Project Wonderful (http://www.projectwonderful.com/ ) already does a lot of what you've suggested. Advertisers choose sites, bid on them, and site hosts can approve ads individually so they always get relevant, unoffensive content.
But you're right, there's no reason they couldn't expand this sort of model to allow site hosts to pick ads as well.
In my opinion the key distinction is that you're directly serving ads as part of your content, instead of embedding some arbitrary external content into your pages. If you wanted to, you could just proxy Google/Doubleclick ads through your own webserver - except right now, they won't pay you to do that (even though it might get more impressions!)