which had only been roughly estimated before), but it didn't point the way to any new, more fundamental model. This new evidence, if it pans out, does point the way to some new, hopefully more fundamental model, because it's something that isn't included in our current models. That is true even if it has no effect at all on the number of free parameters in our theories.
(Btw, the 26 free parameters in the SM sounds like a lot, but since it includes all of the fundamental interactions except gravity, those 26 are really just a collection of all the free parameters from previous theories of those same interactions. For example, the mass and charge of the electron were already free parameters in electrodynamics, so the SM didn't add them on out of nowhere.)
Also, as I've commented already, the SM has been understood to be incomplete for several decades. Everybody already expects that there will have to be a significant shift in our understanding when we go to the next level down. We just don't know what that shift will be, because up to now we've had no experimental data on the question. Now we might finally be getting some.
I agree that the number of parameters needed is less than the number of experimental measurements though, I confused that.
This is true, in practice we can't do all of the derivations from first principles. But AFAIK this is an issue of, as you say, computational power; it is not an issue of theoretical insufficiency (at least within the domain that the SM covers, i.e., the non-gravitational interactions in flat spacetime with gravity being negligible). We know what equations we would have to solve; we just can't solve them analytically and we don't have the computing power to solve them numerically in all cases.
and
>The SM doesn't include gravity. It also has twenty-six free parameters that have to be determined from experiments; it doesn't explain why those parameters take the values they do.
26 free parameters. Yikes.
At what point does the addition of parameters and particles break through from "yet another particle we expected" to "this is completely unexpected and we need to seriously modify our understanding". Obviously with geocentric vs heliocentric it took a major shift in understanding before epicycles crumbled. Same with newton to einstein -- a major shift in understanding before minor errors were explained.
Aside from the SA hyperbole, do you think there is any evidence that particle physics is reaching critical mass in terms of convoluted explanations?
Of course, it could be the case that nature is just damn complex at the particle level.