News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:09PM (#11792616)
More advertising seems wasted money to me - pro Monsanto people don't matter, anti Monsanto people will only see it as propaganda.

Just label GMOs really obviously and let the people decide. Without any labeling or non-obvious labeling it is hard or impossible to avoid GMOs if you want to - for rational reasons or not - and being wholly against GMOs becomes your only real option. There are of course still a lot of other issues like cross contamination and what not but I think it would make a really got start.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by unchocked on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:54PM (#11792836)
The problem with labeling GMO's is that you're taking what ought to be a regulatory issue (is this GMO objectively safe?) and kicking it down I to the team of popular culture (do I the consumer think buying this GMO is safe for me?). Consumers are ill-equipped to make this decision, and if continually confronted by warning labels many will choose to avoid GMO containing foods "just to be safe". When a critical mass of consumers feel this way it will just be a cultural fact that GMO's are "unsafe" and food producers will avoid using them to avoid being seen as purveyors of "unsafe food".

Something similar happened to nuclear power, and we got coal power instead. GMO's enable the intensive agriculture needed to support 7+ billion people with a lower environmental impact than would otherwise be possible, and the technology is still primitive. I don't want it to be stopped in it's tracks by mob psychology.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:08PM (#11792925)
80 % of the world population has - more or less freely - decided to believe in invisible gods guiding the fate of mankind, sometimes with dire consequences, and we protect their right to do so. Should we force them to abandon this irrational nonsense for some greater good? I may not like the consequences of people acting irrationally but I like the idea of forcing people to believe The Right Thing™ even less. They feel about being forced to live with GMOs exactly the same way you feel about being forced to live with coal power, it's just a matter of on which side of the debate you are, both sides strongly believe to be on the right one.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:10PM (#11793228)
I don't believe anything prevents a seller from honestly producing,marketing and selling GMO free foods. However, demanding that the rest of the world participate in their marketing scheme is silly.

Similarly you can put "contains no functional programming" on your software if you like. But it's unreasonable to insist that I put "warning: free monads" on mine, particularly if it's logistically difficult and expensive (as it would be with both FP and GMO) to actually determine the truth.

Also, I suppose corn, tomato, potato, peppers and most other selectively bred crops are can never have the "non-GMO" label?

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:18PM (#11793571)
I am from Europe and here it is mandatory to label products produced with GMOs with some exceptions like meat from animals fed with GMOs. It is not the case that a handful people demanded that, it is a nonnegligible fraction of the population.

And you software example. There are scenarios where certain certifications are required, some with respect to functionality, some with respect to the process the software was build with. For example US companies had to adhere to the Safe Harbor rules if they wanted to offer services in the European Union and they probably had to declare that in the terms of service.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:46PM (#11793683)
Suppose a non-negligible fraction of the population demands Islamic, Hindu or Christian food. Should that also be labelled according to some law (rather than the current voluntary label system)?

Certifications for software are a very different thing because they are based on actual safety and functionality, not a faith-based preference.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @06:12PM (#11793815)
Why not? Consumers have a right to know what they eat. If half the population really wants to know whether products adhere to some religious practices, then so be it, print it on the box. In some cases businesses will voluntary do such things because they see it as beneficial, in some cases they won't and then you have to make into a law. I guess in your example with the religions they would do so voluntarily because what are the downsides? In case of GMOs they won't because they - probably rightly - fear reduced sales and so we need a law. And faith and objectivity, that may be a thin line. What about vegetarians and vegans? And even in case of GMOs there is still a small but non-zero risk of adverse (long-term) effects.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 28, 2016 @06:39PM (#11793908)
Just like halal and kosher food makers, non-GMO food makers can include it on the box.

As a vegetarian myself, I assume food which doesn't disclose itself as being veg is not - particularly when outside of India. I don't feel it is the responsibility of the rest of the world to accommodate my personal tastes.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:10PM (#11794171)
If everyone would label their non-GMO products that would maybe do, but what stops companies from putting non-GMO labels on GMO products if it is not enforced by some law? It also seems a bit backwards, why would one label all non-GMO products if one want's to know which products contain GMOs? That's a bit like labeling everything without honey as honey-free and not labeling honey and products containing honey. And we were already there - it is not you but a nonnegligible fraction of the population.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:42AM (#11796004)
No one is opposed to requiring non-GMO labels to be accurate, just like all other advertising.

What's being discussed here is simply requiring Joe's Corn & Pork to put "non-Halal, non-Kosher, yay GMO" on their label. I.e., forcing Joe to participate in someone else's marketing scheme.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Sunday May 29, 2016 @08:08AM (#11796063)
It is not a marketing scheme, it is customer information just like the usual ingredients labels. As I said in another comment, declaring what is in a product should really be the norm, GMO labeling opponents should justify why it is okay or better to hide this information from customers.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 29, 2016 @08:16AM (#11796079)
It's very simple. Food ingredients are on the label for safety reasons. There are no measurable safety effects of GMO, Halal, etc.

What criteria do you use to determine if a property should be on a label? Should foods with homosexuals or muslims involved in production also get a warning label? If not, why not? Or do you believe every random bias of consumers is something that every possible producer must account for?

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Sunday May 29, 2016 @08:32AM (#11796138)
What criteria do you use to determine if a property should be on a label?

Simple, if a substantial fraction of the consumers cares about it.

Should foods with homosexuals or muslims involved in production also get a warning label? If not, why not? Or do you believe every random bias of consumers is something that every possible producer must account for?

People already avoid products from specific companies, countries and whatnot because they disapprove their ethics, labor conditions and so on. If people cared about the race or religion of the people producing the products they buy, then it should be on the label. I would actually almost bet there were products advertising that they were produced by white Americans only or something similar. That it was never a mandatory labeling probably just means that people never cared enough about it, not that it is something totally unimaginable.

If this is really the only argument against GMO labeling, that it would be kind of a random addition amongst many other possible addition to the labels, that seems a pretty weak argument.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by belorn on Sunday May 29, 2016 @06:15AM (#11795806)
If there isn't already a law to identify when a animal was slaughted in a ritual manner, I would not be against it. Its the same as letting the consumer know that the eggs are from free range hens.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by pdkl95 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:23PM (#11792997)
> Should we force them to abandon this irrational nonsense

No. Nor should we support their delusions.

> both sides strongly believe to be on the right one

What they believe is irrelevant. Having "strong beliefs" doesn't make those beliefs rational or worthy of respect. Labeling should be based on facts.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:26PM (#11793016)
»Contains [no] GMOs« would totally be based on facts. It should be an informational label, not a warning label.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by pdkl95 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#11793248)
> informational

If this is supposed to be informational, what useful information is it providing? Can you name a single utility that will, in practice, be gained from a "GMO" label that isn't based on ignorance, delusion, fear of the unknown, or fundamental attribution error?

If there is some legitimate use, them I would fully support "GMO" labels. Until strong evidence is presented, presenting the "GMO" label as "informative" is an attempt to mislead. It confuses consumers and encourages delusional behavior.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:58PM (#11793467)
Don't you consider free choice for consumers about what they want to eat something useful? Products are labeled as vegan so that people can avoid, for example, milk in their groceries. Cows living in captivity for milk production vs some supposedly small risk for health or environment from GMOs. At least to me it is not obvious which of both is the better reason to put a label on products.

I and probably many people in first world nations would certainly feel different if we desperately needed GMOs to feed our people, but we don't. What do have to gain that justifies taking any additional risk however small? Less usage of biocides? More beautiful and homogeneous products? Less work for farmers?

We have produced harmful things - drugs, foods, building materials - before even though we did more or less our best to avoid it. Why not let people stick with things that we know are not harmful because they are time tested?

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by pdkl95 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @06:36PM (#11793900)
> some supposedly small risk for health or environment from GMOs

That's the part that's delusional.

> Cows living in captivity for milk production

That - and most of your other concerns - has nothing to do with genetic modification. Why do you believe a label about genetic origins will change farming practices? Monoculture farming, abuse of antibiotics, and other farming problems happen regardless of genetic origin.

Milk deserves a label because growth hormones and antibiotics have actual effects on humans. A similar label on Roundup Ready vegetables only encourages the delusional belief that they have "any additionnal risk, however small".

> needed GMOs to feed our people

We crossed that line a long time ago.

> Less usage of biocides?

YES. Roundup isn't perfect, but it is the least worse option compared to previous herbicides.

> they are time tested

Testing is always important, of course, but "old" does not mean "better" (or worse). This is the "appeal to nature" fallacy.

Also, about those crops you are calling "time tested". Does that include all the crops from before the field of genetics existed? Before we had the technology to make small, specific changes to the genome, we used to simply force mutations[1] with e.g. cobalt-60[2], x-rays, ethyl methanesulfonae[3]. Even though the results are random an often include multiple significant genetic changes that are completely unknown, many successful varieties created from mutation breeding are not only in the common food supply, they can also be labeled organic and often "non-GMO".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutation_breeding

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethyl_methanesulfonate

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:02PM (#11794144)
> some supposedly small risk for health or environment from GMOs That's the part that's delusional.

I don't doubt that most research suggests that GMOs are safe for health and environments but I don't know how one would conclude that there are no residual risks. History has enough examples even if not many. Just asserting that it is safe is a unscientific as seeing it as declaring it the beginning of the apocalypse.

> Cows living in captivity for milk production

That - and most of your other concerns - has nothing to do with genetic modification.

That was only meant as an example why people want to know what they eat, they have diverse concerns.

Why do you believe a label about genetic origins will change farming practices? Monoculture farming, abuse of antibiotics, and other farming problems happen regardless of genetic origin.

I never said something like this, I only argued for labeling GMOs so that people can decide for themselves whether to buy the or not.

> needed GMOs to feed our people

We crossed that line a long time ago.

You left out the first world part. The EU, for example, does produce (almost) no GMOs but imports some. I didn't look up the exact numbers but given that we also throw away about a third of our food I am pretty sure we don't need GMOs.

> they are time tested

Testing is always important, of course, but "old" does not mean "better" (or worse). This is the "appeal to nature" fallacy.

My point was just that we have plants of which we know that they are good to consume so it seems not unreasonable to want to continue to do so instead of taking up risk - however small - with new ones.

Also, about those crops you are calling "time tested". Does that include all the crops from before the field of genetics existed? Before we had the technology to make small, specific changes to the genome, we used to simply force mutations[1] with e.g. cobalt-60[2], x-rays, ethyl methanesulfonae[3]. Even though the results are random an often include multiple significant genetic changes that are completely unknown, many successful varieties created from mutation breeding are not only in the common food supply, they can also be labeled organic and often "non-GMO".

We will probably have to back up a bit, the discussion became quite fragmented and we are losing sight of the original issue. I am not against GMOs, at best I am for being careful. My original point was that there is a nonnegligible number of people not wanting GMOs - for good reasons or not - and we should just label GMOs so that everyone can decide for themself.

In the EU we already do this - although it is in the small print - but in the end I have no stakes in what the US or some other country does. For me it just seems a reasonable thing to do in order to pour oil on troubled waters. It doesn't really harm and everyone can eat what he likes. It won't help for people afraid of environmental issues but I guess more people are concerned about their personal health than about possible environmental impact.

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by unchocked on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:35PM (#11793064)
You can't separate those things.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:54PM (#11793147)
Why not? Make it blue, not red or green. Maybe even have it on everything, with and without GMOs, to avoid implicitly expressing any bias. People will surly complain that it is not red and has no skull and crossbones, but that's life.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by unchocked on Sunday May 29, 2016 @12:55AM (#11794861)
Because you are talking about requiring such labels. Requirements are there for a reason, even if that reason is implicit.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Sunday May 29, 2016 @05:22AM (#11795647)
And the reason is that people want to know it. Forget everything pro or contra GMOs, just see it as consumer information in the same way the usual ingredients labels are. I actually feel like this argument should be turned around - consumers have a right to know what is in their products, someone opposing GMO labeling should justify why it is okay or even better to hide this information from consumers.
Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by lukeschlather on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:28PM (#11792715)
You can create poisonous food with conventional techniques. The problem with the anti-GMO movement is that they're focusing on gene splicing without worrying about conventional methods. Labeling and testing cultivars is not a bad idea, but simply labeling "GMO" vs. "non-GMO" gives a false sense of security.

http://boingboing.net/2013/03/25/the-case-of-the-poison-pota...

Re:Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014) by danbruc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:48PM (#11792814)
I don't see how GMO labeling could make the situation worse, as far as I can tell people are currently not looking at the potatoes in front of them wondering whether they may contain excessive amounts of alkaloids or not. People are buying their groceries according to price, past experiences, looking at the photo on the box and maybe reading the nutritional content. They are already eating a lot of stuff they better avoided and they do so knowingly. If they want to know whether it contains GMOs, tell them.