Joel Spolsky had a popular programming blog. He mentions a site that he is involved with (SO) and suddenly it has the attention of a large number of people.
We all know Andrew Warner, what a nice guy is his, how good he is at building relationships. We visit his page often.
Don't you think that this alone is an extremely valuable commodity?
If Andrew decided to start a venture, or to invest and promote a venture, he would have the eyes and ears of the HN community in short order.
That is worth far more than any paywall revenue.
Joel Spolsky sells software for a living and is looking to turn a profit with StackExchange soon.
Why should people be criticized, on a site specifically built to attract entrepreneurs, for trying to turn a profit with their venture? How hypocritical.
There's no reason it couldn't be used either way.
What I am saying is that if you create free, popular, useful content you can't help but make money from the word of mouth it generates.
I'm not sure his business model is the right one by any means, but he has a right to try. It's not lame to do so. And I don't think the knee-jerk reaction against charging is healthy. My guess is that the reaction (seen every time someone starts charging) is usually caused by the desire to keep getting it for free, and then all of these illogical justifications rationalize them.
Andrew can fire his staff, fire his clients, and fire his users and he can certainly follow whatever business model he wants but for someone has had interviews with Seth Godin subscription models are a plain ol' boring not-purple sort of cow.
I don't think that's the case here though. It's hard for me to be objective, but I'm fairly certain this change was executed poorly and may have been an entirely mistaken course.
> ...[they] never suggest any specifically or show any evidence they would actually gain traction.
Leo Laporte makes $1.5MM/year on his podcasts with sponsorships. I doubt Mixergy will make that with paid subscriptions anytime soon, yet it has an even more valuable audience. TechCrunch makes a heck of a lot more than that. Imagine how much money Techcrunch would be making if it had gone subscription a year or two into its life.