Re:Monument Valley in Numbers: Year 2
by ambicapter on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:44AM
(#11751925)
Those F2P games are in a whole different league of replayability compared to Monument Valley. I played through MV once. The F2P games you refer to are endless competitions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
True, from a gamer's perspective those games are trash, but unfortunately studios discovered it's much easier to make money selling cocaine rather than a fine cuisine.
I think it's more like the difference between Chess and Magic The Gathering.
One is based on some sense of immutability, another is the result of constant iteration and community.
Just because they both end up being games doesn't mean they serve the same purpose
Immutability? Chess has tens of thousands of books written on all facets of the game. Its strategies have evolved over a period of centuries of study and development by countless players who have since lent their names, cities, or countries to those lines. Now, with the aid of computers, the game evolves at a faster rate than ever. What worked at one tournament may be refuted at the next! Chess is anything but immutable!
I think the distinction being made was more that Chess doesn't have weekly patch notes or pieces being added and removed on a regular basis.
Ahhh. Another interesting distinction is to compare game trees. Chess has a finite though extremely large game tree. MTG, on the other hand, is potentially infinite. Heck, MTG is even Turing complete so even a single play has the potential to fail to halt!
I feel like the "immutability" refers more to the rules and gameplay mechanics of chess than the strategies. Certainly the strategies of chess evolve, but that is a result of players developing new and different ways to play the game.
This is opposed to a game like Magic the Gathering, Hearthstone or even DOTA 2 where the strategies change because the game itself is constantly being changed
Depends on your definition of gamer; I'm sure the millions of people that love the games (and are willing to spend that much money on it) disagree with your assertion.
Whoa there. We cannot fall into the trap of slandering the competition to excuse ourselves for not doing as well. I have never played the game in question, in fact hadn't heard about it till today; guess I don't get out much.
Its apparent that the definition of gamers isn't what some suspect it to be. Which means, which segment are you aiming for and are you hitting it. Again, make sure you are hitting where you want to and don't use the low sales as proof.
The same is true of movies. The regurgative crap pulls in the bux, so that's what's made. It makes more sense when you think of the industry as a business rather than a charity.
Theoretically, yes. But I've played plenty of F2P games without dumping a single cent in, eventually hit the paywall and delete the game. (I think the minute you pay a single penny into the game, sunk cost fallacy sets in, so I avoid starting that in the first place).
Is that "I already spent Xk$ for that to have been worthwhile I really should buy this other thing for y$?"
Pretty much. I wouldn't be surprised if F2P games price their offerings to get people "on the treadmill". As they progress through the game it starts requiring more and more money to sustain your current pace.
This task is supposed to take you 1 day but we'll let you skip to playing the game for 0.10$!
Re:Monument Valley in Numbers: Year 2
by iwannayoyo on Monday May 23, 2016 @08:48PM
(#11758164)
That being said, I think the utility I get from each game is probably equivalent. Monument valley was an amazing experience, where as these games are several alright experiences that add up to about the same level of enjoyment.