just plain

    for line in yourfile:
        print line

with yourfile containing non-ascii characters and running it in windows console.

That sounds like a limitation of the Windows console, not the programming language.

It's a limitation of how the programming language interacts with the Windows console, and it's a mistake. If you are writing potentially-garbled strings directly to the console, there is already no guarantee that the output will properly reflect the string or e.g. copying and pasting will work correctly, because the string could include backspace characters, or a ton of newlines. Therefore it doesn't make sense to do anything other than make a 'best effort' attempt when rendering strings to the console, including with Unicode handling. If it works, great, but if the string is invalid Unicode, that's only one of multiple problematic cases, so what exactly is throwing an exception supposed to accomplish? Python should use replacement characters by default in this case.

Stop using the Windows console. Or fix it. More rational than a breaking upgrade to Python 3.

Fixing the Windows console rather than upgrading to Python 3 is the only sensible choice.

</s>

It is, and Java has similar problems on Windows. The Windows console can be switched to Unicode, but by default, it emulates the IBM 5150 PC character set, circa 1980. It's not even ISO LATIN-1.

Works fine on Linux.

Windows console shpport is broken on python 3 too on many versions. Click the library can print unicode to the console on windows however. No python 3 needed.

> Citation needed.

I'm sorry to say, but your code for example. While I love your click library it has many small issues. Which annoy the heck out of me.

I would submit a patch but this is not a simple change and requires a bit of effort. Perhaps I'll find some time to work on it, but I'm afraid it might possibly break compatibility.

Can you talk specifics about what does not work? Because if there is an actual unicode problem in click i want to fix it.

Would have to go over the rest of code, but the code in ClickException is broken:

    class ClickException(Exception):
        """An exception that Click can handle and show to the user."""

        #: The exit code for this exception
        exit_code = 1

        def __init__(self, message):
            ctor_msg = message
            if PY2:
                if ctor_msg is not None:
                    ctor_msg = ctor_msg.encode('utf-8')
            Exception.__init__(self, ctor_msg)
            self.message = message

        def format_message(self):
            return self.message

        def __unicode__(self):
            return self.message

        def __str__(self):
            return self.message.encode('utf-8')

        def show(self, file=None):
            if file is None:
                file = get_text_stderr()
            echo('Error: %s' % self.format_message(), file=file)

This code is arguably wrong. I think I understand what you were trying to do, but I'm not certain. There is a possibility to use it correctly in python 2 though, but many people might be not aware of it.

In python 3 you pass the message as is (it might cause another issue, but about that later).

In python 2 you immediately encode the passed variable using utf-8. This means that you're expecting argument to be of unicode type, but at the same time you're discouraging users to use unicode_literals, and in most situations users will pass a regular string.

In python 3 __str__ is trying to convert text to bytes, while the message would already be text. This most of the times will look correct, but it might spew garbage when there are non ascii characters.

Here's corrected code (did not test it though):

    if PY2:
      unicode = str

    class ClickException(Exception):
        """An exception that Click can handle and show to the user."""

        #: The exit code for this exception
        exit_code = 1

        def __init__(self, message):
            if PY2 and isinstance(self, unicode):
                message = message.encode()
            Exception.__init__(self, message)
            self.message = message

        def format_message(self):
            return self.message

        def __unicode__(self):
            return str(self).decode()

        def __str__(self):
            return str(self.message)

        def show(self, file=None):
            if file is None:
                file = get_text_stderr()
            echo('Error: %s' % self.format_message(), file=file)

There are few other things that gives headaches (not necessarily python 2 only).

In python 3 for example click refuses to run if LANG and LC_CTYPE are not defined. Why doesn't it simply do what all other applications are doing and simply fall back to latin-1 (ISO-8859-1) instead of printing the error.

Also, another issue (and my above code is also is affected by this). Click is checking for environmental variables before continuing, yet encode and decode have hardcoded utf-8. It probably should use whatever locale.getdefaultlocale() returns.