News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by scotty79 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @09:47AM (#1180985)
Apparently Mozilla liked Metalab design so much that it was getting ready to actually use it in their product. Price happened to be too steep so they passed.

What Metalab should do is that it should contact Mozilla and tell them: "Look guys, we saw that you put much effort and actually introduced our design into development version of your product. We think it really looks great so maybe you should reconsider and purchase this design from us. We can give you discount on this."

Instead they went "This is mine. You have not paid to touch it. Don't touch it! Hey, everybody!!! They are touching it but they didn't pay me!"

Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @03:16PM (#1181843)
Yeah, I know that price tag says $199.99, but since you walked out of the store with it stuffed in your pocket, I know you like it - how's $180? $160?

Hey, don't walk so fast, I'm trying to negotiate with you. Wait up!

Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by scotty79 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @04:58PM (#1182111)
From what I see is more like:

Why do you touch my apples? You said you didn't want to buy them for 10$! Stop touching my apples! Thief! Thief! Make him stop touching my apples!

Or maybe fitting the dress you said you didn't want to buy would be a better metaphore.

Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @05:21PM (#1182164)
Except, of course, I already took the apples home.

Yesterday.

(Or in Mozilla's case, three months prior.)

I get that folks love Mozilla and don't like MetaLab, but the contortions people are going through to try to paint them as wrong or stupid on this issue are headache-inducing. I wish people would just honestly say, "I don't care that Mozilla ripped off MetaLab."

Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by scotty79 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:20PM (#1182422)
I can't force myself to think about the design as an item that comes in a opaque box with price tag. You have to try if design fits. If it fits you keep it, pay for it and everyone is happy. If not, you don't pay for it and toss it away what apparently Mozilla did. Same thing you do with photographs. You try many of them, but buy only the ones that go into final design. I wonder if MetaLab pays for all the photos that go through its designers hands.

There are some screenshot that prove that at some point that design was tried to be fitted. That's all. Not that Mozilla took design home and unboxed it without paying.

Re:Mozilla rips off Metalab, issue apparently resolved withi... by Semiapies on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:30PM (#1182541)
"If not, you don't pay for it and toss it away what apparently Mozilla did."

They did not toss it away, which is the whole point. They used it in public material.

That you can't "force" yourself to think in terms of accepting or declining agreements is an issue you might look into; I have nothing further to add.