News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @12:02AM (#1172899)
Girls in general are better people and killing them is plain stupid.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by riffic on Sunday March 07, 2010 @02:18AM (#1173026)
I agree with this.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @02:51AM (#1173056)
Honestly, why would anyone take offence at this and downvote? Most of human history has been dominated by men and it has been war after war after war. Throw in the several male prophets whose followers have created several religions and the subsequent strife and women win by at least 1000 points. At this point it shouldn't even be an issue which is the better gender.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by araneae on Sunday March 07, 2010 @10:14AM (#1173459)
There's a bit of cognitive dissonance in your post. It's obvious that you think that the reason that men have been the head of wars is innate, biological determinism. Yet men have also been the ones who developed science and technology. On HN, almost all of us are men. Is that also due to innate, biological determinism? If not, how do you explain the fact that all the things you dislike about men are innate, and all the things you like are not? And if yes, how can you say that women are better than men? Do you not value science, technology, and entrepreneurship?
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by geebee on Sunday March 07, 2010 @12:03PM (#1173606)
Unfortunately, this dissonance seems very widespread. I think it comes from a very uncomfortable compromise between two divergent perspectives on biological differences between men and women.

Some people think that innate differences are extremely minor, while others attribute major cognitive and behavior traits to gender.

Perspective 1 is appealing to people women admire the amazing things men have done, such as develop a vaccination against polio or smallpox, or splitting the atom, and want to see more participation from women. Perspective 2 is appealing to women who are appalled with the negative things men have done, such as spreading the plague to invade a city or dropping an atomic bomb on a city, and want to believe that women would never do such a thing.

So the uncomfortable compromise is that men and women are the same, except for the countless ways in which women are better.

Of course, I don't know how much is innate and how much is cultural, but I'm almost certain that the whole "if it's bad, it's innate to men, if it's good, it's just because women have lacked opportunities" is total crap.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:40PM (#1174057)
When you reduce it to a straw man it certainly is crap but thousands of years of history is a hard thing to ignore.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by DaniFong on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:45PM (#1173968)
Memes are sticker, spread faster, and far more powerful than genes. It's the negative memes of the male segment of civilizations that beget violence; it is to a great extent negative memes that have suppressed women over the years. What's good is that the memes composing an individual can actually be altered -- mutamemic activity. What's bad is that mindsets are set pretty early on in life; you can't change much in the vast majority of people until much later. In this way the lines between innate determinism of biology and determinism/influence of culture are blurred.

It is probably difficult to understand the historical effect of women being cut out of the academy, and otherwise ignored, unless you read some accounts of it. Simone de'Beauvoir's "memoirs of a beautiful daughter" and "the second sex" may explain much to you.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by DaniFong on Sunday March 07, 2010 @06:00PM (#1174192)
*'memoirs of a dutiful daughter'
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:37PM (#1174053)
Everyone keeps reiterating the inventive and creative aspects of men but I don't see why. Nothing in my post mentioned any of that and it's not really a rebuttal of my viewpoint. Most people, male or female, are capable of the same intellectual tasks so saying men are capable of great things doesn't really mean much. When you have to stay home for 9 months and then take care of another human being for another 6-7 years and still have the energy and time to be as creative and inventive then I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

What makes you think I don't value science and technology. Just because I don't approve of the man doing the work does not mean his work does not have merit.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by relay on Sunday March 07, 2010 @11:58AM (#1173594)
I'm not going to argue on nature vs nurture but I will ask you a hypothetical question.. if you had to make a choice between fast evolution of "science, technology, entrepreneurship" and a peaceful world without war nor violence, which would you take ?

If (I have no idea whether it's the case or not) biological determinism was true and those views were confirmed, I still wouldn't see women as inferior. Being smart enough to create and have low enough morals to use the atomic bomb is NOT a gift, it's a curse.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by araneae on Sunday March 07, 2010 @02:09PM (#1173807)
Ask girls about their experiences in all girls schools and ask them if they'd like to experience that for the rest of their lives. It's unlikely that killing off all men and then cloning the remaining females is a viable solution to world peace.

In answer to your actual question, though, you proffer a world with no war in violence as an ideal. However, I challenge that idea that you would even enjoy living in such a world; or at least enjoy living in such a world that is necessitated by a total lack of violence.

In elementary school, we learned that the central element to every story is conflict. A story with no conflict is boring. The same is true of life.

And then add to that that it's impossible to have a world without conflict without giving everyone a lobotomy, which would then result in the sudden collapse of civilization and the extinction of the human race...

It's a very simplistic world view you have that all violence is wrong. Sometimes violence is necessary, and sometimes it's entertaining (sports or action movies, anyone? Or a good beheading in the old days?). But even if you disagree on those two points, conflict is inherent in any system where individuals of the same species compete for resources.

There are such things as dumb questions, especially if they're hypothetical.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by relay on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:51PM (#1174074)
My world view is not any more simplistic than your biased view based on western culture.The buddhist's nirvana is the absence of desire and while they believe in reincarnation, they see it as a curse to those who are too much anchored to their wealth and earthly delights. What seems boring to you is some other people idea of paradise. I'm not religious myself but I feel dramatically attracted by the underlying philosophy of Buddhism. There is something wrong with you if you think that life needs to perpetuate violence for thrill's sake.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by lionhearted on Monday March 08, 2010 @02:36AM (#1174939)
> The buddhist's nirvana is the absence of desire and while they believe in reincarnation, they see it as a curse to those who are too much anchored to their wealth and earthly delights.

As a sidenote, I know Buddhism is quite popular in the West these days, but after spending time in Asia, I don't see it as superior in practice to the Western religions. The best of Buddhism, the most interesting and enlightening concepts make it to the West. But they have just as much silly superstition, social control, religious rank and hierarchy, and warriorship/violence in their history as the Western religions. Actually, some of the finest fighters of their era are the Shaolin and Honganji monks of China and Japan, who were at times much equivalently brutal to crusdaders and jihadists.

As for me personally, I think struggle is a good thing. I think all the most important and valuable aspects of life are struggle - living, thriving, growing. Childbirth, one of the heights of human experience, is a brutal struggle. Farming is struggle, hunting is struggle, cooking is struggle. Training to dance or sing or play an instrument is struggle. I'm with you on non-materialism as accumulating stuff isn't particularly effective, but I (personally) reject the notion that struggle is bad. All the best parts of life are a struggle or the fruits of struggle. I embrace struggle, I embrace suffering for worthy causes - suffering in exercise, in farming, in hunting, in cooking, in dancing, in having and rearing children. It's all struggle - I don't want nirvana, give me this world and its struggles and sufferings, and I'll embrace it fully.

> There is something wrong with you if you think that life needs to perpetuate violence for thrill's sake.

This I agree with, but I think the original commentor's point was a bit more nuanced than that. I think he was saying conflict is necessary at times for life, and he was also noting that people do enjoy observing conflict and drama playing out. Myself, I've got mixed feelings on this - you know, I much prefer baseball to American football for instance. I played linebacker in high school, but watching a 6'6 220 pound receiver catch a pass in the air and get destroyed by a 6'4 260 pound safety while he's largely helpless makes me cringe a little. The strategy aspect of American football I quite like, the brutality of it not so much. So I'm with you on some points, less so on others.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:43PM (#1174062)
Ya, what's so nice about a world where there is no genocide and mass murder? I am not against conflict and you are deliberately using two meanings of the word to make your "point".
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by geebee on Sunday March 07, 2010 @12:05PM (#1173609)
We posted at the same time. I actually agree with you. The only thing that really irritates me is they way some people are willing to assign "innate" or "cultural" based (it appears) on nothing more than whether they consider the activity to be good or bad.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by allenbrunson on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:34AM (#1173084)
Even if true, it's a very polarizing thing to say. It drags the conversation towards an unhealthy, flamey place.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:39AM (#1173088)
If somebody disagrees I would like to know their stance on it and their argument against my view. Being downvoted certainly says people don't approve of the comment but I don't see how it's polarizing or why it's wrong to make polarizing comments if there is a modicum of truth in it. I'll chalk it up to my Asperger's syndrome.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by potatolicious on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:56AM (#1173106)
Saying something so obviously controversial and polarizing demands more backup than the mere statement itself. You know your opinion is going to be unpopular, so the onus is upon you to expand upon that idea in your original post, otherwise it looks like you're just trolling.

In response to your later justification, though, most western societies have been patriarchal, so the fact that we've been very successful at fighting and killing each other is not an indication that women somehow would not if given the chance.

Your argument breaks down to this: since men are so bad at keeping the peace, women must therefore be better at it.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:05AM (#1173116)
In response to your later justification, though, most western societies have been patriarchal, so the fact that we've been very successful at fighting and killing each other is not an indication that women somehow would not if given the chance.

But that's just it. The entire time men have been behaving badly women haven't even shown the slightest interest in participating so that's already evidence enough for me to make some conclusions about which is the more docile and empathetic gender.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by potatolicious on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:58AM (#1173157)
Slightest interest in participating? You realize that in most western, patriarchal societies women were not allowed to participate?

Not to mention, many Native American cultures were matriarchal, and had absolutely no compunction about slaughtering each other there, either.

I find it somewhat ironic that your justification for saying that women are better than men is that they are more docile and empathetic - the very same reasons that were trotted about to try and deny women the vote (i.e., too docile and easily led by the nose politically, too emotional to vote rationally, etc). It's hard to consider you pro-female when you seem to riding the same train of thought as anti-female folk.

I do mean this in the most sincere, respectful way possible: have you considered taking a course in anthropology at your local university? I studied anthropology in a limited way during my time college, it was very eye-opening, and IMHO your viewpoint wouldn't stand up to a simple gut check against even introductory undergrad-level anthro. I know this may sound like I'm bashing you, but I'm really not trying to - IMHO you seem like you have a lot of misconceptions about culture and history which can be rectified by formal education on this subject.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:28PM (#1174037)
You throw around the word patriarchial as if you know what it means. It is a very loaded word and you should define it so I know exactly what you mean. Women have been allowed to participate but not in the way men have been allowed to participate and wanted to participate. I don't know enough about native american culture to comment but I know in jewish culture the family name passes through the female line and men are still the ones committing most of the crimes and fighting most of the wars.

I didn't use docile in a negative way. I meant they are less likely to use aggression as a means of resolving conflict. There is nothing anti-female in my stance.

Thanks for the anthropology tip but now you are contradicting yourself. Most of formal education is simply a reflection of the attitudes and mores of the current times especially when it comes to classes like anthropology, sociology, psychology, etc. Most people that are technically trained, math, physics, cs, etc. are quite blind to this aspect of education. What do you think they taught in anthropology, sociology, psychology classes when women had very few rights, that women were the best ever? No, those classes reflected the attitudes of men learning and teaching in higher education and the same is true now, except now depending on who teaches the classes you might get an anti-male view or a "balanced" one.

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by lionhearted on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:36AM (#1173139)
> The entire time men have been behaving badly women haven't even shown the slightest interest in participating so that's already evidence enough for me to make some conclusions about which is the more docile and empathetic gender.

While we're broadly generalizing, does the fact that men have accounted for 95%+ of all inventions, scientific breakthroughs, philosophy, and governance in history mean men are more proactive and hard working to go alongside women being more docile and empathetic? And does this lend itself easily to a judgment that a particular gender is better?

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by greenlblue on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:33PM (#1174046)
Obviously not. The societal pressures have been different but the thing about people is that it's hard to distinguish between what's actually innate and what's culturally enforced. So given the chance women would be just as proactive and inventive, heck we are already seeing that, but they wouldn't be as aggressive.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by ErrantX on Sunday March 07, 2010 @06:22AM (#1173219)
I think Boudica [1] is reasonable rebuttal to your point :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boudica

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by ErrantX on Monday March 08, 2010 @10:07AM (#1175439)
(huh? this is the exact same point the others are making? Have I got Boudica wrong..... ;))
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by Tichy on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:46AM (#1173150)
Hitler was also cheered on by women. There are plenty of examples of women doing evil things. Just a couple of weeks ago I think there was a female amok runner.

Also, men and women face different challenges in wife. For example I suppose in many primitive societies, if one tribe raided another, the enemy men were killed, but the enemy women were taken home and being married (just one example).

Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by olliesaunders on Sunday March 07, 2010 @07:12AM (#1173270)
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by Tichy on Sunday March 07, 2010 @07:38AM (#1173293)
I remembered that before I mentioned Hitler. So what? Hitler existed. Is he now "He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named"?
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by olliesaunders on Monday March 08, 2010 @08:21AM (#1175270)
No, I just thought it was funny.
Re:Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls by Tichy on Monday March 08, 2010 @10:40AM (#1175522)
Not even sure if it actually applied - according to Wikipedia, it applies to comparing people to Hitler or Nazis.