Re:FarmBot – Open-Source CNC Farming [video]
by snikeris on Tuesday June 07, 2016 @07:54PM
(#11859016)
> Why should lots of microfarms produce less food, than one "macrofarm" of the same size?
Re:FarmBot – Open-Source CNC Farming [video]
by hutzlibu on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @05:21AM
(#11860998)
But the amount of sun shining on the same size of land is exactly the same - no matter how small you splitt it up.
Re:FarmBot – Open-Source CNC Farming [video]
by snikeris on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @03:43PM
(#11865027)
The macrofarm will be able to afford innovations before each microfarm will. Suppose a tool is developed that harvests vegetables better than existing methods. Let's say it's less likely to crush the vegetable it's picking. It's new technology so it's expensive, but if you're operating at a large enough scale, it might be worth the cost.
In this case, each microfarm will produce less vegetables than a macrofarm of the same size.
I wasn't trying to be a jerk by linking to the Wikipedia article. It seemed to me like you weren't familiar with the concept.
Re:FarmBot – Open-Source CNC Farming [video]
by hutzlibu on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:26AM
(#11868669)
> It seemed to me like you weren't familiar with the concept
And you seem to me, like you were not familiar with the topic being discussed:
output of the same amount of land, no matter the required work (because of robots)
So, nevermind ;)
Re:FarmBot – Open-Source CNC Farming [video]
by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:18PM
(#11879663)
The problem isn't the potential output of the land; it's that the costs go up rapidly. With a very large field a traditional tractor/plow/disk/seeder/cultivator can do a lot of work in a short amount of time. If the field is now 1/100 the size, the "tractor" (robot, etc.) and its implements don't cost 1/100 as much. They may only cost 1/5 as much, so your costs are now 20x what they would otherwise have been for the proportional output.
I think that's the point he was trying to make.
So I don't see much precision with the use of pesticides on large scale and never heard of a way to prevent them from going into the groundwater. (oh and I know a little bit about the ways how it gets decided, what chemicals get labeled as "harmless")
Oh and explain this:
> Microfarms are unsustainable. They don't grow nearly enough food
Why should lots of microfarms produce less food, than one "macrofarm" of the same size?
Doing those things on a big scale only reduces required labour -> that's why I want robots.
But it is true, that bio, if you meant that, can't produce as much per field, as a monoculture field, no matter the size - but with a monoculture, poisened field, you only get food and destroyed everything else - with a bio field, you get food and intact nature with diversity, clean water and soil ... all in all a place where you want to be. So all in all you get much more from the land if you grow Bio.