News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by SilasX on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:53PM (#11879495)
Exactly -- the problem is that our civil litigation's "truth-finding procedure" is so vulnerable to financial influence. Asking how to "keep people from spending money on lawyers" is the wrong approach; the system's process needs to be robust against such asymmetric investment. [1]

People forget that proper civil litigation is a public good (in the economic sense). Ensuring that (civil) wrongdoers pay for their actions benefits everyone by making it less likely they will be a victim of such acts, and more likely that transgressors will offer a quick settlement rather than using the courts in the first place.

[1] While it's impossible to truly shield off such influence, we can at least go for some standard like, "it should take an exponential investment to produce a linear impact on the award".

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by unclebucknasty on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:01PM (#11880454)
>"it should take an exponential investment to produce a linear impact on the award"

I'm not sure how we would manage that but, assuming we could, doesn't this cut both ways? As long as money is in the equation, then don't all parties still benefit by having as much money as possible?

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by SilasX on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:11PM (#11880512)
No, because (under the condition I described), the size of the award increases much slower than the investment, so it quickly becomes a losing proposition; the gain in award is exceeded by the loss in expenditures (assuming the bounds on legal costs awarded are bounded by a slower function).

Under that condition, each doubling of the amount spent on influencing the outcome (via payments expert witnesses, bribes to the judge, discovery, etc) would only yield the same gain in revenues from the court. So for example, if you start with $1000, then doubling to $2000 might yield $1500, doubling to $2000 with only yield $1500 more on top of that, and so on.

(I agree an exponential difference might be two hard; I'd be happy for even a quadratic difference!)

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by Retra on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:36PM (#11881917)
The problem is that a court ruling can result in exponential benefits for the victor.
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by SilasX on Saturday June 11, 2016 @12:54AM (#11882140)
And if that ruling is unwarranted, it should take double-exponential costs to get it!
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by unclebucknasty on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:44AM (#11882981)
But, what if it is warranted and who decides this?
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by ryanlol on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:22PM (#11879697)
>the problem is that our civil litigation's "truth-finding procedure" is so vulnerable to financial influence

Do you have any scientific research backing this? Or just anecdotal evidence?

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by EdHominem on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:25PM (#11880160)
Asking for scientific evidence that the sun will come up is almost like trolling.

In an adversarial system your chances depend on the amount of valid legal process-effort you exert. If you acknowledge that this effort is correlated with financing, even a little, then you admit there is a vulnerability.

A more reasonable question would be if they have a reason to assume that the variable has an oversized impact on the process.

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by ryanlol on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:30PM (#11880184)
>In an adversarial system your chances depend on the amount of valid legal process-effort you exert. If you acknowledge that this effort is correlated with financing, even a little, then you admit there is a vulnerability.

This is a fair point, but the existence of such a vulnerability is unquestionable. However, SilasX seemed to be implying that this is a significant vulnerability, which is a claim that certainly deserves some evidence to back it up.

>A more reasonable question would be if they have a reason to assume that the variable has an oversized impact on the process.

That's exactly what I was asking about, SilasX specifically said "so vulnerable" as opposed to just "vulnerable". That seems to imply such an oversized impact.

Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction by SilasX on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:24PM (#11880154)
The premise of this discussion is that the better funded side tends to get a better result (in a manner superlinear with respect to the funding). If you reject that premise, fine, but your comment belongs higher up, or as its own thread, not as a criticism of my specific point.