News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by lolc on Sunday May 29, 2016 @06:36AM (#11795856)
A friend works on deciphering an old script based on very few samples. When he inquired about a piece he learned that more of those with similar inscriptions, presumably from illegal excavations, are stored in Geneva. Luckily he was granted access to have a look at them, I assume that the owners like researchers to validate their stuff, because they are suspected forgeries.

We don't really know how many more samples of that script are tucked away in vaults. In that context in don't care about a 1000 Picasso paintings. I would love for people to go crazy about the paintings, so long as they leave the truly old pieces to the researchers and in the ground until they can be excavated properly.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by return0 on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:10AM (#11795936)
That's the worst part about it. I believe art older than a reasonable number of centuries (e.g 300 years) should not be tradeable. What's the moral argument for allowing it?
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by iwwr on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:37AM (#11795989)
Private property? If you were to implement such a measure, it further encourages black markets, since the demand will still be there. A bad consequence can even be the destruction of art from either: hiding a crime or harder access to legitimate researchers and restorers.

Besides, not everything old is necessarily worth preserving.

You don't always need a physical object, you can take high-res scans or pictures.

Many pieces of privately-owned art are actually on long-term loans to museums.

Public museums usually have far larger stockpiles of objects than can reasonably be displayed. Many languish in storage for decades at a time. In private ownership they can at least be displayed and taken care of.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by jonknee on Sunday May 29, 2016 @09:42AM (#11796330)
Private ownership of antiquity is definitely murky. If you can prove legitimate ownership for an object that is one thing, all of a sudden owning an ancient treasure is another. I think they should belong to the state in question (e.g. the people from that area).
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by chris_va on Sunday May 29, 2016 @01:13PM (#11797133)
Where do you draw the line? In the US we always side with personal freedom in the courts (e.g. if you want to own something, you can do so, pursuit of happiness and all that).

Antiquities don't have a lot of intrinsic value beyond display, so eventually (maybe 50 years, maybe 200 years) they will all end up in a museum. Generally they have higher value to people in the area from which they originated, so they will eventually migrate home. I'd prefer to be patient and let it happen naturally instead of implementing new laws.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by return0 on Sunday May 29, 2016 @01:54PM (#11797401)
Why would they migrate home? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by chris_va on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:14PM (#11809820)
40% in favour of returning the marbles to Greece 15% in favour of keeping them at the British Museum 18% would not vote 27% had no opinion

... I feel like this is a good example of where they will eventually migrate home. It hasn't been very long, on an antiquities scale.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by GunboatDiplomat on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:41AM (#11796001)
What's the moral argument for NOT allowing it?

The default is allowed, not disallowed.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by return0 on Sunday May 29, 2016 @08:18AM (#11796089)
That it was illegally obtained. (could the first seller of the sarcophagus legally prove they owned it?)
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by GunboatDiplomat on Sunday May 29, 2016 @10:11AM (#11796428)
That may apply to sarcophagi from ancient Egypt, but certainly does not apply to all artworks over 300 years old.
Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by Shivetya on Sunday May 29, 2016 @09:10AM (#11796227)
this parallels the copyright laws many of us just hate that it is frightening.

the best solution that honors private property rights is to make part of the requirement of long term storage sites like this is to present high resolution scans of the artwork that would be freely available.

Some bemoan all this art being locked up out of private view, yet many government managed museums and the like are just as bad if not worse as I doubt an investor would let their collections suffer from neglect.

Re:The Geneva Free Port is crammed with storage vaults that ... by lolc on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:36AM (#11795986)
Agreed. The only reason I can sort of accept is that making trade illegal would cause some items to be hidden completely. (Which is not a moral reason to accept trade.)