News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @10:28AM (#118936)
Important world news, which is why it's on cnn.com and pretty much every other news site out there. Pretty much irrelevant to hackers.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by michael_nielsen on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:04PM (#119004)
I voted this story up. The question I try to answer in deciding whether to upvote a story is this: is the story important to hackers? Castro retiring is a major event. It's not on a par with the fall of the Berlin Wall, say, but it's more important than nearly everything that's gone on in the US Primaries, to pick an example. My guess is that it's more interesting to most hackers than the unoriginal me-too lists of "Top ten mistakes startups make" that still regularly populate Hacker News.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by hugh on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @06:14PM (#119277)
I personally tend to try to apply the standard of whether it's of importance or interest to hackers in particular, rather than to human beings in general.

Major news stories are, of course, of importance to everyone, but I personally would rather have a hacker news which is focused on hacker-ish stuff.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by ntoshev on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @03:58AM (#119565)
Thank you, it is a nice Bayesian point of view.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:09PM (#119007)
Ok, but by that same standard, the following stories are important too:

- Vote in Pakistan. They've got nukes...

- Kosovo independence has important repercussions in Europe and elsewhere.

- A big tax scandal in Germany, one of the world's most important economies.

- Obama just announced some kind of protectionist tax plan to 'keep jobs in America'.

just to grab a few...

Re:Fidel Castro retires by michael_nielsen on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:30PM (#119024)
I think we have different standards. In 10 years, will anyone remember any of these? Only Castro and Kosovo might qualify. I certainly wouldn't even considering upvoting any of the rest. They're ephemera, and I agree with you that they're not of great interest to hackers.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:34PM (#119027)
They're all more important than the '10 things every startup should know' link in the grand scheme of things.

The other problem is that it doesn't pass the "make me smarter or inform me of something I didn't know" test. It's a piece of information I already knew, as did anyone else that is in any way connected to TV, radio or other news sites.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by michael_nielsen on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:43PM (#119034)
The test I'm applying is not whether the stories are more important in the grand scheme of things. I completely agree with you - that test is not the right test to apply. The right test, in my opinion, is how interesting a story is to hackers. And on that criterion, my original judgement was that the news of Castro's resignation merits an upvote.

With that said, your point about how widely distributed a story is elsewhere is an interesting one. I'm not sure I completely agree - the Microsoft offer to buy Yahoo wouldn't have made it onto Hacker News under this criterion, for example.

Part of the reason for wanting stories like this to appear on Hacker News isn't so much to be informed of the existence of the story, but rather for the quality of the discussion provoked by the stories. There are certain commenters whose opinion of Castro's resignation I'd far rather hear than some talking head on CNN.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:48PM (#119037)
Aha! Now we're getting somewhere: I was thinking the same thing about commentary - that's the only valid reason to have a widely visible story here.

However, I think that commentary on MS/Yahoo is far more relevant here than anything about Castro can possibly be. Indeed, Castro commentary is very likely to lead down the reddit road.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by michael_nielsen on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @01:24PM (#119070)
You may be right. In the large, I'm optimistic that it's possible to set up a forum where sensible discussion of hot button issues like politics is possible. Certainly, HN offers good initial conditions for achieving this: a great base of intelligent commenters who mostly seem able to have intelligent conversations with one another, even when they disagree. But maybe HN isn't the right place to be attempting this.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by vlad on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @12:33AM (#119454)
There are a few examples of online communities expanding so fast that original users no longer find them intellectually stimulating. Is there a single root cause? Are users so overconfident in their mutual abilities to discuss off-topic content safely, that they mistakingly end up allowing their own communities to kick themselves out; is it the fault of the design of the community software and system/processes; or, could it be that the community grew too quickly?

As somebody who enjoys this community a lot, I want to know that if 1,000 people start posting random URL's tomorrow, that not only would software filters stop junk from getting through, but that the community would step up and moderate itself because, albeit this is Hacker News, algorithms are never perfect: we are going to have to use our brains to make sure the site is still focused (or re-focused) regardless of how interesting an article might be.

On the other hand, there are good signs this may not necessarily happen to Hacker News. It's very possible that Digg, Reddit, and newcomer social news sites will be enough to satisfy the needs of most users. This site could be like a chess club in that it's open to everybody, but most people wouldn't care.

At the same time, one has to admit that if a social news site continues to address every topic on earth, it could get to the point where as the content becomes more similar to that of Digg or Reddit, there would be an exponential increase in new registrations daily of users looking for the next big thing. These users would then vote up new types of stories and change the site in a very short time. I think I read that one can't grow a team by more than 25% in number per year, or one will have a team that has lost qualities of the existing group--this is likely a major factor in retaining consistency and focus for this community, too.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by Hexstream on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @03:11PM (#119142)
"Indeed, Castro commentary is very likely to lead down the reddit road."

Hum... we don't want to digg too deep down the reddit hole?

Re:Fidel Castro retires by cstejerean on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:48PM (#119038)
I'm not connected to a TV, radio or other news sites. This is my primary news source and I don't mind if occasionally an article like this makes its way to the top. OTOH I understand this doesn't belong on HN. But I wouldn't start violently complaining about it.

Why can't I just have a button to dismiss a story of the front page? Not downvote it, just make it disappear from MY homepage?

Re:Fidel Castro retires by pg on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @01:41PM (#119084)
Why can't I just have a button to dismiss a story of the front page? Not downvote it, just make it disappear from MY homepage?

It would be easy enough to do, but my gut tells me it would be a mistake, because it would make it easier for the site as a whole to deteriorate. As long as everyone has to see every story, there's a lot of pressure not to have bad stuff.

Paul Buchheit dislikes optional settings in software for similar reasons. He thinks they're usually just a way to punt on hard design decisions. Nearly everyone is going to use the defaults anyway, so you should just work hard to make those are right.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by cstejerean on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @06:24PM (#119285)
Well, with no ability to downvote I'm not sure how forcing everyone to see every story keeps the quality high. And there are certainly no incentives to prevent submission of low quality stories (as far as I'm aware). Just spam away and hope something will get upvoted.

But from a reading perspective once I read a story (and maybe some of the comments) from the front page I no longer care about it. Something I'll want to follow the comments (but to make that easy an option to see which stories have new comments instead of having to squint at the number of comments would work better anyway).

So usually over half the stories on the home page are links that I don't care about (either I upmoded them or want to ignore them and don't care to follow the comment thread).

Maybe this forces people to follow the new stream (of which an RSS feed would be extremely helpful).

Re:Fidel Castro retires by pg on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @07:33PM (#119323)
I'm not sure how forcing everyone to see every story keeps the quality high

It means the watchdogs will bark when crap stories try to infiltrate the camp.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by foonamefoo on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @07:57PM (#119333)
But the guy was talking about a hide button, not a "hide it before I even see that it is there" (if that's even possible) button. Am I misunderstanding this?
Re:Fidel Castro retires by Hexstream on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @03:20PM (#119150)
Butbutbut!!!

I'm positive at least 20% of the stories do not appeal to each person, but the stories in that 20% are different for each individual (see what I mean?)

Lack of interest towards a subject matter in an individual at a specific time doesn't necessarily denote lack of suitability for the subject for HN.

Personally I'm getting quite irritated at the need to eyeball-scan the news because I'm rather keeping up with the new articles so I visit often but I always have like 15 stories I already decided I wouldn't check out...

Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @01:06PM (#119050)
No one here is "complaining violently". Everyone has been quite civil so far. I like that about this site.

It's your choice not to follow other news sites. Something like cnn, bbc, etc... is a much better place to stay abreast of current events than yc.news.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by andreyf on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @03:50PM (#119164)
Haha, saw that comment coming a mile away! :)
Re:Fidel Castro retires by mk on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:04PM (#119003)
Maybe it is time for a downvote button.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by boredguy8 on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:12PM (#119010)
Just make sure stories can't go below 1, imho.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by kajecounterhack on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:38AM (#119503)
Whats relevant to the world is still relevant to us hackers. We might be a special population interested in something like MSFT's bids on Yahoo, but we're just as interested, (as you can see by this upvoted thread) in the happenings of the "real" world outside of our digital cages.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by hollywoodcole on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @11:18AM (#118977)
If it matters than it isn't irrelevant. No one is forcing you to vote for it.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @11:40AM (#118990)
The set of things that matter, in world terms, far more than what Paul Graham thinks of trolls, or startup school, or memcached is large enough that it could easily crowd out the 'hacker news' without breaking a sweat, as this page suggests: http://www.ft.com/world

I don't see what the problem is with taking this kind of story elsewhere.

It's not a bad story or uninteresting, just that first this one...then a Musharraf one, then another one about the US primaries, and on and on. All of them more important than the regular fare here. And after a while, the value of the site is diluted in terms of its original purpose.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by hollywoodcole on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @11:56AM (#118999)
Come on David don't be so negative. Just because it might have happen on another site doesn't mean it will happen here. Like I said before, I can't vote the article up to the frontpage, takes more than one person.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by pg on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:01PM (#119000)
He's right to worry. I worry too. And in fact our abuse detection code is suspicious about this story, because so many of the first upvotes were from newly created accounts.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by hollywoodcole on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:16PM (#119016)
back to coding for you then!
Re:Fidel Castro retires by kingnothing on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:38PM (#119030)
HN has a different news focus than other sites, and we're trying to protect its identity by saying that certain topics, while important, should not be discussed here. In short, we're trying to prevent the reddit effect.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:19PM (#119018)
Hey, don't take it personally, I would have made the same comments whoever posted the story, and you're right that you only submitted it, it also took a bunch of people to upvote it. No one here but pg can really force anyone to do anything, so I'm just asking, and trying to explain why.

(BTW, even though I disagree with you, I upvoted you because a 0 or a -1 is more than enough to indicate disapproval).

Re:Fidel Castro retires by hollywoodcole on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @12:37PM (#119029)
I understand where you are coming from. not taking it personally or to offend you, just thought it was an article that should be mentioned.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by brent on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @04:35PM (#119187)
Hackers are generally interested in the world around them, particularly things related to freedom (personal, intellectual, or otherwise). It doesn't get much bigger than this. How could this possibly be irrelevant? If its irrelevant to you, you must live in a bubble.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by davidw on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @04:47PM (#119194)
With that as an out, you can basically say that anything goes. I guess 'irrelevant' wasn't the best word. Let's say that I don't think it ought to be here, for the reasons outlined in the other comments.