And I also don't accept the premise that it's the same type of engineers that the companies would hire. The security teams at cloud companies are made up of very specialized engineers that are vastly different from the average dev you'd hire to run your internal on-prem servers.
Security is one of the things that sets SaaS (by the big players) apart. Running something on-prem will not have nearly the same security resources looking at it.
In the latter case intrinsic quality of a biproduct of your operation would not matter to your management, because they primarily think in order to give the best quality to the customers of the company's product, and the intrinsic quality of that product matters to them (eg. to use BPA free materials for the rubber ducks they manufacture). This is why they will feel spending on security of the in-house development unjustified, until a major security breach happens.
Right, I agree, but just because it is important doesn't mean they are good at it. And there is the fact that there is now likely 1 or 2 people attending to 1000 customers, than 1 or 2 people in house tending to 1 customer.
So it really is a comparison of 1-2 security engineers vs 100-200 security engineers.
This is completely not true, many customers often need specific custom tailored security for business specific needs (This is something most startup SaaS developers dont realize or care about because they are usually just starting development and care about growth and base product). This is where the problem lies, you paint with a broad brush and get the 80%, the other 20% is a nightmare usually. Most the time the 80% has holes in it too, like we saw here with SalesForce.
Whenever Im architecting a system, I always tell the execs you can either pay for it now (going on-prem) or pay for it later (with Saas) because at the end of 5 years you always end up paying just about the same, its just a matter of where. With payroll, downtime, customer losses, hardware, DR, wasted time with project managers from your SaaS providers.
Id always rather have control and know my system than depend on someone else's hire who behind a curtain of three, four or five nines of marketing jargon. It's always a pay me now or pay me later situation.
They usually take other precautions like VPNs, etc.
I'm not saying it's perfect, but for MOST people, this is a better alternative.
Does that make sense? If companies made a concerted effort to hire for this and take it seriously, it makes sense. But large enterprise customers with the resources to do this aren't the majority of saleforce users.
This is a fallacy that people like to believe because they are not doing the work themselves. The fact is SalesForce hires the same type of developer/admin that any company would hire and that person is trying to do their best like everyone else. Because it's behind a curtain people feel its more secure, when in reality it's probably the same level of competence/incompetence that anyone can do hosted on-prem.