Imagine measuring a distance vertically along the side of the window. Now imagine a second image in wich, instead of a window, there is just more of the (now larger) desk. If you were to draw the same line in the same location in the second image, the actual distance of the underlying object would be different. Does TakeMeasure somehow account for this? I would assume the answer is no, and if so that would still make for a useful app, but then I saw this "TakeMeasure allows you to measure dimensions of any small or large objects that fit into your camera view. "
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by dave2000 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:17PM
(#11793283)
I can take photos but the second and third tabs are empty; i can't see/set a reference. I tried ensuring the photo had a uk banknote in it (does it matter which?) but it made no difference.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:59PM
(#11793478)
What is your phone model? I'll have a look and try to release an update. You can use any UK banknote.
(aside: one would expect a picture taking using camera app to be fairly trivial, but it is actually very challenging on Android, where each vendor implements it with its own little subtleties)
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @06:11PM
(#11793813)
I reproduced similar problem in Xperia Z3 on 5.1.1, which I was able to fix and release. Unfortunately 6.0.1 was not on device cloud. Nevertheless, I think there are good chances that update to v13 will fix the issue, in any case, please let me know.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by Cerium on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:28PM
(#11793328)
Thanks for posting this. It is rather interesting to play with and has a good interface.
I have a couple issues though. First I can't zoom in enough to be very precise with the placement and measurement. It would be nice if the zoom was not limited so much. Also, using a Samsung S5 I am having some trouble getting an accurate measurement. I put a ruler and a us letter paper in the same plane and took a photo at about a 30 degree angle. I'm seeing about a 12.7" measurement on a 12" ruler.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:18PM
(#11793576)
Thank you for your feedback. I will consider increasing the zoom level. Would you like to share your picture so we could investigate the precision? ([email protected])
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by tjelen on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:42AM
(#11792046)
This is very nice. I'm experiencing some problems taking the picture directly by the camera (Nexus 5; 6.0.1). It takes a picture but the picture is empty or broken (but still shows up in the gallery). As a workaround, it's possible to make pictures by the default Camera app and then select the picture from the gallery.
Anyway, I think it's quite useful and surprisingly precise (+/- 1%). If I may make a feature request, I'd like to see more reference sheet sizes, e.g. the full A0-6 range.. :)
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:29PM
(#11792229)
Hi tjelen, thank you for your comments and suggestions! I have made the camera issue fixed and released to production. You should get an update pushed soon.
I am taking A0 - A6 request into consideration. Quite a few people were asking for a custom reference definition in the app. Might do it in one update if time allows in the future.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:38AM
(#11791613)
Hi, glad you like it! Let me have a look, have you tried to search for "TakeMeasure" directly in your phone? Might also be regional availability, what phone do you have / which region are you in?
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by vanous on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:11PM
(#11793239)
Very nice, thank you Ľuboši. Sorry about not rating it on GPlay, i am not allowed as it still requires G+ account for that :/
I love this kind of apps that interface to physical world. I have been using guitar tuners, BPM counters, noise and lux measuring apps and recently have been looking for RPM meter either by looking at spinning object or by counting LED flashes. Any suggestions?
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:06PM
(#11793510)
Thank you for the positive feedback! Instead of rating you could show your friends :p It is an interesting idea to measure RPM, but I am not knowledgeable about a concrete app. Best regards.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by rareEarth on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:18PM
(#11793287)
I got the iOS version and I was having trouble aligning the corners on the reference object. When I lifted my finger the crosshair would jump slightly with it.
Is it possible to offer edge detection or corner snapping?
I also got much better results when I zoomed as far as possible into the image to align each corner. I think that would be a helpful tip in the app when aligning.
Re:Show HN: TakeMeasure – Make your phone a ruler
by lubos_ on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:10PM
(#11793539)
Good news is that we have recently started playing with corner detection algorithms for snapping, we have first results, it looks promising, after little bit of more work, there might be an update in the near future.
Imagine measuring a distance vertically along the side of the window. Now imagine a second image in wich, instead of a window, there is just more of the (now larger) desk. If you were to draw the same line in the same location in the second image, the actual distance of the underlying object would be different. Does TakeMeasure somehow account for this? I would assume the answer is no, and if so that would still make for a useful app, but then I saw this "TakeMeasure allows you to measure dimensions of any small or large objects that fit into your camera view. "
(aside: one would expect a picture taking using camera app to be fairly trivial, but it is actually very challenging on Android, where each vendor implements it with its own little subtleties)
My wallet folds notes but the app is accurate if I try and make them as flat as possible first.
I have a couple issues though. First I can't zoom in enough to be very precise with the placement and measurement. It would be nice if the zoom was not limited so much. Also, using a Samsung S5 I am having some trouble getting an accurate measurement. I put a ruler and a us letter paper in the same plane and took a photo at about a 30 degree angle. I'm seeing about a 12.7" measurement on a 12" ruler.
Anyway, I think it's quite useful and surprisingly precise (+/- 1%). If I may make a feature request, I'd like to see more reference sheet sizes, e.g. the full A0-6 range.. :)
I am taking A0 - A6 request into consideration. Quite a few people were asking for a custom reference definition in the app. Might do it in one update if time allows in the future.
(Sorry, I'm not well-versed in these Android stuff, but my phone is fairly new and running Kitkat.)
I don't see why you're doing regional blocking for a free app. Even for paid apps it doesn't make a lot of sense. Would've loved to try this out.
I love this kind of apps that interface to physical world. I have been using guitar tuners, BPM counters, noise and lux measuring apps and recently have been looking for RPM meter either by looking at spinning object or by counting LED flashes. Any suggestions?
Is it possible to offer edge detection or corner snapping?
I also got much better results when I zoomed as far as possible into the image to align each corner. I think that would be a helpful tip in the app when aligning.