News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by kailuowang on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:10PM (#11763349)
I am curious how many of these medias actually admit that they are biased themselves?
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by ChuckMcM on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:28PM (#11763570)
That of course is the interesting question. Of course the media knows they are biased, some even call it out in their tag line like "The conservative voice" others are less outspoken.

Facebook is in an interesting position, they have such a wide swath of populations for reasons other than an editorial slant, they have people on site who might disagree with their position. Unlike the media where people who don't like the editorial bias of a paper simply don't read it.

It would be perfectly reasonable for Facebook to have an editorial position on the stories. But it has asserted that it does not. And that is where things get tricky. We saw on a propublica story about how the machine algorithm can get biased by poor data and assumptions, and we've seen from Facebook's media response that even when they don't have an "official" position, their employees naturally do and Facebook is seeking additional training for them to protect their biases from leaking into their curation choices.

That said, the "reality" of what is and what isn't trending is more about reinforcing one's belief in a position and less about the news. People who believe a story that strongly endorses their position but never trends is "suppressed", and stories that conflict with their opinions but are trending are "biased". I have yet to find any way to have a reasonable discussion about the popularity of views versus the correctness of those views with anyone who believes their point of view is being suppressed by "shadowy influences."

I don't think there is any way for Facebook to win here and a lot of ways it can lose.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by tjr on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:48PM (#11763798)
Stupid question, I imagine... I thought that Facebook users subscribe to the posting feeds of individuals and organizations of their own choosing. Would not the resulting custom feed be comprised of articles from sources which that particular user selected?

Where is the Facebook editorial bias coming into play?

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by tracker1 on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:01PM (#11763974)
I have very conservative, and very liberal friends... I myself lean libertarian, which puts my conservative on some issues and liberal on others... so, there is definitely a need for curation for quality, and diversity of opinion.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by needcaffeine on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:54PM (#11763880)
The trending news section, which is supposedly manually curated.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by Torgo on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:51PM (#11764450)
>t would be perfectly reasonable for Facebook to have an editorial position on the stories.

No it wouldn't, Facebook is nearly ubiquitous. It would have far too much control over dialogue.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:21PM (#11763472)
My anecdata suggests conservative outlets tend to acknowledge their bias, as a counterweight to liberal bias in the "mainstream" media, whereas liberal outlets tend to believe themselves to be unbiased.

Given how much liberal outlets scoff at the notion of there being a pervasive liberal bias in the MSM, I suspect they legitimately just don't see it as they're surrounded by people with the same political views and so are predisposed to believing that's what "normal" is.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by hackuser on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:25PM (#11763524)
> pervasive liberal bias in the MSM

The biggest cable news channel, the most popular newspaper (I think WSJ leads; EDIT: and certainly it dominates the business world), and almost all talk radio are highly conservative. They try to paint themselves as underdogs, but it's a little silly.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:30PM (#11763583)
Yes, the big ones are conservative, because every other one is liberal. Conservatives flock to places like Fox and WSJ because they're a refuge from the liberal bias that pervades the rest of the media.

If you're a liberal and you want to watch news that doesn't offend you, you can choose from any of the major networks save Fox. If you're a conservative and want the same, you're stuck with Fox.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by hackuser on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:42PM (#11763717)
> every other one is liberal

I don't agree.

First, there are plenty of smaller conservative ideological publications (two were listed in the original comment, plus endless more: RedState, Daily Caller, Breitbart, etc.). Almost all talk- radio, as I mentioned, is conservative.

Also I said in another comment, there is plenty of apolitical journalism.

  (!conservative) != (liberal)
The ideologues adopt a Manichean, binary view of the world: With us or against us. They say everyone is ideological and anyone who doesn't agree with them must be in the 'other' camp. They seek ideological conflict, to justify their beliefs and behavior. But the world is more complex than that and everyone is not ideological (most are not).

There are leftist ideologues, and they say the NY Times is conservative and there is no difference between the parties (as incredible as that sounds). Either you share their ideology, or you are in the 'other' camp.

The right-wing ideologues are the same: They define any journalism as not ideologically conservative as liberal. (They also call themselves outsiders when the control the 2/3 of the states and both houses of Congress). But it's not the case.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by pythia__ on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @07:42PM (#11766525)
>there is plenty of apolitical journalism

Could you name three major sources of it, preferably not personal blogs? I am asking out of curiosity and disbelief.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by hackuser on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @01:11AM (#11767779)
I think the real issue is to consider why many people have such a strong emotional reaction to the idea. I think it undermines their worldview that everyone is an angry ideologue, necessary to justify their own behavior.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by pythia__ on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @04:01AM (#11768315)
I think to focus on the angry ideologues is actually to divert the attention from the real issue, to the extent there is one; namely, that neurotypical humans, whether happy or angry, have a strong, automatic in-group bias. If you are one you can't really stop having an in-group; the best you can do is try to give out-group ideas a fair shake.

Now, this ability appears to be quite rare. I wouldn't be surprised if, worse yet, the kind of personality needed to do it made you less likely to become a journalist. In short, I doubt you could staff a newsroom full of people receptive to out-group ideas. (And if you think that you, yourself, aren't biased this way without very strong evidence for it I would suggest you take an outside view, per https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Outside_view)

Because of all of this I'd appreciate a genuine answer to my question even if I end up disagreeing with it.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by hackuser on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:28AM (#11769979)
> If you are one you can't really stop having an in-group; the best you can do is try to give out-group ideas a fair shake.

> Now, this ability appears to be quite rare.

I disagree that it's nearly so difficult or rare. The U.S. rarely has been this polarized, and everyone used to share the same news sources (major network nightly news - which probably still are the leading sources). Again, I think this approach is just the justification of those who want ideological war rather than finding ways, as so many have done so often in history, to bring people together.

> the kind of personality needed to do it made you less likely to become a journalist

You are entitled to your opinion, of course, but I have no reason to believe this statement is accurate.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by soundwave106 on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:36PM (#11764307)
Personally, I will say that the notion of news "offending" due to editorial stance strikes me as an awful attitude to have. I am only "offended" by poorly thought out, sensationalist, over-emotional reporting that is devoid of facts and plays on fears (this type of "reporting" occurs on both sides, unfortunately). I may disagree with a well thought out opinion, but a well thought out opinion being actually offensive? What an awful thing to think!

At any rate, even back in the old days of media there certainly were many choices for conservative news. Jim Lehrer's PBS Newshour on TV, many regional newspapers, and business papers for instance. Populism had a few non-gossip national tabloids like the New York Post; talk radio too.

It is true that a lot of media was dominated by a modest-left stance (talk radio being the exception), but I don't find bias a problem per se (we all are biased after all). I lean modest liberal personally, but back when I actually watched TV news I thought the PBS Newshour was the best of the lot, as it seemed to avoid some of the scare story traps the "big three" occasionally worked themselves up over.

Of course, these days, thanks to the web, you have every opportunity to silo yourself in one bias you are not "offended by" if you want.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by hackuser on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @05:21PM (#11765601)
Thanks; those are excellent points IMHO. One important nit:

> poorly thought out, sensationalist, over-emotional reporting that is devoid of facts and plays on fears (this type of "reporting" occurs on both sides, unfortunately)

I think it's important to point out that this is a false equivalency. The conservative outlets that do reporting like this, such as Fox, Rush Limbaugh, the WSJ (it's editorial page, at least) etc. have far more audience than the liberal equivalents (the Huffington Post might be one, but I think even they are better than the three I mentioned).

If we try to be extra fair and say it's equivalent, we hide from what I think is the U.S.'s and world's biggest problem.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by wwweston on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:41PM (#11764367)
> Yes, the big ones are conservative, because every other one is liberal.

How would one measure this? How would one know if what they're detecting is not an opposing bias, but a lack of reinforcement of one's personal bias?

> Conservatives flock to places like Fox and WSJ because they're a refuge from the liberal bias that pervades the rest of the media

That's the story, anyway.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @03:11PM (#11764615)
The big corporate old media (including the so-called MSM) has a conservative bias overall, individual outlets ranging from the rightward half of the space covered by the Republican Party through the rightward half of the space covered by the Democratic Party.

The far right considers everything but the most right-wing fringe of that to be the "liberal" mainstream media

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by gmarx on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @04:07PM (#11765075)
Your statement is actually a lot of evidence that it isn't silly. They dominate AM radio has been something the liberals have been claiming as evidence against media bias for years. I'd say if the only place those people could get their views aired was AM radio it kind of proved the point that the mainstream media (TV, every newspaper and magazine except for those which are specifically conservative) accepts the slightly left of center as normal
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by sgeisenh on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:27PM (#11763557)
From the perspective of an American, the American MSM has a liberal bias. From the perspective of a citizen from most other first-world countries, the American MSM has a hardcore conservative bias.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by talmand on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:32PM (#11763609)
That's because it's comparing apples to oranges. Liberal/Conservative in America is not necessarily the same as Liberal/Conservative elsewhere.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by sgeisenh on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @03:19PM (#11764678)
That's literally the point I was trying to make. I don't think it's valuable to place media outlets on an isolated spectrum. Global information sharing is a reality. I gather my news from sources situated in various countries. And I judge their bias according to a somewhat global spectrum. The American spectrum is so perverted (mostly due to religious beliefs) that I often find it hard to place international sources within it.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by talmand on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @03:45PM (#11764902)
>> American spectrum is so perverted

As compared to what?

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by CM30 on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:29PM (#11764251)
From the perspective of this non American, the America mainstream media seems to have more of a 'pro corporation/pro establishment' bias than anything else. Why else would it be so eager to criticise both Trump and Sanders?
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by tremon on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:47PM (#11764409)
A "pro establishment bias" is a conservative bias.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by mcphage on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @04:12PM (#11765097)
> My anecdata suggests conservative outlets tend to acknowledge their bias

"Fair and Balanced"?

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by howlingfantods on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:37PM (#11763658)
Reality has a notorious liberal bias. Look at climate change, which went from scientific position to liberal position.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by jerf on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:44PM (#11763746)
Just so you know, I read "Reality has a $MY_POSITION bias" as "I've completely epistemically closed myself by reading only what I agree with". Perhaps not something you really want to advertise quite so loudly.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:23PM (#11764189)
Parroting lines from the Daily Show/Colbert Report only makes you seem credible to other young lefties. You're not going to win any converts from the other side; we'll tend to roll our eyes and dismiss the speaker.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by drewrv on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @04:15PM (#11765122)
The line stuck so well because it was so poignant when Colbert said it. This was a time when Karl Rove was criticizing people in the "reality based community" who "believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality."

Since then the republican party has gone even further off the deep end.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @05:03PM (#11765469)
>Since then the republican party has gone even further off the deep end.

Which you say, sincerely, because you're a liberal and the GOP is the other "team" or "tribe". There are plenty of us who don't think of ourselves as Democrats who see plenty of insanity on the left--look at the resurgence of socialism or the social justice crowd on campus and in the media.

Both parties have completely lost touch with voters, which is why we saw populist insurgencies in both. If there were more candidates in the Democratic primaries, we could just as easily have seen a Sanders nomination as we did a Trump one.

Claiming that political insanity is endemic to only one side ignores the batshit lunacy emanating from both camps.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by drewrv on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @06:07PM (#11765923)
There are plenty of republicans who believe their party is going off the deep end, Mitt Romney for example.

And I think there's a lot of insanity on the left too.

Thinking a liberal satirist made a good point does not make one a mindless tribal zombie.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by pythia__ on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @08:05PM (#11766650)
Look at both climate change and the genetics of intelligence to see how America's political groups deal with the scientific consensus.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by talmand on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:41PM (#11763713)
I'm going to have to remember this one.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by noobermin on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:12PM (#11763367)
I think this election has demonstrated the media's bias fairly well.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by drewrv on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @04:20PM (#11765156)
This cracks me up because some people believe the media has treated Sanders unfairly, others believe they've treated Trump unfairly. Maybe both.

Personally I believe left/right bias isn't that interesting. The media has a strong bias toward sensationalism, and in elections there's a strong bias toward reporting on a horse race. Maybe this is the bias you're talking about. IMO these biases have helped Trump and Sanders respectively.

What a weird society we live in where everyone thinks the media is biased and few agree on exactly how.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by duaneb on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:16PM (#11763420)
Yea, but not their own recognition of the bias (which is the useful part).
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by unlinker on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:17PM (#11763431)
Do you think they'd recognise their own bias? That would be like saying "we can't do journalism properly", because proper journalism is unbiased.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by vidarh on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:27PM (#11763552)
There is no such thing as unbiased journalism. Without bias, what you have is cacophony of competing interpretations of events. Even reporting "just the facts" consists of making judgement calls that introduce bias with respect to which facts you report, and what you accept as fact.

I'd rather have reports from sources that don't try to pretend to be unbiased.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by noobermin on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:15PM (#11764107)
cspan is probably the closest thing to unbiased journalism, it's great, but no, it isn't a money maker and is only entertaining to those truly seeking the raw content. I agree that for reporters, the least they can do is acknowledge their own bias. If anything, that acknowledgement goes far towards mitigating said bias.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by duaneb on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:26PM (#11763533)
> That would be like saying "we can't do journalism properly", because proper journalism is unbiased.

I'm not entirely sure about this. Trump's been eating the media's lunch in interviews; perhaps a more biased approach acknowledging his interview games would actually lead to better reporting.

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by ryanl0l on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @06:08PM (#11765931)
Without bias how do you pick your stories? Without bias how do you pick your sources? Bias towards official sources is ubiquitous.

Bias is an integral part of journalism, it's up to the reader to understand this fact and collect information from multiple sources (if they're so inclined).

Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by MisterBastahrd on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @11:17PM (#11767451)
The media's bias is towards sensationalism. Bernie has the personality of cold oatmeal.
Re:Facebook admits rogue employees may have shown bias again... by abiox on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @01:24PM (#11763505)
of course they're biased. profit-seeking enterprises are strongly incentivized to not bite the hand that feeds. (not that state news isn't subject to this.) as noam chomsky has talked about, they "manufacture consent".

you see it in say, chris matthews basically trying to "assassinate" sanders while cozying up to clinton.