Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by petercooper on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:30PM
(#1187959)
This video contains content from Channel 4, who has blocked it in your country on copyright grounds.
What.. my country, the UK? The country where I have to pay an extortionate TV tax/license every year, part of which goes to fund Channel 4? How comes I can view this through a US-based VPN yet not directly in the UK when the content is from a British TV station I'm paying for?
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by corruption on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:06PM
(#1187916)
Anyone who thinks this isn't real, go and read some mentalism books. Derren's ebooks and audio books are especially interesting for beginners.
I was staggered at the practicality of many of their ideas. E.g. I now recognise when someone unwittingly is using hypnotic suggestion in a conversation and it doesn't have the effect it may have. I'm able to pretend to be psychic at parties, and can pull of some pretty good cold reading tricks as well now.
It's worth learning how to do memory palaces just for fun (one of Derren's audiobooks has this, which is a good beginner introduction).
If you don't think he's capable of tricks like this without cutscenes, there are some videos floating around of him performing tricks better than this on other top class magicians which couldn't have been faked. I suspect he claims he's doing illusions because it makes it seem less powerful than it really is, and makes us seem more in control than we really are.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by mapleoin on Saturday March 13, 2010 @03:54AM
(#1188703)
You're just trolling now. Could you be a bit more informative and point the rest of us, who don't know what this is about, to a link with that detailed analysis?
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by corruption on Friday March 12, 2010 @08:23PM
(#1188258)
I would recommend getting a torrent containing some popular ones to see what authors you enjoy (some writing really rubs me the wrong way), then buy the relevant books from the authors directly. There are so many different parts & approaches to mentalism you have to do some searching to see what fits best.
If you want some simple tricks to get into it, just get derrens audio books which are quick and powerful.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by icey on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:13PM
(#1187676)
It's worth noting that Derren Brown is an entertainer / illusionist. For everything that you see in the video, there are likely a large number of things you're not seeing.
Instead of working his tricks under the illusion of them being "magic" he pins the workings on pop psychology - he may tell you that he's using subliminal messages posted along the route, and not mention a bunch of coloring books left in the room with similar pictures (for example).
It's a cool video, for sure; but the results are most likely not derived from "subliminal messages".
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by chrisa on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:31PM
(#1187727)
Even if this was the result of an illusionist, it highlights something I've often thought of, and has come up on HN a few times: that very similar products and movies will come out at just about the same time. The best examples I can give are from movies, and how close together certain movies are made and released, that have very similar plots:
Deep Impact (May 1998) -> Armageddon (July 1998)
The Illusionist (September 2006) -> The Prestige (October 2006)
Paul Blart: Mall Cop (January 2009) -> Observe and Report (April 2009)
These movies came out too close together for one to copy the other, so either the directors and studios were in it together on these movies (entirely likely I suppose: I don't know much about the movie industry; if anyone does know why this occurs, I'd be very interested), or one studio got wind of what the other was doing and made a "copy" before the original even came out, or else something much more subtle is going on.
In the startup / tech world, I think this happens too, because we all tend to follow the same blogs, news sources, etc – so any subtle (probably unintentional) message that makes one of us think of a new product makes 1000 of us think of a nearly identical product, at the exact same time. To me, that highlights execution is so important, and ideas are a "dime a dozen".
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by joezydeco on Friday March 12, 2010 @04:02PM
(#1187788)
One thing you don't realize about the movie industry is that parts of it actually move a lot slower than you think.
Some of these scripts (actually, most of them) float around Hollywood for years, even a decade or longer. They get pushed from studio to studio, shopped around, then suddenly a director or star takes interest in it and a project begins to form.
One can definitely infer once the wheels start moving on a picture (OMG Brad Pitt signed on to do Freakonomics:The Movie!) and word spreads that copycats definitely pop up to try and take some of the action.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by thefool on Friday March 12, 2010 @04:21PM
(#1187831)
This is a better explanation for the movie phenomena.
Probably where something like this occurs more is when people who have had experience working together continue working on parallel projects with similar executions even after parting ways.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by muhfuhkuh on Friday March 12, 2010 @04:06PM
(#1187798)
"so either the directors and studios were in it together on these movies (entirely likely I suppose: I don't know much about the movie industry; if anyone does know why this occurs, I'd be very interested), or one studio got wind of what the other was doing and made a "copy" before the original even came out, or else something much more subtle is going on."
Or, they sit on similarly produced movies for years until such moment as it is economically "sensible" for them to release it. The entertainment industry has done that with dead people (Bernie Mac, Heath Ledger, Michael Jackson, etc.) for a long time. If they see advanced hype from one movie (in the case of Armageddon), they'll release their not-as-good one (Deep Impact, IMO) as an early-bird special to get people in the theater thinking "hey, it's just as good, whatever".
Now, there are companies (like the Asylum) that make films _directly_ knocking off upcoming movies. They shoot and produce them in months and push it straight-to-disc for the rental/retail market. That's a different thing altogether.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by petercooper on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:33PM
(#1187963)
or else something much more subtle is going on.
It's driven me bonkers for the last year but there's a technical term for this (when a combination of external stimuli lead different people to come to similar conclusions and have similar ideas at the same time). I read an interesting Wikipedia article on it a few years back.. yet a good 10 minutes of Googling has failed to bring it back to me.
A recombinant-DNA-inspired "paradigm of paradigms" has been posited, that describes a mechanism of "recombinant conceptualization." This paradigm predicates that a new concept arises through the crossing of pre-existing concepts and facts
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by InclinedPlane on Saturday March 13, 2010 @06:19AM
(#1188810)
There is no mystery here. Movies take a significant amount of time to produce, and they spend a fair amount of time in various pre-production phases as well. As it turns out, the entertainment industry is a fairly small world, just about everybody knows what just about everybody else is doing. If nothing else, movie productions must maintain some degree of publicity in order to attract talent for the cast and crew to work on the movie itself. And in recent years anyone with a subscription to IMDB pro has access to all that information. The fact that often there are movies with highly similar themes that are released in close succession is most likely attributable to nothing more than folks copying what seem to be "hot" ideas of others.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by mixmax on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:15PM
(#1187930)
I spoke to my patent attorney about this some years ago, and he confirmed that this is indeed the case. Very often similar or identical patents are being filed within a very short timeperiod. Alexander Graham Bell and Elisha Grey's filing of the telephone patent is a good example.
They didn't have a name or a cause for it other than pocket philosophy, but it's a generally accepted truth that can be easily observed in their everyday work.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by jdietrich on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:39PM
(#1187749)
Derren says the same thing himself - at the start of every programme he gives a little spiel about what he does being "a combination of magic, showmanship and psychology". Anyone with a basic grasp of magic technique can start to see his use of some very traditional methods.
One of the many brilliant aspects of Derren's performance is how he uses the notion of "psychological manipulation" as misdirection. We as spectators naturally look for an explanation for what we see. Magicians have always sought to provide an explanation for the audience, hence the waving of wands and the use of "magic words". Most of these explanations are deeply unsatisfactory, but Derren's is uniquely compelling.
Most magicians think too much about trying to fool their audience, believing that it is sufficient merely to do something that seems impossible. Derren understands that to engage an audience they must want to believe. Imagine if all magicians really did have the powers that they purport to have. There's nothing particularly exciting about someone who can make sponge balls vanish or candles appear out of thin air, but the ability to control minds is thrilling and dangerous. The imagination overflows with possibility. He performs an illusion that is exciting to watch and gives us an explanation for that illusion which is yet more exciting.
One of the things I keep meaning to write when I get round to starting a blog is a discussion of what UX designers can learn from magicians. I think one of the most important aspects of Apple's design culture is their focus on creating wonder and joy and their use of illusion and misdirection. The reason that the iPad will absolutely tear up personal computing is all in Apple's tagline for it - "a magical and revolutionary product". It's not about features, it's about feelings.
In June 2005, a clip from the second series was widely circulated on the internet. In this clip, Brown claims to have created a video game he calls "Waking Dead" which "is able to put roughly 1/3 of the people who play it into a catatonic trance". In this episode, he places the video game in a pub to lure a supposedly unsuspecting patron into playing the game. He then "kidnaps" the catatonic "victim" and places him in a real-life recreation of the video game, having him fire an air gun at actors, pretending to be zombies and outfitted with explosive squibs.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by eagleal on Friday March 12, 2010 @10:08PM
(#1188378)
If the person suffers from some form of epilepsy, could drop in a state of unconsciousness. From there should be easy to just recreate a similar environment to the previous one (if you find yourself, in a credible place full of zombies, with a gun, you will shoot, instinct).
Video games, offer a good immersion in the story, if played long enough (think of the current military training).
Though, the people in the video linked are just actors (and bad ones). Considered the complexity of organization, I was disappointed in the end: just touch the actor head with his hands, and the actor 'magically' (instantly) calm down, and return to the previous state.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by bgraves on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:31PM
(#1187726)
Thanks for this. I'm a big Derren Brown fan and can't view YouTube due to proxy restrictions. I know exactly which clip this is thanks to your summary.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by ErrantX on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:59PM
(#1187782)
I gather this is the (reasonably old) clip with the logo designers?
Great clip - and I recommend you watch more of Derren Brown. He is by far one of my favorite entertainers because he makes very clear that everything he does is a matter of manipulative psychology and "sleight of hand".
Which makes it all the better because you spend the whole episode trying to figure out how he managed it - and wondering if the solutions (which he often provides) are actually real.
The other great thing about Brown is that he loves debunking pseudo-science and other rubbish. The section in one of his books about Neuro-linguistic programming (NLP) is a fantastically well thought out debunking - he actually tried NLP at one stage in his early career and you can see his fascination with the idea before his final realization it was just pop psychology (his section on religion is equally compelling).
But best of all he pulls some awesome stunts/tricks. Highlights from the past include: playing Russian roulette, live.... (with blanks, but still lethal...) and (my personal favourites) "programming" a group of people to pull off a fake heist and paying for stuff (in the US as it happens) with paper instead of real money.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by proee on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:54PM
(#1188005)
This makes one wonder how much influence major websites are having on designers in general. If a designer is using facebook 10 times a day, will they submliminally add facebook style typography or layout on their next client site?
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by varaon on Friday March 12, 2010 @06:18PM
(#1188065)
In the online real-time strategy game Starcraft, there is a term called the "metagame" that refers to (among other details) the current trends in how the game is played.
There can often be large shifts in the strategies that a majority of players are using. They often start with the professional gamer who first developed it and dominated with it, thus popularizing it. People end up getting exposure from watching the pros play, and also from having the strategy used against them. The more someone loses to a given strategy, the higher they will regard it.
I'm curious if this happens with design trends, as you were saying.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by nazgulnarsil on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:00PM
(#1187634)
marketers are NOT masters of persuasion. there's a selection effect at work that over time the companies best at this sort of thing have triumphed. sure, there's intelligent direction, but lots of effective marketing tools were discovered by accident.
Re:Example of Subliminal Advertising
by wakeupthedawn on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:01PM
(#1187905)
Watch carefully at around 1:15. When the camera comes is shot behind the designers, the envelop is not on the table. It is still in Derren's hand, as it should be. When the camera view switches to the one from behind Derren, the envelope (or whatever that is) is already seen to be on the table. Then it switches back to the view behind the designers, and he has it in his hand again and finally places it on the table. There's lots of other shading editing throughout.
What.. my country, the UK? The country where I have to pay an extortionate TV tax/license every year, part of which goes to fund Channel 4? How comes I can view this through a US-based VPN yet not directly in the UK when the content is from a British TV station I'm paying for?
I was staggered at the practicality of many of their ideas. E.g. I now recognise when someone unwittingly is using hypnotic suggestion in a conversation and it doesn't have the effect it may have. I'm able to pretend to be psychic at parties, and can pull of some pretty good cold reading tricks as well now.
It's worth learning how to do memory palaces just for fun (one of Derren's audiobooks has this, which is a good beginner introduction).
If you don't think he's capable of tricks like this without cutscenes, there are some videos floating around of him performing tricks better than this on other top class magicians which couldn't have been faked. I suspect he claims he's doing illusions because it makes it seem less powerful than it really is, and makes us seem more in control than we really are.
If you want some simple tricks to get into it, just get derrens audio books which are quick and powerful.
http://www.google.com/search?q=derren+brown+audio+books
Instead of working his tricks under the illusion of them being "magic" he pins the workings on pop psychology - he may tell you that he's using subliminal messages posted along the route, and not mention a bunch of coloring books left in the room with similar pictures (for example).
It's a cool video, for sure; but the results are most likely not derived from "subliminal messages".
Deep Impact (May 1998) -> Armageddon (July 1998)
The Illusionist (September 2006) -> The Prestige (October 2006)
Paul Blart: Mall Cop (January 2009) -> Observe and Report (April 2009)
These movies came out too close together for one to copy the other, so either the directors and studios were in it together on these movies (entirely likely I suppose: I don't know much about the movie industry; if anyone does know why this occurs, I'd be very interested), or one studio got wind of what the other was doing and made a "copy" before the original even came out, or else something much more subtle is going on.
In the startup / tech world, I think this happens too, because we all tend to follow the same blogs, news sources, etc – so any subtle (probably unintentional) message that makes one of us think of a new product makes 1000 of us think of a nearly identical product, at the exact same time. To me, that highlights execution is so important, and ideas are a "dime a dozen".
Some of these scripts (actually, most of them) float around Hollywood for years, even a decade or longer. They get pushed from studio to studio, shopped around, then suddenly a director or star takes interest in it and a project begins to form.
One can definitely infer once the wheels start moving on a picture (OMG Brad Pitt signed on to do Freakonomics:The Movie!) and word spreads that copycats definitely pop up to try and take some of the action.
You can also add [A Bug's Life (Nov 1998) -> Antz (Oct 1998)] to your list. There's some background here: http://www.businessweek.com/1998/47/b3605013.htm
Probably where something like this occurs more is when people who have had experience working together continue working on parallel projects with similar executions even after parting ways.
Or, they sit on similarly produced movies for years until such moment as it is economically "sensible" for them to release it. The entertainment industry has done that with dead people (Bernie Mac, Heath Ledger, Michael Jackson, etc.) for a long time. If they see advanced hype from one movie (in the case of Armageddon), they'll release their not-as-good one (Deep Impact, IMO) as an early-bird special to get people in the theater thinking "hey, it's just as good, whatever".
Now, there are companies (like the Asylum) that make films _directly_ knocking off upcoming movies. They shoot and produce them in months and push it straight-to-disc for the rental/retail market. That's a different thing altogether.
It's driven me bonkers for the last year but there's a technical term for this (when a combination of external stimuli lead different people to come to similar conclusions and have similar ideas at the same time). I read an interesting Wikipedia article on it a few years back.. yet a good 10 minutes of Googling has failed to bring it back to me.
Update — I tried again and about 20 searches in found what it might have been: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery .. specifically:
A recombinant-DNA-inspired "paradigm of paradigms" has been posited, that describes a mechanism of "recombinant conceptualization." This paradigm predicates that a new concept arises through the crossing of pre-existing concepts and facts
They didn't have a name or a cause for it other than pocket philosophy, but it's a generally accepted truth that can be easily observed in their everyday work.
(It still could be coincidence I suppose, but it feels like more than that)
http://www.11points.com/Movies/11_Damn_Near_Identical_Movies...
http://www.filmjunk.com/2007/03/07/when-movies-come-in-pairs...
Vampires and Blade (1998) Mighty Joe Young and some other ape movie. Two horror movies with bats. Saving Private Ryan and The Thin Red Line.
It happens over and over again. A semi-biggish movie and another that gets forgotten.
One of the many brilliant aspects of Derren's performance is how he uses the notion of "psychological manipulation" as misdirection. We as spectators naturally look for an explanation for what we see. Magicians have always sought to provide an explanation for the audience, hence the waving of wands and the use of "magic words". Most of these explanations are deeply unsatisfactory, but Derren's is uniquely compelling.
Most magicians think too much about trying to fool their audience, believing that it is sufficient merely to do something that seems impossible. Derren understands that to engage an audience they must want to believe. Imagine if all magicians really did have the powers that they purport to have. There's nothing particularly exciting about someone who can make sponge balls vanish or candles appear out of thin air, but the ability to control minds is thrilling and dangerous. The imagination overflows with possibility. He performs an illusion that is exciting to watch and gives us an explanation for that illusion which is yet more exciting.
One of the things I keep meaning to write when I get round to starting a blog is a discussion of what UX designers can learn from magicians. I think one of the most important aspects of Apple's design culture is their focus on creating wonder and joy and their use of illusion and misdirection. The reason that the iPad will absolutely tear up personal computing is all in Apple's tagline for it - "a magical and revolutionary product". It's not about features, it's about feelings.
a) Guy hires designers to design a logo.
b) Guy feeds designers subliminal messaging on their cab ride to office.
c) Designers build nearly an exact copy of the logos / messaging that the guy implanted.
More about this guy here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derren_Brown
Definitely worth a look.
Here is a description from Wikipedia:
In June 2005, a clip from the second series was widely circulated on the internet. In this clip, Brown claims to have created a video game he calls "Waking Dead" which "is able to put roughly 1/3 of the people who play it into a catatonic trance". In this episode, he places the video game in a pub to lure a supposedly unsuspecting patron into playing the game. He then "kidnaps" the catatonic "victim" and places him in a real-life recreation of the video game, having him fire an air gun at actors, pretending to be zombies and outfitted with explosive squibs.
I'm just not really sure if something like that is ok to do to a random person -- might cause a serious trauma...
Video games, offer a good immersion in the story, if played long enough (think of the current military training).
Though, the people in the video linked are just actors (and bad ones). Considered the complexity of organization, I was disappointed in the end: just touch the actor head with his hands, and the actor 'magically' (instantly) calm down, and return to the previous state.
Great clip - and I recommend you watch more of Derren Brown. He is by far one of my favorite entertainers because he makes very clear that everything he does is a matter of manipulative psychology and "sleight of hand".
Which makes it all the better because you spend the whole episode trying to figure out how he managed it - and wondering if the solutions (which he often provides) are actually real.
The other great thing about Brown is that he loves debunking pseudo-science and other rubbish. The section in one of his books about Neuro-linguistic programming (NLP) is a fantastically well thought out debunking - he actually tried NLP at one stage in his early career and you can see his fascination with the idea before his final realization it was just pop psychology (his section on religion is equally compelling).
But best of all he pulls some awesome stunts/tricks. Highlights from the past include: playing Russian roulette, live.... (with blanks, but still lethal...) and (my personal favourites) "programming" a group of people to pull off a fake heist and paying for stuff (in the US as it happens) with paper instead of real money.
There can often be large shifts in the strategies that a majority of players are using. They often start with the professional gamer who first developed it and dominated with it, thus popularizing it. People end up getting exposure from watching the pros play, and also from having the strategy used against them. The more someone loses to a given strategy, the higher they will regard it.
I'm curious if this happens with design trends, as you were saying.
For more info on the metagame, see http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft/Metagame
After it ended, I watched the first few minutes again... and sure enough, I saw the same stuff once I knew what to look for.