News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyperloop One Will Be Underwater, Underground, Across the... by yoo1I on Sunday June 12, 2016 @03:46PM (#11889910)
Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't this "Hyperloop" system just some, granted elaborate, set of blueprints and whitepapers, but Musk isn't actually delivering it himself. Rather, other companies are working on it ?

But even disregarding that, I think OP was referring to how certain segments of the media hang on Musk's lips, as if he is some sort of tech-messiah.

And I don't want to take any praise away from him, the man has done really impressive things. That's not it.

It's just that there seems to be a certain type of over-hyping. The idea for magnetic, vacuum-escaped tube travel certainly isn't new. And a last week's reporting of his "we probably live in a simulation"-comment comes to mind as well. That's not a very original thought, yet was widely reported.

So yeah, I agree, delivery matters. But it's not just the delivery that's being idolized here.

Re:Hyperloop One Will Be Underwater, Underground, Across the... by coldtea on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:16PM (#11890807)
>Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't this "Hyperloop" system just some, granted elaborate, set of blueprints and whitepapers, but Musk isn't actually delivering it himself. Rather, other companies are working on it ?

In this case yes. But he has delivered plenty already in other fields.

>But even disregarding that, I think OP was referring to how certain segments of the media hang on Musk's lips, as if he is some sort of tech-messiah.

Well, same way certain segments of HN hang on PG's lips etc. People like heroes -- and it's not just the ignorant masses or the "media" that do so.

Re:Hyperloop One Will Be Underwater, Underground, Across the... by Avshalom on Sunday June 12, 2016 @04:30PM (#11890090)
Elaborate is pretty overselling what Musk actually released. It was back of the envelope level engineering and some drawings in that architectural-sketchy style.