Criticizing Thiel shouldn't be confused with supporting Gawker , because we don't know who Thiel might choose to punish next
Thiel didn't "punish" anyone. Gawker broke the law, and he helped hold them to account via the legal system.
I don't like Thiel one tiny bit. He's a weirdo. But this is, like, the least bad thing a billionaire has ever done to infringe on "free speech". Hypothetically abusing the legal system (eg, many frivolous lawsuits) would be bad, but he hasn't actually done that.
This may seem pedantic, but Gawker didn't break the law. This is a civil case.
>He's a weirdo.
I don't know what to make of this, and it adds nothing to the discussion.
So, the problem isn't that you're being pedantic, it's just that you're plain wrong.
Also the organizations you cite are actually working for the public good, while Thiel is working from a petty personal vendetta.
It contains people who are trying to sue. That counts as a personal vendetta, only arbitrated by the courts.
Your juxtaposition of 'private interest' vs 'public interest' needs work. Evidently they can both be aligned.
The attorney then asked him to specify: a child under what age? Daulerio responded: “Four.”"
This was the Gawker editor who came up with the sex tape and story. This sums up the the anything goes interpretation of free speech these people have. (Although he later said he was being flippant, that's even worse in exposing his infantile psychology).
OTOH, Thiel's ruthless use of the suing machine also leaves a bitter taste. This is a case where it's hard to totally root for either side.