As an example, heading East out of London the motorway is often heavy with speed cameras and often police cars (poorer end of London) . Heading West into the Cotswolds (the rich area) , there are few cameras and a high level of very fast speeding. But if you looked at a study it would appear that those from the 'poorer' areas committed more 'speed crime' as those are the only areas we are effectively policing.
I wonder if those looking for cheating also start from the position that foreign pupils are more likely to cheat and therefore spend more time looking for cheating?
Where I went to school, for each CS course (eg algos 201, 301, etc) all programming homework was submitted with a department run submission utility. After submission, all programs for all time were compared for cheating. My guess is they did some basic comparisons of the AST.
The CS department produced well over 10x the cases of academic fraud as the rest of the college. We got lectured each and every semester about it. There were even locked disposal boxes in the CS labs to dispose of printouts; I got busted for cheating one semester because someone had stolen a printout I'd used to figure out bugs in an algorithm and copied the code! Fortunately, the other student had been caught cheating repeatedly and his programs regularly failed to work while I'd never come close and my program worked. The professor gave me the benefit of the doubt.
However, do I really believe CS produced 10x the cheaters? Of course not. They were just easier to detect.
That said, I was stunned at the amount of cheating in graduate courses. One professor teaching math stats was in the habit of posting distributions for each question on the tests. For a particular question, the distribution was bimodal -- I was one of two people in the middle, and the rest of the ~30 students got nearly 0 points or full credit. The question rested on a really neat integral trick, but if you didn't see it (on a timed test), or used the obvious substitution, it was about two pages of work. If you saw the trick, the problem fell apart.
I had been helping one of the students who got full credit for that question with her homework and her calculus was not her strong point. There were ex-physics students in the class who had won integration contests and I kind of expected them to get a trick like this, but not her. So I privately asked her how the hell she got that question. It turned out she had already seen the test -- the 15-ish Chinese kids in my class passed tests down between years, and the professor just twiddled numbers in them instead of rewriting tests. My solution, since I was graded on a curve with them, was to make sure I got to see the tests too. I'm not really sure if I'm proud of that, but you can't be graded on a curve when half the class sees the tests ahead of time.
http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2015/02/16/study-finds-invest...
http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html
http://www.theguardian.com/money/2009/oct/18/racism-discrimi...
And again that is 5x more discovered cheating, what number of cheating occurred undiscovered for all groups? I'm not saying people don't cheat, because they do, I'm saying look at the environment to understand what other impacts on the number might occur.
So if you are going to argue the point that there is bias against foreign-sounding names, enough bias to explain a 5x gap, you'll need more than roundabout inference and implication. Extraordinary evidence means direct evidence, not links to employment-related articles.
That sounds completely implausible. For instance:
For example:
https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2013/...
http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/8078586.html - 1) If a black person and a white person each commit a crime, the black person is more likely to be arrested. This is due in part to the fact that black people are more heavily policed.
http://blogs.channel4.com/factcheck/factcheck-black-american...
Some communities have bars on their windows and others leave their doors unlocked.
Are you really making a case that the reason students don't cheat is fear of getting caught? Is there no room for students who don't cheat because:
1. they actually want to learn the material
2. don't need to cheat because they learned the material
3. have personal honor and integrity - would rather flunk out than be a cheat
4. want to earn the degree with pride
?
#3 and #4 are also pretty much the same thing. Yes some people have academic integrity, others make up for it with integrity in other parts of life (so they still get good feelies about themselves), some people only value winning, some people are lazy, some people just can't cut it and the costs are too high to fail with integrity. All to say it exists, but I don't think this would be a big group if cheating were allowed, even if grades weren't on a curve and other complications were ironed out.
English skill is an obvious one the article talks about, but along with that comes an understanding of what is likely to get caught by a professor. In other words, domestic students don't cheat as much not because they believe in norms against cheating but rather because they understand better that they will probably get caught, or they understand better how not to get caught (so they don't get caught).
The article discusses incentives as well — the risk of getting sent back to China and never coming back — but fails to consider that that risk is precisely what might make getting good grades more important for foreign students than domestic ones.
What I'm describing could be seen as a difference in cultural norms too, but there's a huge gap between not believing that you're cheating and not knowing how cheaters in America get caught.