News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by cryptoz on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:45PM (#11741774)
Link to Project Ara Developer Edition page: https://atap.google.com/ara/

r/android seems unimpressed because many of the initially removable components are no longer removable (at least, as indicated by marketing videos) [1]. However, it seems silly to me to get upset about this because this is a Developer Edition and Google clearly had to limit the scope of the project in order to ship. Though, one wonders if there are physical limits causing the CPU, GPU, battery, and display to be non-removable. We'll see.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/4k9bwr/project_ara...

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by squeaky-clean on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:43PM (#11742116)
> because many of the initially removable components are no longer removable

It's not that "many" of the components aren't available, it's all the components anyone cared about. It seems like you won't be able to swap out the CPU, GPU, RAM, battery or screen. So if you want a phone with a faster CPU, you need to buy an entirely new phone, which goes against all the hype for these modular phone plans.

From the venturebeat article linked below: "The idea of Ara is to ensure that your devices are future-proofed, meaning that the whole “upgrade every two years” mentality is no longer a thing. ". This certainly isn't true. Though I guess it could be slightly cheaper, since you would be just buying a frame, and could pop in your old camera module.

There also aren't any modules being shown that can clue you into what the potential is. The only thing recognizable is a camera module, and what I'm guessing is a small e-ink display., every other module is just an unlabeled colored/textured rectangle. In every article about it the only example ever used is a camera.

The module idea actually seems really cool, a standard way for anyone to create hardware for your phone. But I think the "modular phone. Upgrade one bit a time. Never obsolete." marketing angle is a blatant lie.

Edit: I agree with one of the jokes in that Reddit thread about this

    Here's what I want for my six modules:
      1. Camera
      2. Battery
      3. Battery
      4. Battery
      5. Battery
      6. Battery
Because really, what else is there?
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by malandrew on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:49PM (#11742615)
Different types of cameras such as night vision or infrared heat camera. Also laser range finder modules or something capable of stereoscopic vision. Altimeters. Barometric pressure sensors. Communicator modules for other peripherals when Bluetooth isn't appropriate. Temperature sensor. Wind speed device (would have to protrude beyond the phone's edge so wind can pass through). Light sensor for automatic white balance measurements. Chording keypads to enable more interesting input for power users.

Anyways that's just a stream of conscious I came up with in 5 minutes of noodling. There is potential. Maybe not as much for day to day, but definitely options for professionals that make their living outdoors.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by onion2k on Saturday May 21, 2016 @02:45AM (#11743504)
Having access to those things sounds brilliant. I'd guess that while we might see Ara on the market one day, we're also likely to see standard Android phones with a single Ara accessory port on the back, perhaps replacing the built in camera. That gives users the swappable modules advantage of Ara with the cost/weight/durability benefits of a typical device.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by beambot on Friday May 20, 2016 @09:29PM (#11742719)
Medical sensors -- eg. portable blood analyzer.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by jonknee on Saturday May 21, 2016 @12:50AM (#11743251)
Theranos can pivot!
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by baobabaobab on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:18AM (#11744742)
>but definitely options for professionals that make their living outdoors

My thinking was also that this makes a great platform for professional tools that are currently standalone devices. Multimeters, surveying equipment, thermal inspection tools. Maybe a microscope or even a microfluidics device.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by tdkl on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:09AM (#11744090)
And Google will be glad to deliver all those types of cameras, because they can't bring StreetView in your home - yet.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by hutzlibu on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:06AM (#11744400)
So ... streetview requires nightvision and won't be happy with cameras beeing there allready?
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by asuffield on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:57AM (#11744513)
(Tedious disclaimer: my opinion only, not speaking for anybody else. I'm an SRE at Google.)

> It's not that "many" of the components aren't available, it's all the components anyone cared about. It seems like you won't be able to swap out the CPU, GPU, RAM, battery or screen.

The article addresses this directly:

"After lots of research and testing, they made a big decision: rather than turn every single piece of the phone into modules, from the processor to the RAM to the hard drive, they’d consolidate all that into the standard frame. They found that people don't care about, or want to think about, the processor in their phone. And they especially don't want to worry about it being compatible with all their apps. Users just want a good phone with good specs that does all the basics well, and then they want a place to play on top of that."

They did the research. It turned out that people didn't care about those components after all.

If you think your research is better, build the product.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:13AM (#11744725)
Did the research ask how many people wanted to carry around a bag/box of spare modules they might need during the day, or how big the bag/box would need to be?

>If you think your research is better, build the product.

Or not.

I'm all for experimentation, but hardware is always tricky, and the original idea - open source hardware - has always been problematic.

It looks like the cost of module development is going to be way outside the budget of individuals, security is going to be an issue, and unless the platform builds a big ecosystem very quickly - possible, but unlikely - there's going to be little incentive for companies to join up.

ARA makes perfect sense as a concept phone for hardware research, but I'm less convinced it can ever be a viable popular commercial product.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by squeaky-clean on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @04:54PM (#11772999)
> If you think your research is better, build the product.

I've been saying since the announcement of Ara (and even earlier with that Phonebloks Kickstarter) that it will not work.

So if you'd like to put it that way... I guess my research was better. Also, I have not built a modular phone, but neither has Google. Since I didn't spend 2 years not building the phone, I guess my non-existent product is better too.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by Ressuder on Saturday May 21, 2016 @09:58AM (#11744679)
And you don't find it curious that what made the original concept implausible suddenly is found to "not be desired" by costumers?
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by asuffield on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:16AM (#11744737)
I find it entirely reasonable that research shows consumers don't want products that don't work very well. The text I quoted explicitly called out that it would be a software compatibility nightmare.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by ethanbond on Saturday May 21, 2016 @11:56AM (#11745091)
So then what modularity do they think consumers do care about?

And yes, that was exactly what everyone was saying from the beginning: it's infeasible to do what Ara was dreamt up to do.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by asuffield on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:28PM (#11745410)
Sure, I can find that section of the article for you:

"Which brings us to the most important question still facing Project Ara: what the hell kind of modules are people going to build? Woolridge and his team took their user research to the Mobile World Congress conference in Barcelona in February, where they started showing it to potential partners: carriers, tech companies, fashion brands, everyone.

Turns out they all have ideas. Better speakers, flashlights, panic buttons, fitness trackers, projectors, app-shortcut buttons, kickstands, a million other things. Some are incredibly high-tech—pro-level cameras clearly fascinate the Ara team, and they all get excited at the idea of replacing my hideous tape recorder with a microphone module—but some aren’t. Bertrand shows me a small compact case for storing makeup, and a small hollow pillbox. They’re also building “style” modules, which don’t do anything except look nice. Apparently, when given the opportunity to make anything that plugs into their phone, people come up with some pretty useless ideas."

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by ethanbond on Sunday May 22, 2016 @09:34AM (#11748513)
> potential partners... Carriers, tech companies, fashion brands

Aka the people whose weird priorities got us to this position (needing/wanting Ara) to begin with?

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by 8note on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:32PM (#11742556)
Id go for two cameras, and try to hack some 3D recording out of it.

and replacement inertial sensors, those always seem to break on me.

edit: actually, it would be cool to put an FPGA on there.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by hutzlibu on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:07AM (#11744404)
What would you do with it?
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by DanGarcia595 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:31AM (#11744462)
In theory a lot of things. Depending on how much hardware you could synthesize, you'd only be limited by your IO and size. You could have a module that is able to be modified by software.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by fu9ar on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:45PM (#11742606)
off of the top of my head:

SDR, Storage, bigger/better Speakers, more USB/whatever ports, HDMI output, video Projector, JTAG (why not?), RFID

edit: oh, temperature/barometer built into the device would be pretty cool too.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by Klathmon on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:55PM (#11742450)
From the article:

>“The key here,” Camargo says, “is to develop the functionality you don’t get on your smartphone today. I’ll give you the smartphone, so you don’t have to worry about it.”

It sounds to me the reason their "dev kit" includes so much "out of the box" is to spur development of newer more interesting modules.

Like you said, we all know that camera, storage, battery modules will be there, but they are pushing to see what others can come up with (blood sugar testers, credit-card readers, touchpads, temperature sensors, etc...)

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by wubbfindel on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:19AM (#11743934)
2 Cameras for recording in 3D? ;-)
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by LeoPanthera on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:18PM (#11741973)
I haven't read the Reddit comments (and I don't even own an Android phone) but... aren't those the things you would MOST want to upgrade in the future?
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by digi_owl on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:38PM (#11742090)
Bingo. SOC, screen and battery define the longevity of the device. Being able to upgrade those piecemeal moved mobile devices closer to that of the desktop PC (frankly if we could move the CPU onto a daughterboard i would be dancing with joy).

Also, screens are what most often break on a device, because glass don't deal well with sudden applications of force. Making them modular with a defined attachment system would be godsend for many butterfingers and parents.

All in all, what they are presenting now is things that can be done USB, WIFI or bluetooth.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by iainmerrick on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:44PM (#11742601)
At least the modules will get power from the case (I assume) so they won't all need their own batteries and chargers. That could be handy.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by chillingeffect on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:09PM (#11742257)
Given the economics of today's limitations, yes, that would be.

But if you knew, for example, that your camera could be used with your next two CPUs, you might make a longer term investment in a higher-quality camera.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by petra on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:25PM (#11742321)
I think OEM's pushed Google a bit, not wanting to kill the upgrade cycle. One sign for that is the non-removable battery - which is easy to do technically.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by rtkwe on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:04AM (#11743279)
I'm not so sure. Look at the module sizes the largest one at the bottom is still much smaller than modern batteries. If the battery had to be in one of those they'd have issues with longevity. Maybe allowing additional packs but trying to fit a main battery into it is going to require compromises somewhere.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by x1798DE on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:28PM (#11742029)
They couldn't even make the battery removable? That's pretty weak for something touted as a modular phone.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by notatoad on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:01PM (#11742229)
the core of the phone contains a non-removable battery. That doesn't mean you can't attach supplementary battery modules to it.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by x1798DE on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:07PM (#11745331)
You can attach a supplemental battery pack to any phone, but many normal phones (such as every phone I've ever owned) have replaceable batteries. It seems hard to believe that if you're going to make a phone specifically touted as being modular you'd be less modular than other phones already on the market.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by notatoad on Saturday May 21, 2016 @03:22PM (#11745808)
The original Ara prototype had a small internal battery to allow hot-swapping of the battery modules. I'm not sure if this has changed and it's now more of a standalone battery, but it used to only give you about 5 minutes of power.

One of the big criticisms of the LG G5's claims of "modularity" was that the battery couldn't be hot swapped, so it seems that some level of internal battery is necessary for modularity.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by asdz on Friday May 20, 2016 @10:34PM (#11742916)
if they are making all battery removable, most probably they will have to start a support line for everyone who can't power on their device :) Cust A - "Why can't I power on my device? I charge it"
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by digi_owl on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:25PM (#11742318)
Except that they had a more modular device booting on stage a year ago.

And shipping this as a dev device will limit the scope of ideas developers will implement.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by Klathmon on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:51PM (#11742434)
Actually it looks like the reason their dev kit includes so much in the "base" is exactly the opposite reason:

> “The key here,” Camargo says, “is to develop the functionality you don’t get on your smartphone today. I’ll give you the smartphone, so you don’t have to worry about it.”

They are including an entire phone as the "base" in order to get developers to create new and interesting modules for it.

Everyone and anyone can make a battery, or an SD card reader, they want to see what other things people can come up with.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by digi_owl on Saturday May 21, 2016 @11:17AM (#11744933)
Hrmf, between this and all the talk about a module marketplace i wonder if they are trying to avoid a "PC clones" scenario. Meaning that if all they control is the endo, and someone else releases a clean room implementation of same, Google's control of the ecosystem goes out the window...
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by Zak on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:28AM (#11744459)
It seems to me that treating the frame containing these components as just another module is reasonable enough. That said, the battery is the number one item I want to be easily replaceable. Not only is it a big help to be able to carry spares, but Li-ion batteries degrade over time and put a limit on the useful life of a device even if its capabilities still suit the user.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by listic on Saturday May 21, 2016 @12:33PM (#11745237)
I like that they showed a pill box application. That's the one I could use in my smartphone.

It doesn't have to be just a passive box; it could have a companion app and door open sensor. I'm using a separate device for that: http://www.amazon.com/Reizen-Vibrating-Five-Alarm-Pill/dp/B0...

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by listic on Saturday May 21, 2016 @12:11PM (#11745151)
> many of the initially removable components are no longer removable

'many' is CPU+GPU+RAM, which was going to be a single module, but now is part of the frame, right?

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by DiabloD3 on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:07PM (#11742250)
That basically kills it for me. The only reason I was interested was to be able to transform a phone into a larger tablet just by swapping the screen module out.

Oh well.

Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by onion2k on Saturday May 21, 2016 @02:36AM (#11743478)
There's no reason why you couldn't add a "tablet screen" module. It doesn't have to replace an existing feature; a module could suppliment a feature.
Re:Project Ara Lives: Google's Modular Phone by JBiserkov on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:57AM (#11744372)
You are correct, and this has been done already: http://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?sName=Padfone

The disadvantage is that you are still carrying the smaller screen without using it, so it adds to the weight/volume of the device.