Re:Becoming a Professor
by mathattack on Friday June 03, 2016 @08:39AM
(#11829951)
If someone is talented enough, schools will bend the rules on credentials. You can't do it "on the way up", you have to be "already there." I suspect that a school out there would be willing to triple his salary, and Mr. Ito could walk with faculty and corporate contracts and rebuild the Media Lab somewhere else. This is a small price to pay to keep him.
This is perhaps also made a little easier based on the field. In the arts, faculty members do get by without Phds a little more often than in science. Sometimes an MFA is enough.
If he had written it in the same spirit as your excellent comment, of course it wouldn't have been a problem. Indeed you've done a fine job of turning it into something interesting (but note that you did it by depersonalizing).
But what he actually posted was a snarky drive-by smear. This doesn't strike me as a difficult distinction.
I wasn't faulting your reaction ... but I was looking for the best in his/her question rather than assuming it was a baseless attack. I like to play devil's advocate but even without personal attacks, that can be dangerous around here. When your handle is "untilHellbanned" people might perceive you to be trolling by default.
I'm also interested in the other half of the question - what made the MIT selection committee willing to promote an uncredentialed candidate - that's a gutsy move in a university environment as faculty are very protective of the status of their group.