Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by izacus on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:44PM
(#11881074)
Yes, we would certanly rather have nothing. Status Quo is infinitely better than forced data transfer of our data to another nation and infinitely better than selling out IP protection to US corporation under ridiculous copyright laws.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by tptacek on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:49PM
(#11881102)
If that's true, why does your local legislature (I don't know where you are) enable the treaty in domestic law?
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by izacus on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:58PM
(#11881163)
It doesn't. I'm not sure why that would affect this debate at all?
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by tptacek on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:37PM
(#11881311)
If your local legislature doesn't enable the treaty, you aren't bound by it: it isn't a part of your law. A trade treaty is essentially a promise to pass a set of laws.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by iofj on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:19PM
(#11881866)
Generally treaties are negotiated by the executive of a country, not the legislative force. Even in the cases where there is still a ratification step, the initiative is taken away from the legislative, and the law is written by indirectly (at best) elected commissars (in the case of the EU), rather than directly elected representatives.
In the case of the EU, there isn't even a ratification step once the EU commission (which isn't elected) agrees to a treaty.
And of course ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supremacy_(European_Union_law)
That means that with EU commission agreement you get the supreme court (that supersedes all local courts) arguing that anything the commission agrees to can countermand local constitutions.
So local legislature agreement required, in many cases, is incorrect.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by roel_v on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:35AM
(#11882506)
Eh, no it isn't (necessarily). That depends on whether a certain legal system is monistic or dualistic; or rather, adheres to monistic or dualistic principles (it's not a black or white thing). Without knowing where the GP is from, you can't reasonably make any assumptions, because both are common.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by forrestthewoods on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:34PM
(#11881721)
The total number of down votes I've gotten is crazy. HN sucks when you don't agree with the hivemind. It's frustrating.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by MawNicker on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:08PM
(#11881827)
The most discouraging pattern is down-votes on reasonable comments without any feedback whatsoever. Before a person can down-vote they should be required to leave a response OR to up-vote an existing response.
It's a large and complicated document; there's plenty of room for bad ideas, and plenty of room for good. The real question is, "Would we rather have nothing?" Because the existing ecosystem of loosely-affiliated nation-by-nation policies is a sh-tshow.