News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by Tycho on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:24PM (#11837827)
But it might create even bigger disincentives that have a much more universal effect, which could be disasterous.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by leereeves on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:27PM (#11837837)
There are good reasons to think it won't.

People continue to work after they have enough money not to; people making $40K per year go to night school to try to increase their income.

Most people continue to want more after their basic needs are met.

And beyond money, work can give a sense of purpose and a connection to other people.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by Tycho on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:42PM (#11837909)
But we're not talking about 'most' people. We're talking about all people. What about the people who think to themselves, I don't want to work, I want to live off welfare. Now there will be more of those people (especially since technology satisfies more and more leisure needs for just the price of an internet connection). Also as people grow up in such a society, they don't have that driving motive in the back of their mind that if they have to eventually find employment to survive. How will such people turn out as adults?

The promise of UBI is saving money and unlocking more human potential (by allowing more risk taking, or letting artists pursue their art, or whatever). But if you think of the need to be productive (for survival) as a force/pressure that has shaped the complex system we call society since the dawn of civilisation, then I can imagine that removing that force in a large nation could result in something extremely dysfunctional or even horrifying.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by leereeves on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:54PM (#11837976)
> But if you think of the need to be productive (for survival) as a force/pressure that has shaped...

That's why UBI is only now becoming a possibility.

The need for everyone to be productive is diminishing. The labor force participation rate has dropped enormously since 2000.

https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CIVPART

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by sambe on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:55PM (#11837987)
I would expect them to get bored and find something interesting to do. Could be quite a positive. Regardless, most existing small studies and surveys show few people behave like this or intend to.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by Tycho on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:34PM (#11838489)
I worry that the small studies and surveys tell us nothing about the real dangers - from interaction and scale effects in a complex system.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by maxerickson on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:29PM (#11837847)
It would be trivial to implement it slowly and dial it back if you saw adverse outcomes. Giving everyone $20 next year probably wouldn't destroy America.

(of course a slow implementation would have to overlap with existing benefits, not replace them)

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by bkeroack on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:36PM (#11837880)
The people who are likely to drop out of the labor market are almost certainly not the motivated, high-productivity workers that actually benefit society. High achievers tend to be motivated by things like passion, creativity, need for recognition, etc, not purely income.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by JorgeGT on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:42PM (#11837910)
> The people who are likely to drop out of the labor market are almost certainly not the motivated, high-productivity workers that actually benefit society

The people who are likely to drop out of their job are plumbers, dishwashers, garbage collectors, miners, mail carriers, highway maintainers, taxi drivers, manual fruit pickers and the rest of those performing soul-crushing jobs that actually allow society to keep running.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by trbvm2 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @05:40PM (#11838221)
All solvable problems though, no? If no one has to wash dishes in order to survive then you will have to offer a quite decent wage to get people to wash dishes else pay someone to finally make the washing of dishes completely automated. Supply and demand should dictate that the worst issue will end up being the rising cost of having a night on the town.

Same thing for any other currently low value jobs. We will have to adjust to paying people properly, even above minimum wage, to do things that suck. I view this as a desirable outcome when considered against the current situation in which only the most glamorous jobs tend to pay well, even if the job is not necessarily most helpful.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by adynatos on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:39AM (#11840154)
so a minimum wage? great, so i'll pay half the dishwashers twice the previous wage for twice the work. or, if automation is possible, i'll pay one guy a minimum wage to look after dozens of dishwashing machines. result is less people working.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dllthomas on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:53AM (#11840186)
Not quite the same as a minimum wage. It's not enforced by bureaucrats, but by potential employees each individually deciding they have better uses for their time to do the work you're asking for the price you're offering.

If your workers are willing and able to do twice as much work in the same time for twice as much pay, you should likely make that switch anyway - at the least it'd save you bookkeeping, and it would be a better use of the workers' time.

And if people systematically decide that they have better things to do than a particular job, and we automate that job so we don't need people doing it, that seems like a win to me.

Whether it means less people working overall depends on how big these effects are, what the effects are on demand, and whether we couple it with other changes like a decreased minimum wage (which could lead to more people working on things which are more pleasant/fulfilling but less highly paid).

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by greedo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @10:02PM (#11839275)
Can't really lump plumbers in that group; they're very well compensated, and I wouldn't describe their jobs as soul-crushing. There are a lot of trade jobs that won't be easily automated; plumbing, electricians, welders, landscapers (it's really an art) etc.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by ericd on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:40PM (#11837899)
13k is still poverty level, I imagine most would not be fully content at that level.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by pkaye on Sunday June 05, 2016 @01:13AM (#11839726)
That is why it is called basic income and not deluxe income. The goal is to put food on the table and a roof over your head.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by ericd on Sunday June 05, 2016 @07:09PM (#11843639)
Heh yep, I know, I was just trying to explain why I don't think it's going to suddenly cause everyone to stop working.