News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by dang on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:29PM (#11844282)
Please keep nationalistic grandstanding off HN. We don't want this kind of flamewar here, and HN's many Indian readers have a right (as does anyone else) not to see their country insulted on this site.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by sudoscript on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:19PM (#11844446)
EDIT: Looks like the comment in question was about India being better off under the British. Which probably deserves deletion. Leaving my comment for posterity but nothing to worry about here.

I'm sorry, but I feel like the comment from OP does have a place in this discussion, given the context of the article. I agree it could have been worded in better ways, but an argument that India's bureaucracy is corrupt is not a groundless insult nor completely irrelevant to the article here. I'm not sure how closely you follow Indian politics but I'd refer you to the last national election and the emergence of the Aam Admi Party, both driven in large part by popular frustration at pervasive bureaucratic corruption (eg how telecom spectrum was awarded by the previous administration). In fact, it'd be hard to argue that India's bureaucracy doesn't have a history of bribery to some degree, especially in cases when it comes to regulators and companies.

Again, I think OP could have done a better job phrasing his point, perhaps pointing out how regulation unfavorable to Apple actually might point to less tolerance of corruption at high levels. But I think simply censoring dicscussion of corruption as nationalistic grandstanding is heavy-handed. In other contexts, making comments about political lobbying in the US as corruption would not be considered nationalistic. I don't see why it should be here either.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by parennoob on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:38PM (#11844497)
I don't think it was the first statement that led to the flagging, but the second one.

Anyone who thinks "India was better off under British rule" needs to read about the Bengal Famine that killed 3 million people from Bengal [1] -- a direct result of Churchill's basic idea that Indian lives were worth less than others [2]. This is not to mention the numerous previous atrocities, such as the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre [3], in which a garden was blocked off and troops ordered to fire into a massed crowd until their ammunition was exhausted.

I am usually not one to dust off the history books, but in my opinion, people who perpetrate this "Things were great under the British" meme (including pmarca) need at least some amount of education, and perhaps a little more empathy. Indians were absolutely considered as an inferior, secondary class by the British, and the lack of a few Apple stores is a small price to pay for avoiding that.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943

[2] http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/soutikbiswas/2010/10...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jallianwala_Bagh_massacre

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by sudoscript on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:42PM (#11844509)
Ah my mistake. I thought dangs reply was in response to the top level comment. Yeah this is pretty unwarranted.

Editing my comment to reflect my mistake. Thanks.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by vinaybn on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:12PM (#11844423)
Indian here and I'm sure that I, nor anyone else, has any such right that you speak of.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by simula67 on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:14AM (#11844619)
Fellow Indian here, I must agree with you. But I can understand dang's point of view. He is trying to be polite.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by dang on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:05AM (#11844776)
Well, we don't need a doctrine of rights to know that such comments are profoundly destructive of civil discourse on HN, which is the reason they don't belong here.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by themartorana on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:35PM (#11844303)
It's a joke: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-02-10/marc-andre...

Edit: at least I think it is.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by dang on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:51PM (#11844350)
I don't think it was a joke.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by falsestprophet on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:37PM (#11844308)
Does that apply to United States readers?

There are certainly many criticisms of or insults to our country that a lot of our countrymen would prefer to not see.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by dang on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:55PM (#11844358)
Sure it does. I don't think the bar can be "prefer not to see", since most people prefer not to see things that they disagree with. But if a comment is substanceless enough to be an outright national slur, we'd react the same way (and have indeed done so).
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by newyork on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:09PM (#11844216)
FYI: India went from 27% of world income to 3% under colonial rule
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:33PM (#11844295)
Source/context? There was no such thing as "India" before colonial rule. The idea of India as a cohesive entity is a colonial and post-colonial innovation.

Hinduism was never even a cohesive entity before British rule, it was the orientalist scholars that classified it based on many similar belief systems. http://www.e-ir.info/2012/11/26/the-impact-of-european-colon...

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:27PM (#11844475)
I seem to have ticked some people off with that statement, but it's factual. The idea of "India" as a nation just didn't exist. To say that the "income" (whatever that means) of India changed under colonization is incoherent without context.

That's not the same as saying that the people in what is now India didn't exist or share many of the same traditions and cultures, but it was not a cohesive unit, let alone a nation with a national identity.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:49PM (#11844528)
I don't know why some people are so hell bent on denying India an identity. India as a nation has existed for a loonng time. Vedas are ancient (everybody would agree) and they refer to India (Bharat) as the nation which extends from Himalayas to the sea (just like it is today). What arguments do you have against that?

"The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhāratam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharata_(emperor)

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:53PM (#11844542)
Read the link in my first post above. Your claim would be the same as saying that "Christendom" was a nation during the middle ages and that the EU has always existed as an identity.

It's a region with many shared traditions and at some times has had large swaths governed by warlords, kings, conquerors, but the concept of India as a nation just did not exist pre-colonialism. I don't see how that's denying anybody identity.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:41AM (#11844706)
That's a very very misinformed opinion. This seems to be a popular theme that British made India. Somehow Britishers conquering large swaths of India gave it an identity but not for the earlier rulers. You should read the Arabic and Chinese accounts of India if the Indian accounts are only "holy books" and thus not to be trusted. The Arabs (they called it Hindustan) and the Chinese both recognise the Indian nation.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:03AM (#11844578)
So you are arguing against Vedas based on a student submission for a university degree?
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:11AM (#11844603)
Where am I arguing against "the Vedas" and what does that even mean?

The (well cited and researched) paper I linked above mentions how old the Vedas are. However, they are holy books and mythology, not historical documents. A description of a region in a holy book is not as a identity or cohesiveness as a cultural or political entity.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:37AM (#11844695)
King Bharata is as much mythology as king Arthur. The "well researched" paper is a student submission. Have you read any other research that argues for the opposite? I am on mobile, will search and link a few later.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:06AM (#11844781)
There's a pretty long list of citations at the bottom of that paper and the sample of them that I could be bothered to check for an internet article were legit. If you have any arguments against the thesis of that paper other than ad hominem I'd love to hear them.

I'm hardly a scholar of Indian history, I just did a bunch of reading during the two months I recently spent traveling the country from south to north. That was one of the articles that popped up when I was trying to find any decent information on the caste system and it's very well written and argued (and, like I said, the citations check out).

It seems to me though that the area was wildly diverse and hardly a unified entity before the Brits came along. I mean, what about Pakistan? That's not part of India. But that's only as of 75 or so years ago? Is that counted in these "national income" totals that the original parent poster was talking about? That was my original quibble with what the hell the guy meant by his statement and the historical existence of India as a nation. (A nation being a modern concept anyway, which was also at the heart of my quibble.)

Anyway, as to the analogy with Arthurian mythology, that's a good one. The area that King Arthur purportedly ruled was Britain, Ireland, Norway, and Gaul. Is that all Britain or . . . ? See the problem with that line of reasoning?

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:40AM (#11844874)
Alright, I took the bait. I read through the paper and it seems it heavily depends on Vedas for some of it's arguments. So your point about not considering Vedas as credible evidence doesn't stand. The paper doesn't comment anything (at least conclusively) about the Indian nation. The paper is about caste system.

Some of your queries might be answered here http://sankrant.org/2003/10/why-india-is-a-nation/

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by weeksie on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:03AM (#11845115)
That's a shame. You didn't even read the link you were arguing the validity of until now? I still don't think you read it since you've just quoted the thesis but not referenced the notion that the idea even of "Hindu" identity just didn't exist, even though the people in the region shared many of the same texts. That's not the same as claiming that the belief systems didn't exist, or that they weren't widely similar, but that they weren't a cohesive unit.

The blog post you linked me to just reinforces my point about nationhood if you'd have been paying much attention to my posts instead of getting defensive about "Indian identity" or whatever.

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:28AM (#11845188)
I am an Indian, do I need to read a foreign paper to know about my own nation?

You are confusing two different topics, we are not discussing the concept "Hindu", we are discussing whether there was an entity "India". The paper you linked says nothing about that. I have told you how the concept of India is very old using the citations in your cited paper. The blog post I linked proves my point so I don't know what you are talking about.

What do I have to be defensive about? Do you think I have identity crisis because some random person on the internet has some beliefs? lol

Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by eklavya on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:34AM (#11844680)
You seem to have changed the whole comment since I replied.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:16PM (#11844237)
This would be a much more compelling point if I thought world income had stayed constant while India was under British colonial rule.
Re:The trials and tribulations of doing business in India by droom on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:00PM (#11844191)
Have you heard of the Bengal famine?