Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede...
by ckozlowski on Friday May 20, 2016 @11:26PM
(#11743052)
>there is an argument that current F1 cars are more energy efficient than a tesla
It does sound like click-bait, but I see the point they're making there. No one is proposing we all drive F1s, but for that performance regime, under those conditions, F1 is more efficient with it's energy usage in achieving a target output than a Tesla would be. I'm sure that decreases dramatically driving at pedestrian speeds.
It reminds me a bit of when I first read about the SR-71's J58 engine. I'm trying to remember where I saw it (I think it was in the book "Skunk Works") in that the SR-71 was actually most efficient running at Mach 3.2 than it was running at lower speeds. Seems counter-intuitive, but like F1, that was the situation for which it was designed.
Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede...
by nopzor on Saturday May 21, 2016 @12:11PM
(#11745152)
Yes, the SR-71 was happiest at mach 3+. At these speeds, metal expansion due to heat would seal the airplane frame up too. Designed for its mission. Insanely, it would literally leak fuel on the ground.
Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede...
by yborg on Friday May 20, 2016 @10:53PM
(#11742970)
They are also considerably more expensive than a Tesla.
http://raconteur.net/infographics/the-economics-of-formula-1
Sorry to be a buzzkill but this is not correct
The engines are not camless. However, they are 'spring less' in a traditional sense. In the early 1990's the typical wound wire springs were replaced with pneumatically charged cylinder that functions as the spring. The reason was do to the inability to create wound wire springs that did not encounter harmonic issues as RPM went up and a more efficient valve closing action. However, through all of this, the camshaft itself is retained.This allowed engines to reach over 20k rpm (which sounds unreal) but the current regulations, introduced in 2014, limit them to 15k and they typically run less due to rules that limit fuel flow at higher RPMs.
The Koenisegg on the other hand is absolutely camless technology they call Free valve and it is a marvel. It not only allows control of the profile, overall, but a on a cylinder by cylinder valve by valve basis.
Similar thing with Mercedes' turbo charger. It is split, and it is impressive, but the benefits are more complex simply gaining from placing the compressor and turbine at different ends of the engine (e.g., moving intake charge away from exhaust heat, providing space for an ultra highspeed motor/generator on the turbo shaft) etc.
At the risk of sharing clickbait...there is an argument that current F1 cars are more energy efficient than a tesla (http://www.espn.co.uk/f1/story/_/id/15152695/f1-cars-more-ef...)