Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American
by dclowd9901 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:18PM
(#11838693)
My mistake. Still, I think it should be a flat UBI. The point shouldn't be to supplement income but to be income. Plus I think, politically it's a harder sell to provide levels is support ("WE DONT GET AS MUCH BECAUSE WE'RE SUCCESSFUL THATS BULLSHIT", etc.)
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American
by maxerickson on Saturday June 04, 2016 @05:02PM
(#11838015)
It would be really dumb to stack the taper on top of existing tax rates.
Which I guess doesn't mean it wouldn't happen.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American
by sokoloff on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:07PM
(#11838641)
There's a 3.8% Obamacare surtax on investment income that adds onto the top bracket starting at $250K.
> I agree that the UBI should be flat, because anything else is equivalent to changing our tax brackets; and if we want to do that, we should just change our tax brackets.
This was such a dumb sentence in an otherwise interesting post.
The current marginal tax rate for someone (unmarried) making between 37k and 91k is 25% [0]
This means that over this $30k interval, people would be facing about a 46% effective marginal tax [1]. The current top bracket is only 39.6% and does not kick in (for unmarried individuals) until $415k.
While this proposal does create a silly marginal tax rate, it is still below 100%, which means that making more income still leads to more money in your pocket. Our current system, if you count the value of non-monotary aid, often exceeds a marginal rate of 100%, which is a far more serious problem.
I agree that the UBI should be flat, because anything else is equivalent to changing our tax brackets; and if we want to do that, we should just change our tax brackets.
[0] https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-15-53.pdf
[1] This number might be slightly different if the two taxes interact with each other.