News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:14AM (#1180714)
Summary: Political rant with editorialized title. Speaker advocates for cuts to student loan programs to produce massive cuts the university budgets leading to decreased program quality but affordable prices.

I'm not sure this is even worth criticizing because frankly this guy is completely clueless, but:

* The decreased program quality part seems to be skimmed over.

* Educational institutions that just react to market forces are bad educational institutions. Market forces result in grade inflation and low graduation standards, something I think most people agree are extremely unfortunate trends.

Alternative proposal: Redirect student loan subsidies from students towards institutions directly, possibly also bias the subsidies towards public institutions. The result should be lower tuition for everyone, mild downward forces on private institutions' tuition costs, hopefully no cuts to program quality and reasonable levels of affordability for reduced income students who will still rely on need-based aid more than loans and continue to have fairly cheap public schools they can opt to go to.

Re:The truth about student loans by yummyfajitas on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:42AM (#1180758)
The decreased program quality part seems to be skimmed over.

Some numbers: students pay $19,869.5 per term (http://www.nyu.edu/bursar/tuition.fees/rates09/ugcas.html). If each student takes 6 classes (between 18 and 24 credits), a class of 30 students pays $99,347.5 for one course.

Another number: a typical PTL in math gets $4-6,000 per class. Presumably the cost of a PTL in a less marketable subject is lower.

Unless rent for a classroom + admin overhead adds up to about $90,000/semester, there is plenty of waste to be cut.

Specific examples of waste: the climbing wall, counseling services, latino center, anime club, gym, soccer team, korean formal ball, resident assistants, multiple offices of affirmative action [1]. (These all exist at universities I've attended or worked for.)

Educational institutions that just react to market forces are bad educational institutions. Market forces result in grade inflation and low graduation standards, something I think most people agree are extremely unfortunate trends.

Come up with uniform standards, and separate the tasks of education and evaluation. Problem solved.

[1] If a university has three offices of AA, that's either 2 or 3 too many (depending on your views on AA).

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:21AM (#1180823)
Also, the specific examples of waste I'd like to address, since I think you might have some misconceptions on how these are funded:

* Climbing wall: At most universities I've seen these types of services are usually funding through a university recreation department that gets paid via student fees... voted on by the students. I.E. students went to an actual ballot and chose to raise their fees to supply things like this.

* Counseling center: I disagree this is waste. Parents tend to get angry when students throw themselves from buildings. Universities that provide psych help for their students can lessen the number of students who do this, which is helpful for retaining not only the students who would otherwise kill themselves, but the students who object to seeing a rain of their peers from the tall building on campus. It also tends to increase alumni donation rates, IIRC.

* Latino center / other AA type things: These are often student funded or sometimes funded through restricted funds where some interest group gives funds to the university specifically for this purpose. This doesn't always happen, but does more than you think. And yet again, these usually increase alumni donation rates among minorities and therefore net the university more than they paid, which means the university is simply making a smart investment, doubly so if they didn't even pay for it because someone else gave them funds to build it.

* Various student clubs: Again, these are typically funded by students at most universities through an activities fee their own student government put onto the thing. They voted on this, they decided to spend it where they spent it and on some campuses the administrators are in fact legally prevented from doing anything about it.

* Soccer team / sport programs: I'm not really a fan of sports programs being part of a university, but from a waste perspective not all of them are revenue losers. Some universities actually find they make money of teams and inspire a lot more private donations. Universities with strong sports programs tend to raise more money from alumni. I think this doesn't work out in practice for a lot of universities so I see this as potentially one of the better cases you've brought up as waste.

* Resident assistants: Actually a vastly cheaper alternative to paid university staff doing these types of tasks. This generally is a smart and low cost way to staff buildings and the opposite of waste.

Re:The truth about student loans by yummyfajitas on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:33AM (#1180838)
At most universities I've seen these types of services are usually funding through a university recreation department that gets paid via student fees... voted on by the students

We have a better way than voting to allocate private goods than voting: a market. Rather than allowing some students to vote for other students to pay for their entertainment, we should simply require that everyone pay for their own entertainment.

As for sports teams/etc, if they bring in money, keep them. Most don't. As for RAs, their services are completely unnecessary. My apartment building simply does not provide monthly pasta dinners, free light bulbs, an ice cream social at the beginning of the year, or endless spam about sorority events. Somehow I've survived.

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:40AM (#1180856)
If your apartment building had an alumni foundation that brought in substantial revenues it would. Also RAs do paperwork and some amount of administrative tasks that universities would have to hire a clerk or someone else to do. RAs are dirt cheap and it takes surprisingly little funds to make students feel like they're being pampered and money fluttered away on them when in reality it's almost nothing. But later they go "wow the university really cared" and they write checks.

Take up the market idea to the students. At most of the campuses they're the ones who control these fees and can chose to lower, raise, reallocate or toss them. Students overwhelmingly vote for certain types of fees consistently across campuses. Apparently they don't buy your market argument and frankly if they vote that stuff in that's their own choice and not much we can get riled up about. (These types of fees are typically not a large part of the overall cost of tuition. It depends on the system. A very few places are just absurd, most are pretty minor.)

Re:The truth about student loans by yummyfajitas on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @02:32PM (#1181731)
I guarantee you that a temp to do some paperwork for a week or two would cost less than free rent for a year (the cost of an RA).

As for taking the market idea to students, I advocate doing exactly that. Allow students to opt out of student activity fees (but they can't join clubs) and make sure the government doesn't subsidize them.

Incidentally, a student in the 49% who voted against student fees is NOT paying student fees by choice.

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:10AM (#1180805)
Universities vary widely and are extremely complex beasts. I can't address how NYU spends their money because I'm not familiar with their particular institutions, but the cost of the university is a lot more than space to teach and a body at the front of the room and students do derive some benefits from this environment.

I think our system is broken in that a lot of students who don't gain much from being on a research campus are pushed to research campuses anyways. My theory is we need to separate training and education so that people who need training in fields can go to low-cost non-research involved places and learn the skills they need. Whereas people who truly need an education among some of the best researchers in the world go to the research institutions and do research along with their coursework.

The latter is not necessary for a vast majority of college students and I think we need to stop pushing students into a system where degrees from research universities are valued independent of the need for that type of background.

Re:The truth about student loans by wisty on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:50AM (#1180775)
"Come up with uniform standards, and separate the tasks of education and evaluation. Problem solved."

In the UK, people used to "read" for a subject. Then they would take their exams. I'm not sure that system really worked though.

Re:The truth about student loans by barry-cotter on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:17AM (#1180816)
I don't see any evidence it didn't. Britain ran an Empire and had the industrial revolution all done well before the system started to change. There are people still alive whose professors had to be leaned on very hard not to give them a degree based on the quality of their tutorial work (Oxbridge sysytem).

The German system that took over with end of degree Finals also has certain very obvious advantages in ensuring people learn but the bundling of teaching, examination/certification and research is historically contingent.

yummyfajitas suggested some time ago asking a local university how much it would cost to take a course at a local university by examination, and I'm presuming that was a deadpan way of saying 95%+ of Universities would have hell freeze over before doing that, but the system seems to work just fine for accountancy. I see no reason why it couldn't be greatly expanded.

Re:The truth about student loans by Estragon on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @12:41PM (#1181456)

  ...frankly this guy is completely clueless...
I find what he's saying troubling, too, but you should know he has a pretty good track record when it comes to economic predictions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Schiff#Economic_views

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:25AM (#1180734)
I'd love to hear comments and replies rather than simply seeing your downvotes or your upvotes.
Re:The truth about student loans by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:30AM (#1180739)
If you have to know, I accidentally downvoted you.

I was torn between downvoting, commenting and ignoring you, and I clicked before I thought it through.

Giving money directly to the schools is not even wrong. Costs are totally out of control as it is. But you are correct that we have a great university system, so I figure you're at least hitting on something and are best left to your own devices.

Sorry for the downvote. No conspiracy was afoot.

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:32AM (#1180740)
Sorry for the mistaken assumption. I've edited the post to just be a kind reminder to others that I would appreciate replies to accompany votes. :)

To clarify: I completely agree costs are out of control. I just don't agree the solution is simply to defund it.

Re:The truth about student loans by AndrewS on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:48AM (#1180771)
Perhaps "they" could see how higher education is funded in other countries. I finished a decent four year software engineering degree a few years ago here in Australia and it set me back around AU$18k. That debt is CPI indexed (I think) and paid for by a levy on top of my income tax. The rest of the cost was covered by the government.

The system isn't perfect (and one of many issues is unis compromising difficulty/quality for full fee paying overseas students), but I'm pretty happy with it and paid off my debt easily enough.

I assume some other countries do a better job again.

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @07:53AM (#1180780)
We have this system in several states in the US, it does quite well. Unfortunately states are defunding their systems right now because of lower revenues and so tuition prices at public universities are beginning to rise at unfortunate rates. I'm all for reinvesting in our public education systems. Unfortunately, this particular video advocates simply cutting funding without actually providing any funds to universities.

My alternative plan is much closer to what you're saying than what the video's plan was. You don't actually seem to disagree with me at all. I'm curious where you got the impression you did.

Re:The truth about student loans by tokenadult on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:36AM (#1180846)
states are defunding their systems right now because of lower revenues

I observe that in my state, which historically has been a state with quite a high level of funding for higher education. And I observe that nationally there seem to be several states well known for lavish funding of higher education that are in severe economic downturns right now. In light of this, I'm wondering how an advocate of continued high levels of taxpayer funding for higher education makes the case that that is really beneficial for the overall economy of a jurisdiction. Could it be that there is less "investment" with dependable return in such taxpayer funding than people whose incomes derive from higher education claim?

Re:The truth about student loans by djcapelis on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:47AM (#1180869)
There's been quite a few good studies done that show the rate of return on education funding is something absurd like usually 1:10. Unfortunately I don't have any links to them on hand, but if you google around you should find the studies and then we can start quibbling about methodology. :-P

The other point you're making is that states with strong educational investments are hurting worse right now. I think you might find that those states are hurting worse because the difference between the amazing acceleration of everything they felt when the economy was good is just so out of step with the stagnant environment that comes about when the economy is bad that they simply had more to lose.

If you're referring to California, then that's a situation that has a lot of factors, many to do with the fact that the California Constitution is simply an document which is downright insane and progressively continuing to get more insane as voters keep lobbing stuff into it.

Re:The truth about student loans by AndrewS on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:14AM (#1180812)
I never said I disagreed with you; just mentioning that there are probably plenty of solutions and this was my experience under a different system.
Re:The truth about student loans by ytinas on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @08:48AM (#1180873)
On this site, downvote doesn't mean "disagree", it means you violated some etiquette.