News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:William Gibson has written a comic by criddell on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @09:19AM (#11806335)
I've never been able to enjoy reading a comic, other than short three panel or single page comics that you might see in a newspaper (like Herman or Far Side).

There's something about the switch from reading the words to examining the art work that is a little jarring. They just don't flow for me and so I never get into them. Is this something that others have felt? Do you get over it after reading comics for a while?

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by CaptSpify on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @10:19AM (#11806639)
I'm not a visually-oriented person. I enjoy art, but I like concepts much better. I like comics because it skips all of the description that books need to do in order to tell their story. They just show it instead. A picture is worth a thousand words, etc.

Some people like the descriptions that books offer, and that's fine. But for me they are annoying, and I want to get back to the story/dialogue.

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by sanoli on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:19AM (#11807027)
> A picture is worth a thousand words

A famous writer from my country had a good quote about that: "A picture is worth a thousand words. Now say that with a picture."

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by trentmb on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:32AM (#11807119)
You can probably do something interesting, similar to this: https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/b2/2a/e0/b22ae0a33...
Re:William Gibson has written a comic by vidarh on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:48AM (#11807237)
I think it really depends what you start with at what age. Some of the books I loved as a kid and where the stories are great, are painful to re-read now because the exposition is clumsy.

If you want to try something, I'd recommend Alan Moore. Especially his Swamp Thing run or Watchmen. They are both very literary to the extent that you could if you wanted to largely ignore the art (you'd lose out, but the story still largely makes sense) and just read the text. It lets you let the art just be there in the background.

Swamp Thing is basically a gothic epos of the man become monster (sort of; that was the original origin, which Alan Moore slightly upends in the second issue he wrote) who struggles to find his humanity and love, and then learns that his place in the world goes far beyond his old human identity.

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by fit2rule on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:55AM (#11807269)
Yes, definitely. One thing that I have found to be very comic-positive, is finding the archives and having the archives. Seriously, just knowing that you have the complete set of the comic/serial format, makes all the difference in the world.

I'm a fan of HEAVY METAL and METAL HURLANT magazines, myself. I just love the fantasy genre. I could stare at the lines of Moebius for hours. It is delightful to realize the effort put into the works.

But you have to find your niche. Not everyone is down with DEN. For some, HM/MH magazines are little more than titty-magz. (Not so, btw. Is Fantasy.)

Anyway, when you've got the full series, the experiences become really complete. Serialization is broken. Route around it.

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by level3 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:24AM (#11807060)
Have you tried black-and-white comics, like most Japanese manga? In my own experience, I've had that jarring feeling when reading full color comics, but only rarely for black-and-white (regardless of origin). I think full color makes it too easy to become engrossed in/distracted by the artwork, while black-and-white maintains a better balance so the transition back and forth is smoother. The level of detail in the artwork also seems to make a difference.

As an aside, Japanese (and I assume Chinese as well) also has an advantage due to its glyphs being visual by nature - i.e. you can view a panel in its entirety and still pick up meaning from the text without actually reading it word for word.

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by zzalpha on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @09:28AM (#11806368)
You get over it.

I came to the artform later in life and found it a weird transition. It's definitely a different experience and you have to change your approach... it's no longer just about reading the words, but also about studying the panels, which take the place of a lot of typical written prose.

Re:William Gibson has written a comic by dpark on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @10:15AM (#11806612)
I've never been able to get into long-form comics. They just don't hold my attention. I don't find them immersive at all, presumably due to the words<->art transition you refer to.
Re:William Gibson has written a comic by sevensor on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:13PM (#11807402)
I think it also depends on how you learned to read -- for a couple of years as a child I mostly read the Tintin books. Over and over, until they fell apart. As a result, the graphical style of comic books just makes sense for me as a storytelling medium. Although Hergé set a pretty high bar, and I do find a badly laid-out page hard to follow.
Re:William Gibson has written a comic by oxplot on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @10:05AM (#11806556)
Ye, I've also had a very hard time enjoying this mix. I feel clumsy and I suspect it's something one has to get used to.