If instead you define art as the communication of things that can't be fully expressed by direct sterile language, that's something I can get behind. Going that route, I think that getting AI to create real art has some pretty clear challenges, but there are also ways whers I could see it being better than humans.
Depending on how the AI learns and analyzes it has a chance to have a unique perspective on human communication. From there, it can find new and innovative ways of identifying gaps between primal human experiences and sterile human communication - and with a unique understanding of human communication could come up with fascinating ways of bridging those gaps.
This is all spitballing, but I think AI could eventually be the main new frontier in art.
>If instead you define art as the communication of things that can't be fully expressed by direct sterile language
Reading this, the first thing I thought of was emotion, feeling! So much of that is wrapped up in who we are, in what we are, in our experiences, and in our limitations.
I like spitballing --- and the thought exercise follows:
Lets say tomorrow we have AI, real thinking machines, with the classic 3 laws of Asimov. Lets also assume we have a few of them. Because of what and who they are, is it possible that AI generates something that other AI's consider "art" but that we, as people, do not?
That being said, musicians have been creating machine-assisted composition (sequencer driven, stochastic, etc.) for a long time. I can imagine great art coming from AI, if the composer is there to help "guide the AI tool" in the direction he or she wants. AI as a means to an end, I don't see greatness from that... AI as an instrument, that could be very interesting...
And yes - musicians use accidents both digitally but even in the acoustic world all the time, that suddenly makes for interesting listening. Music has never been 100% human.
And the last point is if you want computers to be able to fabricate the stories themselves, and maybe create output that tells or "exploits" such a story, then yes maybe it isn't a human story, or maybe they can emulate our story, but in the end we come down to what is consciousness, what is intelligence, and all of this. But if intelligence can be artificial similar to humans, then AI's can in theory create vast and amazingly intricate stories that would be even more fascinating than what a human could come up with.
I'm listening to Boards of Canada and Aphex Twin right now. What about those can't be analyzed and recreated ? There's not complex bowing technique or lyrics to speak of, but it's still relatable, and some I'm sure would say soulful. BoC for certain (by their tone) evoke "nostalgia". Does that qualify as soulful ? Does it seem out of reach of algorithms ?
I think "soul" will have to be better qualified unless its just going to be tautological.
But a machine does not yet have the capacity to lay its finger on the cultural pulse and create something new and slightly different that strikes a resonating cord, pulls people in a new direction, makes them grow, because in addition to having a certain algorithmic description, the music they are making also betrays a certain darkness, a blend of fear, grotesque and dissonance that is there, somewhere down inside us, and that we love despite its ugliness. Until a machine can discover this part of humanity and translate this roiling mass into music, it hasn't managed the same feat as Aphex Twin.
This is what makes music great, that it is born from a place that requires loving observation of humanity. Real creativity requires having insights about humans, representing them in art, and exposing your insight through a particular medium. The image itself, the sound, means nothing. It's the reception, the speaker, the meaning, that matters.
A machine has no place in society. It isn't "straight out of Compton". It CANNOT make music.
James/Aphex said back in 1997 that he was using algocomp for some of his music. :)
This will also help attract young researchers to Tensorflow, so a low cost win for them.
Meaning in music can come from the creator or the listener.
Can code generate a catchy pop tune? Im sure it can. Would I qualify it as music? Probably not.
Music can pull from sources that are EXTERNAL to the music: Heres a modern track that does just such a thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvtNS6hbVy4
Music can have some very non traditional structure that most would qualify as "noise" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYaWND9n9h0
Hell music can even be "silent" http://rosewhitemusic.com/piano/writings/silence-taught-john...
Ultimately, I think that it is possible for a machine to generate music, but were going to be talking about something that is more or less an AI at that point, after all music has a soul.