News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by jfe on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:32PM (#11825776)
i have trouble accepting the idea that fewer women in tech is a problem. it's not that i want to discourage women -- or anyone -- from going into tech. i just don't believe in encouraging anyone to do anything in particular, except what they enjoy. i'd appreciate it if someone can persuade me that the hype is true so i no longer need to feel like a black sheep. but..

for one, the fact that there are fewer women than men in any field, computing or otherwise, is neither good nor bad. the disproportionate number of women in nursing is not seen as a problem, but somehow it has become one in tech.

two, as we flood more people into professional computing, the good pay -- one of the reasons given on the wwcode website for encouraging women to enter the field -- will decrease, due to the increased supply of workers. tech is reduced to Yet Another Job, and Women Who Bgurp becomes the next YC startup.

three, the wwcode website argues that diverse teams perform better by increasing collective intelligence -- measured in what units? and when it claims that organizations with the largest representation of women leadership have a higher return on investment, how is that measured? this seems super hand-wavy to me.

lastly, the website's statement about women investing 90% of their income in their communities "when [they] make more" is not only unlikely, but is predicated on the long-term availability of good pay in professional computing, which, as i mentioned earlier, will decline at a rate proportional to the frequency with which we encourage people to enter the field.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by lukeschlather on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:53PM (#11825959)
> for one, the fact that there are fewer women than men in any field, computing or otherwise, is neither good nor bad. the disproportionate number of women in nursing is not seen as a problem, but somehow it has become one in tech.

I don't agree. I think the gender disparity in nursing is just as much a problem. I think it's a significantly less tractable problem though, because I don't think the monetary incentives are there for men to enter nursing.

As for your economic arguments, I think they're oversimplified. We really don't know what the job market is going to look like long-term. We do know that the computing job market has quadrupled in size over the past 20 years, and it is a good bet that the job market can quadruple again over the next 20 years, without any loss in median salary.

Back to monetary incentives. The median salary for software engineers could be reduced by 25% and it would still be a good career choice. So there's no real reason not to encourage more people to enter the field. Nursing has a substantially lower median salary.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:51PM (#11826383)
> The median salary for software engineers could be reduced by 25% and it would still be a good career choice. So there's no real reason not to encourage more people to enter the field. Nursing has a substantially lower median salary.

That's not accurate, at least when controlling for location. Going by BLS data, the difference between RNs and software engineers is less than 25% in LA, NYC, Boston, Chicago, San Jose and probably many other places that I didn't check. In San Francisco, RNs actually get paid more on average.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by lukeschlather on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:58PM (#11826844)
It's not useful to control for location without controlling for number of jobs available. What I'm really trying to approximate is "How difficult is it to get a job making at least a six-figure salary as a nurse or a software developer?" In SF for example, there are at least twice as many software developer positions as nursing positions. So while the median may be higher for nurses, it's still harder to get a high-paid nursing job than a similarly paid software job.

http://www.bls.gov/regions/west/news-release/occupationalemp...

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by sev on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:16PM (#11826141)
I agree with both of you, in some regards. But just thinking about it...maybe it's okay to have an uphill battle to get into a field that's prized. "Natural selection" of sorts...or survival of the fittest, etc. The field being dominated by males at this moment, might simply be a temporal problem that will automatically change in time without much specific effort.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by atom-morgan on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:56PM (#11827992)
> I don't agree. I think the gender disparity in nursing is just as much a problem.

What makes you say that? An argument could be made that women, in general, are more nurturing and that role fits them better than men. I know in that environment I'd prefer a woman taking care of me over a man.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by thaumasiotes on Thursday June 02, 2016 @07:56PM (#11827249)
One reason nursing has a substantially lower median salary is that it's largely women. You might be interested in the median salary of male nurses.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nck4222 on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:44PM (#11825889)
>i just don't believe in encouraging anyone to do anything in particular, except what they enjoy.

There are plenty of women who would enjoy being a developer but it wasn't presented to them as a realistic option in their childhood, or it wasn't a welcoming atmosphere for them when they started learning about it.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by busterarm on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:48PM (#11825918)
You could swap the gender and career with just about any field in either end of this list[0] and have the same argument, but there is a razor focus on this one specific field/gender combination.

[0]: https://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/chal...

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nck4222 on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:05PM (#11826058)
You could, but I'm not sure how that's relevant to this discussion. Other fields have a similar problem, and are either unaware or don't consider it a problem.

I consider it a problem in the software/tech industry regardless of whether other professions do.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by busterarm on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:13PM (#11826125)
It's a reference to the GP's suggestion that maybe this isn't the correct problem to solve.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by kaitai on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:02PM (#11827804)
This is a tech site. Is it any surprise that there aren't a lot of discussions about getting men into macrame? There are no discussions of macrame, period, on HN. More's the pity -- it involves lots of cool knots. But somehow on a tech site it's just not of primary interest.

Nursing is brought up on everyone of these threads about gender, though. I haven't yet built the threatened autoposter about efforts to get men into nursing and the premium that men in nursing are paid over women in nursing, but both of those are well-documented.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by chongli on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:20PM (#11826580)
I think the reason so much emphasis is put on attracting women to tech is the same reason so much emphasis is put on female politicians: tech people - especially startup founders - have the opportunity to have an outsize impact on the lives of everybody else in society. Encouraging more men to become kindergarten teachers may be great for the kids in their classroom but it's unlikely to have the impact of the next Twitter or a Facebook.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nostrebored on Thursday June 02, 2016 @07:03PM (#11826873)
And the majority of the fields leading up to tech, excluding a few outliers like Sales reps, fall under categories in which men have an undeniable advantage as employees. Computer Science and other STEM fields are not limited by physical capabilities.

Also, I'd be interested to see if the rates of women in AE/IE are going up, holding steady, or if like CS they are declining. The declining rates of women entering our field is truly worrying.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by st3v3r on Thursday June 02, 2016 @08:16PM (#11827381)
So what? That's not any kind of rebuttal to doing this.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by antisthenes on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:36PM (#11826685)
Being a developer was not presented to me as a realistic option in my childhood either, mainly because most of the many schools I've attended did not have any sort of computer science curriculum until the senior year.

Nor did I have anyone in my circles interested enough in programming until I've already picked my major.

Does that mean I now qualify for some special victim treatment just like those women?

Let's be honest here. If you want your argument to mean something, it can't have anything to do with gender. If it does - then the whole basis of it just boils down to "let's give women more handouts"

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by kaitai on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:14PM (#11827835)
There are plenty of outreach efforts in the US targeted at students who might not get exposed to coding in school. I guess I wouldn't consider them special victim treatment; after all, golf and tennis also have outreach efforts to communities that don't have golf and tennis in school. Is that special victim treatment? It is often framed as charity as well as a way to popularize the activity in question.

Should all attempts to expose people to coding cease? Or are they ok if we only target people like those currently in the industry, perpetuating the status quo of 2016 but not 1984?

I notice you ignore the "welcoming atmosphere" part of the parent.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nostrebored on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:58PM (#11826843)
Yes, because your childhood and socialization is the same as the countless women who were raised to think that their value is an extension of their sexuality or partner. You did not face the same sets of problems that women did. Presenting your "analagous" situation is entirely disingenuous.

If you want your argument to mean something, it can be related to gender. It can be related to a critical analysis of the way that our society treats and raises boys and girls and the implications that this has on their lives and livelihoods.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by nostrebored on Thursday June 02, 2016 @07:13PM (#11826948)
1. When it becomes a systemic problem, i.e. women earn a significantly lower amount based on their job choices, there is an issue. The narrative of the pay-gap has largely been framed around pay for the same job, when in reality the consideration we should be making is pay-gap based on profession.

The reason being that it exposes a flaw in the way that our society is socializing young women. The idea that we have that women go into non-profits at an absurdly high rate because they have some inherent biological difference just doesn't make sense based on the neuroscience research that we have today.

A huge proportional difference in any field that does not have a physical limitation (i.e. if women were 1% of lumberjacks I would not see that as a problem) is worrisome.

The large proportion of women in nursing is emblematic of a problem -- it's a field with ridiculously long hours, high rates of injury, and entirely focused around caregiving.

While a higher number of available candidates in a field will decrease our salaries, is that a valid reason to keep women out of high-paying fields? You could say the same for any other engineering profession.

I agree that the wwcode claims are nebulous.

I don't doubt that women who make more invest more in their communities, I do doubt that it's 90%, but in a way I feel like this is also part of the problem, and I would be saddened if women invested 90% of their income in their communities. It would mean that the problems I'm talking about above are not solved, and are rather being financially and socially perpetuated.

Meh

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by HarshTruth on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:44AM (#11828365)
Women earn lower because they choose to earn lower. Men face more pressure to earn a higher income than women, so naturally men dominate the high income fields. Then, once married, it makes more sense (economically) for the lower earning partner (the woman) to become the primary parent further widening the pay gap.

Want to fix it? Tell women to instead (statistically, as a group) start marrying down in income. Then men will face less pressure to earn a high income (and be able to, like women now, marry up for economic security), so will have more freedom to choose, and pay gaps will equalize.

The reason women go into non-profits is that it doesn't significantly effect their sexual selection. A man who does so would be significantly limiting his sexual opportunities. You don't need neuroscience to explain it. Men face every economic pressure that women do AND a sexual pressure. So naturally men earn more.

I would also be hesitant to try and fix it because the entire human endeavor is built around the male's desire for high status, which is fundamentally sexually motivated. Fix it and humanity stagnates.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by tomp on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:20AM (#11829193)
> When it becomes a systemic problem, i.e. women earn a significantly lower amount based on their job choices, there is an issue.

I disagree. E.g. in the Netherlands, many women (mothers) choose to work part-time (4 hours) to be able to spend more time at home (presumably with their kids). I think it's great that the governments supports this choice, more governments should follow!

(You could use the same argument for other job choices; maybe more women choose to be e.g. teachers despite the lower salary, because they enjoy working with kids!)

Sure, they earn (much) less, but in exchange they have a higher quality of life, so I see it as a perfectly valid choice/tradeoff.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by tuna-piano on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:41PM (#11825858)
One other comment on your comment of many female nurses (among other professions, great graph here showing that surprisingly few professions are even close to 50/50 mix: https://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/chal...)

Keeping it simple and assuming that the economy needs a stable amount of nurses + coders, for every girl who decides to be a coder instead of a nurse, you are saying a boy should be a nurse instead of a coder! But as you say, I don't see a big push for boys to do other things, which is exactly what would have to happen.*

*I understand price substitution effects occur, but the general idea is still correct.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:35PM (#11826677)
> the good pay -- one of the reasons given on the wwcode website for encouraging women to enter the field -- will decrease, due to the increased supply of workers

As women enter a field, the pay decreases faster than can be explained by just "increased supply", because the job becomes perceived as "women's work" which is systematically undervalued.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by startling on Friday June 03, 2016 @02:40AM (#11828736)
> just don't believe in encouraging anyone to do anything in particular, except what they enjoy.

Great. What about the women working in tech now who feel isolated and held back, and the women who leave tech because of it?

(i.e. the people this initiative is supposed to help)

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by busterarm on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:39PM (#11825846)
Also, should we really be pushing anyone into a field known for social isolation, long hours, depression and suicide without making a seriously strong effort to resolve those problems as well?
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by maerF0x0 on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:51AM (#11828589)
it may be known for that because those are societal problems that plague men. Sadly no big push to solve those for men.

suicide (proxy for depression) : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_differences_in_suicide Hours : http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2015/time-spent-working-by-full-...

Sad thing is by introducing women it will dilute the averages making it seem like everything is aok.

Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by morgante on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:24PM (#11828097)
Introducing a higher percentage of women to the field would likely directly improve several of those problems due to statistics alone.
Re:Women Who Code (YC S16) helps female engineers level up i... by lukeschlather on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:18PM (#11826158)
It might be harder to solve either problem in isolation than it is to solve both at the same time.