News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by julius_geezer on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:33PM (#1182547)
Next up: J.M. Keynes on quantum electrodynamics.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by tjgabbour on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:44PM (#1182712)
There's nothing wrong with voicing an opinion on the economy which you depend on, particularly if you've thought about it a lot. The world would probably be a better place if this were more common. (After all, wars are even fought over economic incompatibilities. Take the US and old Soviet Union; their economies even had crucial similarities, like top-down workplace decisionmaking.)

In probably any country it's very difficult to be an economics prof if you go outside narrow ideological bounds. Like if you wanted to pursue Participatory Economics or something, rather than forms of capitalism or marxism-leninism. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_economics

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by nlabs on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:40PM (#1182556)
Bad retort. The prerequisites to understanding economics is hardly close to that needed to understand QED. Besides, economists have physics envy. Physicists can intelligently contribute to economics.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by camccann on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:02PM (#1182602)
Physicists can intelligently contribute to economics.

I remain to be convinced that economists can, in general, intelligently contribute to economics. At least physics gets results...

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by mtalantikite on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:48PM (#1182719)
I hear where you're coming from, economics definitely can feel clumsy at times, but that to me is even more reason to continue pushing it for breakthroughs. Economics is a relatively new field of study compared to the history of physics.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by freebsd_dude on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:22PM (#1182804)
Economics can contribute to economics, so long as they are not dynamic macroeconomic theorists. That stuff is witchcraft.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by glhaynes on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:53PM (#1182582)
I'm not sure I understand what you mean. It seems (from a certain perspective, at least) that physics is much more thoroughly understood than economics. We can make really precise predictions in physics... economics, not so much.
[deleted]
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:33PM (#1182683)
As the only reason we're paying attention to this non-mathematical essay is because Albert Einstein wrote it, noting that he was not actually an economist is entirely valid.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by freebsd_dude on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:42PM (#1182704)
Economics in the 40-50s was about Markets vs. Planning. The big economic names at the time - Hayek, Keynes, were debating the merits and faults of markets and planning. Einstein threw in his 2 cents. That he was a physicist has no bearing on his argument.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:50PM (#1182724)
Exactly. And yet the only reason this essay has been dug up is because the greatest physicist of the day wrote it.

Hayek, Keynes, et al discussed the economics - the models, the math.

Einstein here makes a political argument, complete with hand-waving about how economics can't be used to judge his position because it's so last-wave.

This is the political version of Linus Pauling and vitamin C .

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by freebsd_dude on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:06PM (#1182761)
Actually Hayek and Keynes never used much math in their arguments. Keynes ideas were put into economic models by later economists with science backgrounds: Alvin Hansen, Paul Sameulson, James Tobin, etc.

Quit pointing out that Einstein was wrong. Thats obvious. The point is that a physicist can contribute to economics. Had the original poster simply pointed out the flaws of socialism, this discussion would never had taken place.

Edit: original poster = I mean the guy who said JM Keynes on QED - had he pointed out socialism flaws this discussion would have never taken place.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:10PM (#1182773)
You are far out of your depth; this'll be my last to you.

"Quit pointing out that Einstein was wrong. Thats obvious."

Please point that out to the people trying to sleaze in the claim he was right. :)

"The point is that a physicist can contribute to economics."

To quote another physicist, you're not even wrong!

"ad the original poster simply pointed out the flaws of socialism, this discussion would never had taken place."

Well no - gnosis apparently would have never submitted this, judging by some of his other remarks.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by laut on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:27PM (#1182671)
Economics is not a natural science. It is a social science. It's pretty important to understand this, but most people don't.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by waldrews on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:24PM (#1182658)
Was it Max Planck who gave up economics for physics after finding the former too difficult?
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:00PM (#1182597)
"Physicists can intelligently contribute to economics"

Someone should submit a link of an example; this does not do so any more than a blog rant about the "global warming hoax" contributes to climatology.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Anon84 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:06PM (#1182607)
You mean like the 2000 Nobel prize in Economics?

    The deficiencies in my college preparatory training were
    quickly made up, and at age 19, I received a B.S. in
    Physics with highest honors.

    I continued my studies in physics as a graduate student
    at Minnesota, but was strongly attracted to the study of
    human behavior.
 
http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economics/laureates/2000/...
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:13PM (#1182626)
Exactly. That's actual contribution to a field of knowledge, not a political essay.
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by MaysonL on Thursday March 11, 2010 @02:22AM (#1183260)
von Neumann on game theory. QED. (the other QED).
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Thursday March 11, 2010 @11:40AM (#1184152)
I assume you mean quod erat demonstrandum, which normally goes at the end of a proof.

The only thing you've helped prove, as requested, is that there are far better stories about physicists and economics to submit here than a political essay by Albert Einstein. :)

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by nlabs on Thursday March 11, 2010 @11:57PM (#1185820)
of course, but the guy who posted the essay it did so to show off a critique of captialism. An appropriate response is then to say why Einstein is wrong, not attack his credibility by making it akin to JM Keynes commenting on QED (as Keynes is clearly not qualified to comment on QED).
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:19PM (#1187528)
No.

Einstein is championing a system shown not to work. Why should I spend any more time refuting that in 2010 than I would trying to counter some old essay by an economist on the luminiferous aether?

[deleted]
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:13PM (#1182628)
You seem to be misreading what I wrote, above. That or you might need to RTFA and compare what Einstein is saying with a discussion of economics.
[deleted]
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:17PM (#1182639)
Well, as it's not an economic argument, I'd agree.

However, his political argument in that essay should not be given special credence because he was one of history's greatest physicists.

[deleted]
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:37PM (#1182688)
Maybe you mean axioms.

I don't see why you're defending an essay pimping socialism after the results of socialism over the course of the 20th century. Einstein had the excuse of much of what happened in the Soviet Union being effectively covered up; in the wake of our knowledge of what happened there, during the Cultural Revolution, etc., it's just not excusable in 2010.

It's like linking to Ludwig von Mises rambling about FTL travel.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by freebsd_dude on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:52PM (#1182728)
huh?

They are called the "Fundamental Theorems of Welfare Economics" - look it up in any graduate econ text. Stop ranting.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:59PM (#1182744)
You'll know when I rant. :)
Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by gnosis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:05PM (#1182606)
Einstein anticipates and addresses this criticism in his essay:

"...economic science in its present state can throw little light on the socialist society of the future [which has evolved beyond the 'predatory phase' with which economists of today are concerned with].

Second, socialism is directed towards a social-ethical end. Science, however, cannot create ends and, even less, instill them in human beings; science, at most, can supply the means by which to attain certain ends. ...

For these reasons, we should be on our guard not to overestimate science and scientific methods when it is a question of human problems; and we should not assume that experts are the only ones who have a right to express themselves on questions affecting the organization of society."

(Comments in brackets are mine)

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:20PM (#1182654)
I will note that scientists of any degree of renown tend to be absolutely fantastic at careful, hard-nosed, scientific analysis that leads to the conclusion that the very political beliefs they already have are objectively correct.

Every downturn of the economic cycle leads to declarations that capitalism is disproved. Oddly, some people refuse to acknowledge that tens of millions of dead people seem to be much stronger evidence against command economies and socialism. (Socialism in the 20th century sense, not "welfare systems bolted atop market systems" in the Teabagger sense.)

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by seanl on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:23PM (#1182806)
Arguably the two world wars of the 20th century were a consequence of the expansionist tendencies of capitalist economies, and between them deaths were nigh on 100 million.

Of course you may well reject such an argument, as I might reject the argument that the tens of millions of deaths in totalitarian states that described themselves as communist were an inevitable consequence of their politico-economic structure.

My point is not to claim that either of these points of view are true or false. My point is that complex, somewhat subjective and potentially contentious historical analyses are required to attribute causation to the 20th century's multiple clusters of mass homicide (unlike, say, the deaths caused by the 1918 flu pandemic where an objective attribution of cause is relatively straightforward).

The evidence is not as straightforward as you portray it.

(edit: I missed out the word 'deaths' in the first paragraph)

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by lionhearted on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:30PM (#1182825)
> Arguably the two world wars of the 20th century were a consequence of the expansionist tendencies of capitalist economies, and between them deaths were nigh on 100 million.

Wait, wait, wait, hold up - in what universe are Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan capitalist? Both countries had heavy government ownership, control, and coordination of industry. Hitler's party was the National Socialist German Workers Party - the Third Reich state owned all the chemical production and most of the industrial production in Germany. People loosely in favor of socialism don't like counting Nazi Germany among socialists, but they definitely had worker/state control over industry.

Unless you mean to imply that the United States, England, and France started WWII? I mean, you could make a roundabout Treaty of Versailles argument to do that, but clearly the Axis war economies of WWII were not free enterprise/free market/capitalist.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by seanl on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:42PM (#1182854)
Unless you mean to imply that the United States, England, and France started WWII? I mean, you could make a roundabout Treaty of Versailles argument to do that

That would be a simple version of the argument I have in mind. Basically I don't think WW1 and WW2 were disconnected events, there is a path of historical causation that runs through both.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:31PM (#1182827)
You almost have a case for WW1, though I find it hilarious that people sniffing about totalitarian communism not being "real" socialism so smoothly conflate mercantilism and capitalism. WW2 flat requires the re-branding of command economies as "capitalist".

Mind, I didn't mention the wars; I actually had in mind the people who died en masse in "peacetime".

"I might reject the argument that the tens of millions of deaths in totalitarian states that described themselves as communist"

You might; I'd be impressed by that as I would be the latest from the Discovery Institute.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by seanl on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @11:11PM (#1182926)
OK, so you significantly edited your reply, rather than do the same I'll respond again:

"smoothly conflate mercantilism and capitalism."

That mercantilism was a phase of capitalism is a common - though not universally accepted - point of view.

"WW2 flat requires the re-branding of command economies as "capitalist"."

Repeating myself somewhat, but that depends on how you attribute causation. That capitalism was in crisis in the 1930s is pretty uncontentious. That the effects of that crisis on Germany contributed to the rise of Nazism is also fairly uncontentious. The rest depends on how you weight those factors against others.

I appreciate that you are not open to the view that a non-murderous and non-totalitarian socialist society is possible. I myself am on the fence.

However I do strongly believe the first half of my argument: that capitalism begets death and destruction on a scale that exceeds the murderousness of the 20th century's totalitarian regimes (whether within 'wartime' or 'peacetime' matters not to me).

I hope that something better is possible. I accept that based on the empirical evidence we are screwed.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by seanl on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:39PM (#1182844)
WW2 requires the re-branding of command economies as "capitalist"

Only if you see the rise of Nazism and WW2 as discrete historical events with no causal relationship to the years that immediately preceded them. I've encountered reasonable arguments that the first half of the 20th century was dominated by a single protracted world war with a lapse in explicit hostilities in the 1920s. The rise of any ideology has to be accompanied by conducive political and economic conditions.

You might; I'm as impressed of that as I am by ID.

Apparently your repeated mistake is to confuse the methodologies that lead to sound scientific theory and the methodologies that lead to sound historical theory. I'm attempting to highlight complexity and nuance in the history of the 20th century that you are overlooking. If you refuse to see it then no amount of rational argument will help.

Re:Albert Einstein: Why Socialism? by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @10:47PM (#1182869)
"Only if you see the rise of Nazism and WW2 as discrete historical events with no causal relationship to the years that immediately preceded them."

This is not required.

I'm afraid I have to view the rest of your response, straw-manning arguments I haven't even made, as pure trolling; ta.

EDIT: Been on the net almost 20 years, and I've come to accept that there's always going to be a class of person who'll wander up, recite one side of a script in his head, and declare victory when people realize what he's on to. :)