I suspect that most people read once or twice a day so the difference between voting when something is +10 and +1 is when they see an article relative to its posting time.
In other words, most folks aren't looking for "close" votes to affect.
Besides, who's to say that +10 to +9 is actually different from +1 to 0? The score just tells you the difference between up and down votes. It doesn't tell you that the +10 was 10-0 while the +1 was 100-99. Do you really want to argue that a downvote is inappropriate in the latter case?
I think that public scores are arguably a mistake because folks read far too much into them. Someone didn't like something - get over it.
That said, I think that scores should be hidden except when they get "close". Or, maybe they should disappear if you vote "too much".
Reply with the facts as you understand them.
Also, "disagreement" isn't always the best characterization. If someone makes factual errors in their post downvoting is a perfectly valid signal, for instance.