News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Thursday June 02, 2016 @08:17PM (#11827386)
What would people think if the genders were reversed and this institution was discriminating against women and only helping men? Women have a far larger presence in other fields like biology and education, but you don't see new organizations popping up every other month to change that in favor of men.

Discrimination like this should be illegal.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by parennoob on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:16AM (#11828252)
You have a point. From the article,

“One member, Erica Stanley, had a Masters in Computer Science but felt held back because she wasn’t confident in her skills as a public speaker. WWCode presented her with the opportunity to step up and lead WWCode Atlanta’s programs, including technical events and hackathons.”

I know this sounds a bit glib – but I'm aware of several men (including myself, an Asian person of color) with higher degrees who feel held back because of a lack of confidence as a public speaker. Where are our support groups and opportunities? (Seriously, if you have any, my email is in my profile).

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:28AM (#11828294)
I spent a few years teaching math and I think that made public speaking rather easy for me. If you're looking for a supportive group to help improve your public speaking skills then I recommend you checkout your local toastmasters group. I've not attended myself, but I've heard from several members that it was life changing for them. Just like most every other group, they don't discriminate based on race or gender - so you should be very welcome.

If there's a technology you really like working with, then you might want to look on meetup.com to see if you can find some like minded people and look for an opportunity to present something. Some of the meetup.com groups discriminate based on gender or race, but the vast majority do not and are very welcoming :)

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nekitamo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @08:42PM (#11839042)
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Thursday June 02, 2016 @08:23PM (#11827426)
The reason women dominate in certain fields is that those fields were generally seen as less important, so women were pushed into them. E.g., doctors were men, women were nurses, and there was an enormous pay and prestige difference between the two. (Hint: it did not favor the nurses.)

If you're interested in learning more, researching "pink ghetto" will get you started.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by HarshTruth on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:33AM (#11828316)
Its actually the other way around. Men face more pressure to earn a higher income than women, so more men enter higher paying careers.

1. Women prefer to marry a guy who makes more money than her. So there is significant sexual pressure to become a high status ($) man.

2. Men (statistically) can't marry up large income gaps. So they know that what ever lifestyle they want, they have to be solely responsible for it.

Women on the other hand have more freedom to do what they desire since men care far less about their partners income, and women have the economic security of being able to marry a higher income partner.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by strictnein on Friday June 03, 2016 @02:23AM (#11828682)
Men also end up working in far more dangerous jobs, which pay more. The gap in workplace accidents and deaths affecting men vs women is staggering. Over 90% of workplace deaths are men.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by arsenide on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:06AM (#11829153)
"Men face more pressure to earn a higher income than women, so more men enter higher paying careers."

Citation?

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @11:00AM (#11830691)
That sounds good, but, it's mainly retrograde sexist bunk. It also ignores the long history of women fighting for access to those professions and being actively denied.

Which you presumably know as well, which is why you created a new, anonymous account rather than owning your words.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by brighteyes on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:41PM (#11828144)
That is a theory that can explain some fields. However, so many exceptions exist that it can't be the whole story. For example, women dominate

* Clinical psychology

* Veterinary medicine

* Biology

All of which are important, fulfilling, well-paying fields. In all of them it's hard to say women were "pushed" there, rather women were very interested in them, and arrived in larger numbers than men.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @11:11AM (#11830762)
I don't recall saying it was the whole story. It's a big world. I'm just telling the "OMG discrimination" guy that it's important to understand the history.

But if you'd like to claim those as important exceptions, you'd have to show that those fields are important and well-paying relative to other options available to those women.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by MollyR on Friday June 03, 2016 @10:04AM (#11830346)
This is a little weird comment to me. I have lots of friends who are nurses that make 90k and higher on the east cost, and have way more prestige,class, respect from other people than me a software engineer.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @11:27AM (#11830857)
Ok?

I am not denying that, but I'm not seeing how it's connected to me telling the "OMG helping women is sexism" guy that there's a history here that he should pay attention to.

In particular, the historical comparator to nurses isn't software engineers, it's doctors. Take a look at the gender distribution of medical school graduates:

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_otfwl2zc6Qc/SwyK7qFvLaI/AAAAAAAAL_...

You can see it take off with Title IX, which banned outright institutional discrimination by gender.

A lot of women with interest in and talent for medicine who wanted to become doctors instead became nurses, which fed that historical imbalance. We've fixed the schooling, but we're still working on the outcome; the gender distribution of doctors is still not great: 66% male in the US.

So when this guy whines that there are no organizations helping men become nurses, my reply is that the reason women have historically dominated that field is not anti-male barriers to dudes who really want to be nurses, but previous anti-female barriers in the higher-status profession of doctors (and other things they could have done).

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by MollyR on Friday June 03, 2016 @11:41AM (#11830948)
Why do we have to work on the equality of outcome ? Isn't equality of opportunity enough ?

My friends who are nurses wanted to be nurses, they didn't want to go medical school. They didn't want to wait to make money until their 30's, they considered career paths in relation to having a family. As long as they had the option, I don't see why forcing outcome is important here.

As for helping men into nursing, if diversity is good in one field its probably helpful in another. Men might want a male nurse who can emphasize with male concerns. Being a woman, I'm just taking guesses here, like prostate issues, balding, infertility, and whatever else.

Maybe we should help men get into fields like nursing and teaching. So boys and girls both have role models in lots of fields.

I get the historical context, but I don't think forcing an over reaction in the other direction is better. I think we all benefit from choices and freedom.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @03:06PM (#11832455)
We don't have to force an equality of outcome. But it behooves us to be suspicious when the outcomes aren't equal. For centuries we had unequal outcomes in terms of doctor gender; one defense was "women don't want to be doctors". But when we finally removed the barriers, we see medical school admissions run about equal.

I'm all for men going into nursing. You can work on shifting that ratio if you like. But I'm not personally going to work on that because I don't think it is a result of oppression in the same way that keeping women out of medicine was.

I'm also fine with a little bit of what looks like overreaction in the moment, because that's how we find out where the balance is. People thought Title IX was an overreaction at the time, too.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by thomasatethose on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:33PM (#11833419)
Two wrongs don't make a right. All throughout history rich men AND WOMEN of all races, colors and creed tortured the poor.

The real issue isn't color, or gender. Its Class.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:05PM (#11833875)
I disagree with your notion that in all the world there is only one real issue.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by thomasatethose on Friday June 03, 2016 @09:29PM (#11834452)
well that's fair.

but why do you think the over reaction is ok, which punishes innocent people not the people who created the system.

again two wrongs don't make a right, all it does is continue a negative cycle.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Friday June 03, 2016 @10:53PM (#11834706)
The people who created the system are dead. But the people who benefit from the broken system are still alive. (I am one of them.) And pushing the system toward fairness is not actually punishing them.

Loss of privilege feels is definitely experienced as loss, so I can see why people would see it as punishment. Note all the rich people who cry rivers over having to pay their fair share or taxes. But reducing injustice is not punishment.

Two wrongs don't make a right. But allowing a harmful system to persevere is what continues the negative cycle.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by thomasatethose on Saturday June 04, 2016 @10:36AM (#11836475)
I struggle to make a living,and I am a human being too. just because you made it doesn't mean we all have that middle upper class male privilege. The harmful system is not pursuing equality the right way. As you phrase you views, I have Less sympathy to help women because its clear this is not about equality,and I know I'm not the only one.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by wpietri on Saturday June 04, 2016 @01:45PM (#11837161)
What I am after is equality. I just think to do that we have to acknowledge the historical situation in which a lot of the inequality is rooted. (And I'll note that I didn't have "upper class privilege", just white and male privilege.)

If you decline to have sympathy for other downtrodden people, I believe that's your problem, and I don't think blaming me will help.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by reednj on Thursday June 02, 2016 @08:30PM (#11827462)
80% of people working in PR are women. Is that a pink ghetto as well?
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by gaylemcd on Thursday June 02, 2016 @09:07PM (#11827611)
And PR is not very well paid.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by dopamean on Thursday June 02, 2016 @08:59PM (#11827575)
Definitely.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by gaylemcd on Thursday June 02, 2016 @09:09PM (#11827624)
So you mean if you totally changed the context? Gee, for this completely different situation that really has little to do with this one, yes people would be offended.

But, you know, the context and implications are so completely different. What's your point?

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by imaginenore on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:15PM (#11827840)
Reversing the genders is not totally changing the context. It just shows that it is discrimination based on gender.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by deciplex on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:33PM (#11827903)
Unfortunately fighting discrimination purely by working to eliminate instances of it and revert to a gender-neutral (or race-neutral, or sexual orientation-neutral, etc) method of operation does not work. You must counter discrimination by elevating the oppressed group i.e. giving them privileges the already-privileged group does not possess. This is the basis of affirmative action, for example. It works because we care first and foremost about the net privilege one group possesses over the other, not that they have one particular privilege that another group does not (though obviously the long-term goal is to eliminate that as well). And, in case you were not aware, there remains a significant "privilege gap" between the genders and it is in favor of men. Once that gap no longer exists, we can talk about rolling back these programs.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:59PM (#11828205)
What if the "privilege" you think you see is actually a difference in average ability or preferences between groups of people that are in fact different from each other?

Affirmative action does not help the groups it is directed towards, it simply handicaps them further by preventing them from being properly matched to their level or ability.

Clarence Thomas recently wrote about this in detail... Slaveholders argued that slavery was a ‘positive good’ that civilized blacks and elevated them in every dimension of life. A century later, segregationists similarly asserted that segregation was not only benign, but good for black students. Although cloaked in good intentions, the University’s racial tinkering harms the very people it claims to be helping

If you'd like to learn about the unfortunate real outcomes of affirmative action then I strongly recommend researching Clarence Thomas and Thomas Sowell.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by deciplex on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:29AM (#11828303)
Promoting university enrollment for disadvantaged students really, like fucking really, is not the same as enslaving them. Likewise segregation was bad for a host of reasons among which was social isolation and misappropriation of resources (i.e. whites-only schools were well-funded while blacks-only schools were left to languish), both of which affirmative action is designed to remedy (and objectively does remedy based on fifty years studying the effects of these policies).

Clarence Thomas is a pretty shitty Justice tbh. Recommendation rejected.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by greggman on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:12AM (#11828995)
There was an interesting Intelligence Squared US on Affirmative Action

http://intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/past-debates/item/1...

The side arguing against affirmative action basically claimed they're for the idea of fixing the inequalities but that affirmative action with colleges is actually a net negative. In other words it's not making things more equal it's making them worse.

Their argument was basically that most kids inserted into top schools by affirmative action fail because they aren't at the level of the other students. Because they fail they don't become the things we want them to be come (doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc) and so the circle of inequality continues.

Where as if instead they went to a school with more students at the same level they'd more likely graduate, get the good jobs, and their kids would then make it to the high end schools. A win-win.

I don't know if it's true or not. They claimed to have lots of studies to back them up. But regardless it was interesting food for thought.

I'd love to have a more diverse workplace both in race and sex. I don't know the best way to get there.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:48AM (#11828385)
But isolating/segregating with women-only groups like this is good?

I hope your dislike of Justice Thomas is just because you don't agree with his politics. I think your use of profanity is inappropriate regardless of your reasoning.

Perhaps you would like economist Thomas Sowell better. Or perhaps you're unwilling to give honest consideration to other views.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by deciplex on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:02AM (#11828424)
Nice subtle accusation of racism, person-who-literally-thinks-that-some-races-are-inferior-to-others.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:20AM (#11828494)
You have that backwards. If you don't believe that some races are inferior then there are no reasons for things like affirmative action.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by dragonwriter on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:29PM (#11833031)
> If you don't believe that some races are inferior then there are no reasons for things like affirmative action.

"affirmative action" is short for "affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed, and that employees are treated during employment, without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin".

Please explain how belief that some races are inferior is necessary to the belief that affirmative action is necessary. (Affirmative action often includes action directed specifically at addressing ways in which processes which might superficially seem neutral are, in effect, taking race indirectly into account because of circumstances resulting from the material effects of past discrimination and segregation, but that's a disadvantage of circumstance, not inherent inferiority.)

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:52PM (#11833549)
Affirmative action sets a lower barrier to entry for people of certain races, or it establishes quotas around certain races. This is to say that they cannot be held to the same standard of merit and expect a proportional outcome to something like admission to a particular college.

> without regard to their race, creed, color...

Affirmative action does the very thing it purports to ensure against, by discriminating on the bases of race.

If you believe that one race is inferior in some way and cannot compete on a level playing field then you may feel that affirmative action is necessary to give them a greater advantage. You mentioned circumstances which basically form an inferiority from past accrued disadvantage (I know you called it disadvantage of circumstance, but try to follow me for a moment). This doesn't seem to be the case with affirmative action admissions programs because they lower the bar for Blacks and raise the bar for Asians. Sure Blacks, were treated worst than Asians throughout most of American history, but Whites were not treated better than Asians.

Often the greatest beneficiaries of these programs are not native born African Americans, but recent African immigrants whose ancestors were not enslaved in the US, and not subject to past discrimination and segregation.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/07/nyregion/long-island-high-...

http://nypost.com/2015/04/05/meet-the-student-accepted-into-...

Incidentally, the two cases above would make good counterpoints to the idea of racial intellectual inferiority regardless of affirmative action and would likely have been able to gain admissions to a top university without it. But the unfortunate consequence of affirmative action is that many people will assume it is all because of their special treatment. Clarence Thomas had much more difficult obstacles to overcome, and he was subjected to this unfortunate assumption after graduating from law school.

I think the real intention of affirmative action is to achieve more equal outcomes across racial divides. I think that's a good objective. But I also think this is a policy that sounds much better than it actually works. If we're to have more equal outcomes, then we need more equal opportunities and we need an end to all forms of discrimination.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by deciplex on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:40AM (#11828563)
I already laid out the case for affirmative action which has nothing to do with any inherent racial ability whatsoever. Your reply:

> What if the "privilege" you think you see is actually a difference in average ability or preferences between groups of people that are in fact different from each other?

...is the textbook definition of racism (and sexism). Moreover it criticizes affirmative action precisely on the basis that there are inherent differences of ability among different groups, by race or gender, etc.

Initially I gave you the benefit of the doubt, assuming for the sake of argument and also in the interest of fair discussion that you probably didn't mean what you said, exactly. It is clear now I overestimated you.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:54AM (#11828595)
In case anyone is wondering what the "textbook" definition of racism is:

the belief that "ALL" members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially so as to distinguish it as inferior or superior to another race or races.

The belief that races may be different in average ability with respect to certain characteristics or that members of certain races have their own preferences is not racist. Some people like to use the term racist as some sort of a perverted trump card to silence an opposing view rather than engaging in an actual debate. Good luck trying to have a civil conversation with someone like that.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by deciplex on Friday June 03, 2016 @02:13AM (#11828655)
I refrained from calling you a racist even after you said the obviously racist thing. Moreover you first implied I'm racist out of the blue, because I disagree with a SCOTUS Justice who happens to be black. Also:

> The belief that races may be different in average ability with respect to certain characteristics or that members of certain races have their own preferences is not racist.

Quoting this for posterity in case you try to edit it out later. Sorry for you, I think you'll find the belief that black people are just not "on average" intelligent enough to be enrolled at university in the same proportion as white people, or that women are just too emotional to be in tech, or whatever, are rather unpopular opinions and likely to get you labeled (indeed, correctly) a racist and a sexist. Good luck with that.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by H0n3sty on Friday June 03, 2016 @03:26AM (#11828872)
I'm still trying to decide if you're holding the racism of lower expectation beliefs. Privileged and oppressed are just code words with no clear meaning. I don't know you, so I don't know why you would use profanity to describe Justice Thomas. He has solid principles based on his life's experiences and has had to endure a lot to serve so it makes no sense to me that anyone would describe him that way.

You're probably right about the labels but certainly wrong about the accuracy (thanks for the tip).

I'm not sure why some races perform better at some tasks, on average. I think that Blacks are faster sprinters than Asians, on average. I think that Asians have a higher preference for education than Blacks, on average. I think that the physical characteristics that we describe as races are shaped by evolutionary pressures. Darker skin is likely an adaptation for living closer to the equator. Blacks can probably withstand more direct sun exposure than Whites before developing skin cancer. None of this makes one race superior to another outside the narrow scope of the adaptive characteristic, and even then you only see the differences on average.

I suspect that the lower turnout of women in tech has more to do with preferences around work/life balance and family. But I wouldn't rule out other possible explanations. I've witnessed a few emotional breakdowns at work, but never from men. Which is fortunate because it seems that when men snap they go postal, on average.

> I disagree with a SCOTUS Justice who happens to be black

I like how you phrased that. Much more civil. Do you like George Carlin :D? -> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bRoOOm0-3_8

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by dang on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:21PM (#11832968)
This kind of generic ideological flamewar, as unresolvable as it is tedious, is off topic on HN. Please don't do this again.

It's instructive how you managed to leap from gender to race without skipping a beat. That's an example of what I mean by generic. This is a marker—maybe the primary marker—of low quality discussion. It's always about pre-existing views, held for extraneous reasons, pretending to be a rational response to the story under discussion but reflexively heading straight for one of the same two or three places. A few people insist on taking every discussion there; the rest of us have visited countless times and wish not to return. This community exists for interesting things, of which these ideological back-and-forths are the antithesis.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by jacalata on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:20PM (#11827858)
It is changing the context. I don't know if you know this, but there are a lot of existing gender-based influences in the world already, they aren't inventing the concept.