I don't think Zed's doing anything wrong. He's saying what he thinks needs to be said, he's challenging the complacent, and he's not pulling any punches. If you don't like his attitude there's plenty of other people to listen to. I appreciate that he's out there making noise, getting people to re-think their assumptions about programming.
If you live life by particular principles sometimes you have to take the hard road. You can't argue it hasn't been an interesting path.
Screw passion, I'd rather have discipline and a healthy interest instead.
>Has he at least mellowed out since 2007?
YesWhereas the guy we're discussing seems to actually think that Paul Graham, billionaire, wakes up every morning thinking "how, today, can I enable the vicious internet slander campaign against Zed Shaw? (I am so intimidated by his genius)."
What would happen if I decided to pay you back for HN Paul?
What would happen if I started honestly reviewing your startups’ products?
If I just picked the worst ones, and then started tearing them in half?
What would happen if I went on every HN hiring post and started
posting dirt about the various shit HR practices your companies have?
What if I took all this writing and got my friends
you’ve fucked over to help me broadcast it?
What if I started posting this writing as replies to many of your comments?
What if I started offering to advise new coders, the millions I teach a year
(yes, millions Paul) to avoid all of your company’s startups?
What would happen if I just started putting anti-YC ads on my properties?
What if I started telling everyone how you take
7% and don’t give startups any real guidance?
What would happen if I started talking about the crazy bullshit I know
has happened at YC startups I’ve worked for and others have told me about?
Er… nothing?No, it's a blatant ad hominem.
The guy invested his time and effort trying to improve the world by writing a technical book, which he then proceeded to give it away for free, and to this we see people like barbs replying with personal attacks accusing the author of being mentally disturbed to the point of requiring therapy.
This is a personal attack at its worst.
Perhaps the issue here is the C programming language and how teaching it can be improved, not what insults and personal attacks a random user online is able to throw at the author of a technical book.
People have more to lean from writing on undefined behavior than puerile complains regarding comments on penis sizes and ironic accusations of immaturity.
> The guy invested his time and effort trying to improve the world by writing a technical book, which he then proceeded to give it away for free
And I think this is certainly laudable, especially since they seem to have helped so many people. But he also called the Rails community "pricks, morons, assholes, and arrogant fucks who didn’t care about the art or the craft." and I think he should be held accountable for that, amongst other things.
I wrote a comment about the author's behaviour in public forums and in blogs, something I think he should be held accountable for, and something which I believe hurts both him and the communities he participates in. I believe this is relevant, and I'm entitled to discuss this here.
This is a discussion on a book on the C programming language written by someone, and here you are going full throttle on your personal vendetta against the author while saying absolutely nothing regarding the book or the programming language.
> Sure, I'm discussing his character
Precisely.
Go vent your frustrations somewhere else.
I don't have an opinion on the actual topic, but whether someone's goal is others' perception of them, or they are just poorly optimizing it as a proxy for their sense of self worth, attacking every criticism head on could undermine how others perceive them, or it could waste their time and mental energy compared to other things they actually care about more than the measure of their achievements based on others perceptions.
Perhaps if you don't have an opinion on the actual topic, you should refrain from commenting on it the best thing you have to add are a series of ill-advised ad hominems.
But man, the guy is insecure to the point of requiring therapy or something. He seems obsessed with his image and status, and the slightest criticism will cause him to lash out in an immature and ridiculous manner. Past rants have him making lewd comments about penis-sizes and challenging others to a physical fight[1].
It's a shame, because if he just relaxed a bit and took criticism gracefully, he'd probably find himself to be a bit more valuable to the community and employers, and would actually be a pretty decent dude. Instead, his writing seems to reek of a constant need to validate and defend himself.
This is probably an unfair comparison, but I can't help but think of Terry Davis: a brilliant programmer hindered by mental issues. Schizophrenia is obviously not the same as insecurity, but I think the situation here is somewhat similar.
[0] http://programming-motherfucker.com/
[1] http://harmful.cat-v.org/software/ruby/rails/is-a-ghetto