Also, "disagreement" isn't always the best characterization. If someone makes factual errors in their post downvoting is a perfectly valid signal, for instance.
I suspect that most people read once or twice a day so the difference between voting when something is +10 and +1 is when they see an article relative to its posting time.
In other words, most folks aren't looking for "close" votes to affect.
Besides, who's to say that +10 to +9 is actually different from +1 to 0? The score just tells you the difference between up and down votes. It doesn't tell you that the +10 was 10-0 while the +1 was 100-99. Do you really want to argue that a downvote is inappropriate in the latter case?
I think that public scores are arguably a mistake because folks read far too much into them. Someone didn't like something - get over it.
That said, I think that scores should be hidden except when they get "close". Or, maybe they should disappear if you vote "too much".
Reply with the facts as you understand them.
As downvotes don't differentiate between agreement and poor construction of argument how can you tell what contributes. I find that those who disagree with me in a well thought out way are instructive. I don't wish to homogenise with the community but want to know if I'm not expressing myself well.
For example, this comment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1135803, I can't work out why it's downvoted. Thus I can't see what I could have done to improve the comment or why I should perhaps of not made it.
IMO we should have an agreement vote as well as a quality vote.
Probably because you wrote "Next they'll be telling us they don't proofread their title submissions, un-freaking-believable ;0)" as the opening sentence. The rest of the comment looks fine, but it leads off with language that sounds like LOL-speak. Too bad you got downvoted. But the downvotes give you something to learn from about how to express yourself when you are making a serious comment, as that comment mostly was.
It is annoying to see a reasonable comment downvoted to 0, or less. I feel like I'm missing something and what I'm missing is an explanation. Why was the comment voted down?
Now what happened in the grandparent of this comment here is that another HN participant asked why a particular comment of his in another thread was downvoted. I kindly followed the link he provided, to see his comment for the first time. After reading that comment, I pondered his informational question in this thread about why that comment was downvoted. I don't know FOR SURE, because I had no role in downvoting that comment, and indeed wouldn't downvote that comment if I came upon it in a thread I was following actively. But I suggest to him one reason why somebody--unknown to me--might have thought to downvote that comment. Then I see that my own informational answer to his question was downvoted--for reasons not stated in this thread. There is some kind of signal here, but I sure hope that the signal is not "Don't answer informational questions posted by other participants."
The answer I gave above was a hypothesis based on previous comments I have seen with downvotes. But the hypothesis doesn't fit the answer itself being downvoted, which for all I know was simply drive-by downvoting.
Comes across as condescending and mildly offensive because of that. Probably why you got downvoted.
FWIW I think that the use of humour in identifying errors, particularly when coupled with information as in my representative comment, does not detract from the comment's worth. Indeed I find it hard not to find funny the errors in a piece which is all about pointing out a common error...
The point still stands - you can assert that the reason is my terrible sense of humour (!) but I can't tell if that's true or not.
In my opinion, upvotes should be used to promote any comment that provides a unique or underconsidered point-of-view on the topic at hand, to indicate enthusiastic agreement, or to encourage users. For instance, if someone posts a comment that says what I would have said if they had not said it, I upvote it, because I enthusiastically agree and that user has saved me the time I would have spent typing it out, and usually introduced an element I hadn't considered. Or, if a user has posted a thoughtful comment with a divergent take from the rest of the group, even if I don't agree or don't care, I will often upvote that because it will get people thinking and hopefully generate good discussion. I will also upvote comments that have caused me to reconsider an opinion, or that make a point I hadn't yet considered. Those comments expand my mind and experience, and are good.
I find myself upvoting a lot of things I otherwise wouldn't upvote recently, primarily because I don't think the comment is worthy of downvotes it has received. For instance, http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188846 is the comment that pushed me over on posting this, and it had a score of zero when I found it. I didn't find it particularly useful or insightful, and I didn't really have much opinion on its content, but I didn't think it deserved a downvote, and I upvoted it to get it back up to 1.
I try to reserve my downvotes for lines of thought or discussion that are either useless or actively damaging to the community. I don't think a comment deserves to be buried and its user penalized by karma removal merely because I disagree or don't find their comment interesting. I think of the vote buttons as a tool for communal cropping, I suppose, not a personal comment rating system.
This is an often-discussed issue. I see your join date is not quite from long enough ago that you may have seen this comment from pg
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
in which he said, "I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness.
"It only becomes abuse when people resort to karma bombing: downvoting a lot of comments by one user without reading them in order to subtract maximum karma. Fortunately we now have several levels of software to protect against that."
But I have a still more recent join date, and I have seen links back to that comment on the MANY previous occasions when downvotes have been discussed, so I have become aware of this point of view.
Of course, more recent discussions of the issue of voting behavior on HN
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507948
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057133
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1103339
(this set of links is far from exhaustive) show that there is thought on the part of site management about how to improve current incentives.
I try to learn from the downvotes I receive. I don't expect everyone to agree with me, but I expect myself to analyze my own behavior to figure out what really contributes to the community. The site management, of course, has to figure out how to set up incentives for altruistic rather than mob behavior.
I always wonder, when I see a post about the evils of downvotes, why I don't see more replies about what is good to upvote. I tried opening a separate thread about that issue recently
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1065084
but you can see for yourself it didn't get upvoted much at the time. I will ask again here: what ought to be upvoted? I would like advice from the community about how to use my upvotes to build up the community.