Re:Why you shouldn't share links on Facebook
by ikeboy on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:36AM
(#11868922)
How are HN comments an issue? All comments are public, so what's the concern?
Keeping information in URLs is fine as long as it has enough entropy to be unbruteforcable. Bit.ly and t.co don't, and so aren't secure.
Re:Why you shouldn't share links on Facebook
by starquake on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @04:17AM
(#11907855)
That's exactly my point. Because some users don't understand this technical issue, you shouldn't use personally identifiable information in URLs. They might post it to services with enough entropy. But they also might post it to public parts of the internet.
I use HN comments as an example of an unsafe way to share URLs with personally identifiable information.
But I also think sites should never use personally identifiable information in the URL. There are much more sites that cause issues when sharing these kinds of URLs. To name a few: bit.ly, twitter, Comments in Hacker News.