News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open access: All human knowledge is there, so why can’t e... by dredmorbius on Sunday June 12, 2016 @01:14AM (#11886746)
You're pretty much entirely missing the point.

1. Scientists aren't at the heart of the scientific Open Access problem. Journals are.

2. The fact that copyright exists means that journals can then request it be transferred (or licensed) to the journal. For what's effectively forever.

3. Journals exercise gatekeeper access over scientists' careers, in that publishing in prestige journals is how scientists advance academically. This is de facto* coercive control over scientists.

4. With that control, journals compell publication of articles in controlled journals, for scientists to advance, require subscriptions of libraries (who otherwise forgo access to the material), and maintain a bank of virtually all scientific papers published since 1924 as an absolute monopoly.

Hence: no copyright, or a far-less-rediculous copyright, say, 14, 28, or 54 years (as was historically the case, via registration(s) and/or renewals), and much the problem would disappear.

The additional factor of deadweight costs of denied access to virtually all of humanity for this material is the other cost.

There are no comments on this comment yet.