News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by IkmoIkmo on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:23AM (#11744290)
This is a decent article but it's flawed in some ways.

Some of it is simply outright wrong:

> The narrative of return and independence also presents many practical challenges. In 1976, the Moroccan “Green March” sent 350,000 Moroccans into the Western Sahara to settle, massively altering the demographics in the sparsely populated region.

The Green March was a peaceful march of 350k unarmed Moroccans into the region, that pushed out the Spaniards who had colonised it. Not a single bullet was fired, and these 350k people didn't settle there at all, they went straight back home.

On the other hand, in the past 40 years people have come to settle in the region, mostly driven by business opportunities as it's being invested in by Morocco. This is changing the demographics, but very much unrelated to the Green March. It's these quite clear errors that show the author isn't doing the proper research.

Anyway what bothers me the most is that it's so one-sided. I don't mind when authors take up a position at all, and I too am empathetic with the plight of the Sahrawi's, but it's a deeply complex issue with many facets left unspoken. Like the role of Algeria, which has financed the military rebellion for decades. And not for moral reasons, because they think it's the 'right thing to do'. Morocco and Algeria had been in a cold war, one was allied to the west/us, the other to the soviet union. Algeria also had no direct access to the ocean outside of the med. sea, and wants to build a road through the western sahara to get to a free standing port. None of this is mentioned at all, we only hear of the poor human interest story of a refugee girl who's described as a perfect western hollywood story: poor but desperate to go to school etc, read it yourself it's a bit corny.

Fact is, Morocco's various dynasties have ruled over these lands a long time. The Sahrawi's are berbers, just like Moroccans (and Algerians and Tunisians btw, they're all very similar peoples). Morocco is willing to invest heavily into the region, and is looking to give large degrees of autonomy, like has been ongoing in Morocco itself (a country which has many different berber groups, who've been getting increased autonomy, respect, special educational programmes, cultural recognition etc). But Morocco is not looking to lose territory to a few hundred thousand people under the influence of Algeria. The notion that this vast piece of land, if left alone by Morocco, will be independently and without other influences (e.g. Algeria) be ruled by a few hundred thousand people, and run as a successful nation, more so than as a part of Morocco, is I think naive.

So I fully support their right to self determination, but I'm also cognisant that it's paired with a complex geopolitical story that's left unsaid in this article, and honestly I think the best and most sensible outcome is an autonomous region within Morocco.

Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by toyg on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:49AM (#11744346)
Morocco ain't a paradise either, though. It's an absolutist monarchy backed by brutal and vicious secret police, with huge poverty, huge inequalities, lots of corruption, no free press... even the concept of having a "cold war" with Algeria in 2016 is laughable, Algerians itself having bigger fish to fry than trying to expand their territory (considering they're barely in control of what they already have).

The Saharawi situation is one of those where the bigger guy (in this case, Morocco) has to grow the f* up, make a magnanimous act, and live happily ever after. Grant independence and be done with it; hell, if you really care, include in the agreement a free-trade no-border clause guaranteed for 50 years or something. The alternative is simply worse: Polisario and their refugee camps will forever be at the mercy of whichever enemy of Morocco wanted to stir shit up, not unlike what happens at the other end of the Mediterranean.

Territorial disputes resolved with guns, in 2016, are for the weak. Moroccans can be better than this.

Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by BurningFrog on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:20AM (#11744748)
How precisely were the Spaniards "pushed out"?
Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by IkmoIkmo on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#11745348)
They left, because they didn't want to risk a colonial war.

See for example France and Algeria just a decade earlier, which cost between 350k and 1.5m lives depending on the estimate.

Around the 1970s essentially it was clear that everything would be decolonized before the end of the 20th century, except places where you actually had 'your' people live a long time, like in Ceuta which is effectively Spanish. The Western Sahara wasn't like that, Spaniards didn't live there, it was just a military occupation for the resources there, so they knew eventually they'd have to give it up. No reason to risk a bloodshed then.

In the 1950s or 1960s there was still a lot of resistance to various independence movements, by mid 1970s there was no real question of if colonial powers would have to withdraw, only when. It was a sensible Spanish decision, only very poorly executed.

Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by BurningFrog on Saturday May 21, 2016 @09:49PM (#11747070)
You wrote "The Green March was a peaceful march of 350k unarmed Moroccans into the region, that pushed out the Spaniards who had colonised it"

That sounds like they were pushed out by the marching Moroccans during a few day, not that they calmly decided it was time to move to Spain.

Re:The Fading Dream to Liberate Africa’s Last Colony by IkmoIkmo on Sunday May 22, 2016 @07:53AM (#11748243)
They were pushed out because if they didn't leave there'd be bloodshed. How hard is that to imagine?

At the same time, they calmly left. These two things are not mutually exclusive.

i.e. if a squatter goes to my house while I'm on vacation and lives there, for personal safety reasons he has a gun as do I, and I come home and make it clear it's not going to end well for either of us if he's going to stay, and the squatter makes the sensible choice to leave behind what is not his peacefully and go back to where he came from, you can say that he was pushed out by my presence on the scene. After all, if I hadn't been there he'd likely have stayed.

That's the best analogy I can think of to explain it to you.

Decolonisation was rarely peaceful, in this case it was. But even if it was peaceful, it doesn't mean Spain left for no reason. They were pressured to leave my hundreds of thousands of civilians descending on a piece of land that wasn't theirs with the support of the country. That showed them, if they wanted to keep the land, there'd be a colonial war. And if the 50s and 60s taught the world anything, it's that colonial powers always lose their stake in the end, but not before hundreds of thousands of unnecessary lives get ruined. Further, it creates animosity that lasts for many decades. Algerians and French for example still have deep wounds that need to heal, this was a post WWII war that saw massive death, destruction, torture, assassinations etc, it was quite brutal. Spain made a more sensible choice in this particular territory.