News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AWS X1 instances – 1.9 TB of memory by throwaway2016a on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @01:11PM (#11723552)
I tend to agree with you on AWS. I swear by it. But in this case I would probably go at it this way...

How many hours can I run the machine before it costs more than building one? Probably a month? (random guess) Will I be running it longer than that?

If yes, build the machine, if no, just rent it from AWS.

I can't even imagine a scenario where I run this 24 hours a day 365 that I wouldn't build out a Hadoop cluster or similar for.

Re:AWS X1 instances – 1.9 TB of memory by zymhan on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @03:16PM (#11724897)
Well, the advantage of AWS is that you don't have to run it 24/7 unless your workload requires it.
Re:AWS X1 instances – 1.9 TB of memory by throwaway2016a on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @03:57PM (#11725331)
Exactly, so say you are running it 3 hours a day every day and it costs x an hour and you want an ROI on your hardware of 3 months. If y is the cost of building it...

if 3x * 90 > y build else rent

So at $13.338 (assuming no reserved instance) if y is less than $3600 you make your money back in 3 months. Of course a machine with those stats will not be $3600.

Re:AWS X1 instances – 1.9 TB of memory by eloff on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @10:00PM (#11727425)
Your math is off. At $13.338/hour you're looking at just shy of 10 grand per month ($9763 for a month of 30.5 days.)

It looks like one of these bad boys would set you back about $40000. So you'd break even at 4 months. If you're going to go for the 3 year reserved instance, with $100K upfront, you'd be way better off on capex and opex just buying and colocating the thing (not considering other expenses.)

The bigger you grow the more the balance tips towards do it yourself because your costs for colocation, managing hardware, etc amortize out better with scale. AWS gets a little better with scale but not nearly as quickly.

Re:AWS X1 instances – 1.9 TB of memory by throwaway2016a on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @11:25PM (#11727737)
My math isn't off... it's for 3 hours a day and I state that in my post (perhaps not clearly enough). Your number is for 24. The point was if you're not full utilization it could make sense.