News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Downvotes by philwelch on Saturday March 13, 2010 @10:18AM (#1188995)
There's a difference between downvoting a +10 comment down to +9 out of disagreement and downvoting a +! comment down to 0 out of disagreement.

Also, "disagreement" isn't always the best characterization. If someone makes factual errors in their post downvoting is a perfectly valid signal, for instance.

Re:Downvotes by anamax on Saturday March 13, 2010 @11:11AM (#1189071)
> There's a difference between downvoting a +10 comment down to +9 out of disagreement and downvoting a +! comment down to 0 out of disagreement.

I suspect that most people read once or twice a day so the difference between voting when something is +10 and +1 is when they see an article relative to its posting time.

In other words, most folks aren't looking for "close" votes to affect.

Besides, who's to say that +10 to +9 is actually different from +1 to 0? The score just tells you the difference between up and down votes. It doesn't tell you that the +10 was 10-0 while the +1 was 100-99. Do you really want to argue that a downvote is inappropriate in the latter case?

I think that public scores are arguably a mistake because folks read far too much into them. Someone didn't like something - get over it.

That said, I think that scores should be hidden except when they get "close". Or, maybe they should disappear if you vote "too much".

Re:Downvotes by philwelch on Sunday March 14, 2010 @02:23PM (#1191046)
Personally, I'm far more cavalier about downvoting +10 comments than I am about downvoting +1 comments.
Re:Downvotes by lucifer on Saturday March 13, 2010 @10:53AM (#1189048)
" If someone makes factual errors in their post downvoting is a perfectly valid signal, for instance."

Reply with the facts as you understand them.

Re:Downvotes by philwelch on Saturday March 13, 2010 @11:07AM (#1189068)
I usually do. But the downvotes work as a signal to the people reading the thread, just as they're meant to.
Re:Downvotes by cookiecaper on Saturday March 13, 2010 @06:28PM (#1189864)
I think that's interesting but sad when a person makes a good-faith effort to help out, because it deducts from that person's karma even though they don't really deserve a punishment for trying to help.