News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by kevinh on Saturday March 06, 2010 @05:27PM (#1172320)
As naive as this may make me sound, I think this attitude is hurting society. The idea that everyone is and should be trying to screw everyone else out of as much pleasure and profit as legal is, in my opinion, detrimental to society.

When we stop doing things that don't negatively affect us much and help others, we've lost the benefits of altruism that helped our species evolve beyond the rest.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by lotharbot on Saturday March 06, 2010 @05:56PM (#1172380)
Perhaps a better way to phrase it: you should expect your customers to act in accordance with their best interests (as they understand them.) They aren't trying to "screw" you so much as trying to get the best value they can. Not viewing annoying ads is of value to people, which is why they go to the trouble of running adblock or paying for ad-free premium pages.

It's up to content providers to figure out how to get paid. Guilt-tripping readers into viewing ads is one approach; running skeezy ads is another; paywalls or premium content is another; merchandising yet another. Each of those affects the value your readers get from your site. Given that, how can content providers best align their interest (getting paid) with their readers' interests (getting good content cheap/free)?

I submit that, if sites ran carefully-vetted ads that were of legitimate interest to their readers, were not annoying, and did not compromise user privacy, far fewer of us would use adblock.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by rick888 on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:11PM (#1172422)
"I submit that, if sites ran carefully-vetted ads that were of legitimate interest to their readers, were not annoying, and did not compromise user privacy, far fewer of us would use adblock."

How do you know if the site has changed if you are using adblock? If they do decide to change ads, it won't really matter because they are already blocked.

What about people that are using a computer with adblock already installed? They never saw the ads on the blocked site.

Adblock doesn't just block one site's ads. It blocks entire networks of ads, which hurts innocent sites that may or may not have intrusive ads. This is why I can't support its usage.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by lotharbot on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:36PM (#1172571)
I'm speaking more generally, and more long-term. If the average content model on the web was "carefully vetted ads, of legitimate interest, not annoying, not privacy-compromising" then far fewer people would opt to use adblock in the first place.

For an individual site to get users who are already using adblock to stop, they may have to resort to the type of pleading or content-blocking Ars Technia did.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by bd on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:18PM (#1172650)
How do you know if the site has changed if you are using adblock? What about people that are using a computer with adblock already installed?

If, for example, your site has a community and ads are indeed "of legitimate interest", your community will discuss interesting ads. I have seen this happening on MetaFilter and Reddit.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by DennisP on Monday March 08, 2010 @09:55AM (#1175409)
The trouble might be that if your advertising message really is all that interesting, you can just submit it like any other story and people will vote it up.

Every now and then, an advertiser will make a mistake and pay for attention he could have gotten for free. But I don't think we can expect them to do that all the time. The only way to make money from advertising is to accept money from people who can't get attention otherwise.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by doron on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:23PM (#1172453)
I consider ads that are served from many well known ad services intrusive to my experience, they dramatically slow the rendering of pages, often block content, or have such jarring graphics or color themes it is almost impossible to read the document.

Ads are blocked for me by default, and i choose to unblock them in websites that generate repeated value for me.

this includes the content of the website, but also the speed and how the ads complement the design of the website itself.

I will consider paying website to get content completely ad free.

I would like to also have the option to get a discount for just clicking on the Ad from the vendor, if you want my attention offer me an incentive.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by ash on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:28PM (#1172677)
> I would like to also have the option to get a discount for just clicking on the Ad from the vendor, if you want my attention offer me an incentive.

AdSense doesn't allow sites to do this. I don't know about other services.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by barrkel on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:43PM (#1172692)
As many people love to point out, it's companies' fiduciary duty to screw people, impersonally, as much as possible. The distance and amenability to machine automation that technology adds makes it easier for customers to treat companies in a similar way.

What if the technology wasn't visible, wasn't in browsers, but instead was in our heads? What if we had a perfect ability to selectively filter out what we see and not let it affect us consciously, subconsciously or unconsciously? What if our awarenesses were so under our control that advertising could be scientifically proven to be useless?

Would this ability to focus our minds, free ourselves from distractions and pay deliberate attention only to what we willed, be morally or ethically wrong?

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by justinph on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:28PM (#1172458)
While I agree with the sentiment, that's a whole heck of a love of evolution to work against. Nature (think of life on the Serengeti) is all about screwing over one creature for the benefit of another.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by fexl on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:41PM (#1172577)
Human survival and wealth depend on voluntary production and trade. That is already baked into the evolutionary cake. If human behavior ever became "all about screwing over" other people, initiating force, and taking property without consent, then the human race would die out. Of course, a small portion of humans can and do live that way, but that is an aberration. If it ever becomes the norm, misery, illness, poverty, and death will prevail.

[Ed. note: As expected, "red in tooth and claw" is voted up, and "people need to cooperate" is voted down. If that's karma then I'll have no part of it.]

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by cabalamat on Sunday March 07, 2010 @07:34AM (#1173290)
> If human behavior ever became "all about screwing over" other people, initiating force, and taking property without consent,

Humans have been doing these things for as long as there have been humans...

> then the human race would die out.

...and this hasn't happened. Ergo, your argument is wrong.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by fexl on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:07AM (#1173321)
You are not responding to the argument that I made.

I said that if such behavior ever became the norm, the human race would die. As of now, only a small portion of humans behave this way. This happy fact enables humans to survive.

However, on the basis of your comment I will scale back my argument a bit. It might be possible for some humans to survive in a movie fantasy post-apocalyptic world of pure rampaging feral aggression. But the number would be very few. It would consist of a few people picking berries and hunting rabbits in secret, and gangs of others occasionally sniffing them out and looting them.

In reality, in order for a human being to survive, he must have things and services produced by other humans. He can't do it all himself. If he wants to ensure that other humans continue to produce the things he needs, the best way is to offer something in return.

Certainly voluntary trade is not his only option. He could plead hardship and gain some sympathy that way. He could commit fraud, deceiving others into giving him what he wants. He could use force to take what he wants.

But ultimately all of these options are limited and fraught with risks of their own. Why risk death when you can just wash a few dishes instead?

So yes, humans have been doing stupid evil things for as long as there have been humans, and they will continue to do so. My point is, stupidity and evil are not sustainable or reliable methods for achieving life, happiness, health, and wealth. That is why they are called "stupid" and "evil."

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by DennisP on Monday March 08, 2010 @10:06AM (#1175438)
> In reality, in order for a human being to survive, he must have things and services produced by other humans. He can't do it all himself.

Actually he can, and quite easily, as long as he's got the appropriate skills and the population density is low. We can survive comfortably in most environments; it's just that today our environment consists mostly of other humans.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by zaphar on Saturday March 06, 2010 @10:09PM (#1172796)
While cooperation makes logical sense. The statistics and study of human behaviour indicate that far from being an aberration "red in tooth and claw" is far more the norm.

Don't mistake culture and societal norms for the norms of natrual human behavior.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by skmurphy on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:32PM (#1174433)
One good book length counter-argument to "red in tooth and claw" is Robin Wright's "NonZero" (see summary site at http://www.nonzero.org/ for excerpts) that argues life's arrow is toward more complexity based on cooperation and that it's not a "zero sum game" where every gain is someone else's loss.

Wright's thesis for humanity is that people cooperate far more in the context of society than they did even 20,000 years ago, allowing for much larger populations. This larger population enables more diversity and further complexity.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by fexl on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:10AM (#1173323)
What statistics? Why do you differentiate between "cultural and societal norms" and "natural human behavior?" Cultural and societal norms are natural human behaviors.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by scrod on Sunday March 07, 2010 @02:17AM (#1173024)
I sure hope you're not suggesting that the recognition and protection of private property is somehow linked with the survival of the species, because that would demonstrate a pretty shallow view of history.

Indeed, the notion of "private property" often comes hand in hand with authoritarian force: http://everything2.com/title/The+Enclosure+Movement

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by fexl on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:27AM (#1173339)
You have linked to a story of people who used authoritarian force to violate private property. The people who took that land from its rightful owners were thieves.

Rightful property is established by production or trade. A rough recursive definition goes: Your body and mind are your property. If you make a thing using your property, that thing is your property. If you obtain a thing by trading your property for it, that thing is your property. (I view "gift" as a special case of trade, where the price is zero.)

I would also define "trade" as a voluntary contractual interaction between two parties. The word "voluntary" precludes force, and the word "contractual" precludes fraud.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by rudzki on Sunday March 07, 2010 @11:43PM (#1174672)
It's a little bit more complicated. I mean, suppose it's true that the only things you own are your mind, body, and the things you make using them. Then, the only things you can legitimately own are your mind, body, and bodily waste. Oh, and spit. So, there must be something else that you can own. For Locke, you can own land and other natural resources by mixing your labor with it. (But what this really means is a matter of serious debate, involving very old people wearing argyle socks, pipe tobacco, and tenure)
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by fexl on Monday March 08, 2010 @11:15AM (#1175625)
I think the recursion gets off the ground better than that. Notice that I said "if you make a thing using your property, that thing is your property." Property starts with your mind and body but it doesn't end there.

Certainly an infant produces spit, vomit, and poop. But it doesn't stop there. The infant also produces cuteness, affection, and love. In any case the parents give the infant food, shelter, education, and care for free. Those are gifts.

So the infant grows into a strong, healthy, and wise adult. He obtains that position largely through gifts from his parents, but he has also done some production and trade along the way, for example any jobs he did as a teenager.

Now he produces far more than spit, vomit, and poop. He uses his mind and body to produce all sorts of things other people value. He owns the products of his mind and body right up until the time he trades them for something else.

Simple example: he buys a set of tools using the money he earned as a teenager cutting grass and starts a small repair business. He is now using both the physical and intellectual capital he has accumulated over the years to produce even more goods and services. That capital is his property.

So my definition gets off the ground far better than you suggest. Spit and poop ... you so funny!

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by yters on Saturday March 06, 2010 @11:52PM (#1172888)
Which is why society didn't evolve, it was designed. Only design can create global states which are contrary to local conditions.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by pook on Sunday March 07, 2010 @07:51AM (#1173304)
What do you mean?

"Design" as in the memetic evolution has an unnaturally recursive feedback system compared to our biological evolution, thus producing patterns of regularity determined by initial tiny quirks? Or what the people who downmodded you seem to think you meant?

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by yters on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:09PM (#1173908)
I've no idea what's controversial about what I said. I write my comments using design, not random variation and natural selection. It's pretty obvious we do the same with societal institutions.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by Tichy on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:11PM (#1172531)
This is a little bit silly. By not watching ads, I am screwing somebody? How about by watching ads I screw the people who paid for the ads, as there is no way those ads would affect me in a positive way? I don't see how one is worse than the other. If a web site asks people who hate ads to watch ads, they are screwing the people who pay for the ads. They should be thankful for ad blockers, because at least they prevent me from getting negative emotions towards the advertised stuff.

If I block ads, the site should have a higher conversion rate, so they should be able to ask for more money for the ad impressions.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by dandelany on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:29PM (#1172559)
> This is a little bit silly. By not watching ads, I am screwing somebody?

Yes. As Ars said explicitly in their post, every time you choose to block the rendering of an ad on their page, their ad provider does not count the impression, and they do not get paid anything. So yes, you're directly screwing Ars by costing them money, denying them revenue, and nullifying their business model.

> If a web site asks people who hate ads to watch ads, they are screwing the people who pay for the ads.

In the first instance, "screwing" means "putting out of business". In the second, it means "mildly inconveniencing".

> If I block ads, the site should have a higher conversion rate

Again, if you'd read Ars' post, you would know that they are paid on impressions, not conversion rate.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by vannevar on Sunday March 07, 2010 @01:12PM (#1173730)
The effects you cite are not independent: 'costing them money' and 'denying them revenue' are the same thing, and both flow from 'nullifying their business model.' But lots of companies have their business model nullified (ask BlockBuster). They either find another one or they go out of business and a smarter outfit with a better model takes their place.

If everyone blocked ads, no one would serve them. They would charge for content. This is probably the fairest model for everyone. But content providers like Ars want to mislead their customers into thinking they are getting something for free, so they make their money from advertising: that is, they don't sell content, they use content as 'bait' to attract attention and then sell that attention to advertisers. An ad-blocker is acting perfectly ethically and rationally by refusing to give their attention---after all, Ars is pretending to be free, you can hardly blame the viewers who take them up on the offer. The only ones being screwed by this are the non-blocking viewers, who are forced to give more of their attention to compensate for the blockers.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by dandelany on Sunday March 07, 2010 @03:22PM (#1173930)
> 'costing them money' and 'denying them revenue' are the same thing

No they're not. The point I was making is that you necessarily cost them money every time you visit a page, but by blocking the ad, you're also denying them the revenue that would balance out that cost.

> But content providers like Ars want to mislead their customers into thinking they are getting something for free

I think that even the least savvy of Internet users understand the advertising model. No one is "misled" to believe that running a site like Ars costs nothing. They're not "pretending to be free" any more than a newspaper full of ads is.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by vannevar on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:24PM (#1174417)
You're correct that visiting the page does impose an infinitesimal marginal cost. The economics would remain the same, however, if there were no cost at all for viewing the site. The content still costs money to produce. The real issue here is the denial of revenue, which as I said flows logically from nullifying the business model.

Ars wants people to think that they are in the business of reporting tech news, when in fact they are in the business of selling individuals to advertisers. I don't see any notices on Ars explicitly asking people to view ads in exchange for viewing content. The reason is that doing so would confront people with the reality of the site and turn them off, even though many of them understand the ad model in principle. And yes, a newspaper full of ads is also pretending to be free.

If Ars won't explicitly require their users to view ads, then they can hardly complain when people skip them. I have no sympathy.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by Tichy on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:55PM (#1172607)
"Again, if you'd read Ars' post, you would know that they are paid on impressions, not conversion rate."

I read that, but as I said, if they have a higher conversion rate, they should be able to negotiate a higher fee for the ads anyway.

On the other aspects, I guess we just disagree (why is it worse to screw advertisers than ad pushing people)?

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by doron on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:29PM (#1172678)
revenue from impressions is a speculative hogwash remnant of the print medium and needs to go

The idea one makes money from ads simply by having it displayed is copying a highly speculative advertising model of print (where the effect can hardly be measured) to the web (where you can measure it be by actual clicks) put simply its vaporware of the worst kind, and a business that hedges its revenue on this model is hedging its existence on speculation alone.

The premise of advertising on the web is highly informed by age old print models that have failed that industry and put into doubt the efficacy of anything that is uttered in them.

users have a choice. You want effective Ads on the web, offer the users something,so they wont block you. or go away. effective Ads on the web are to be about incentive.

I own the delivery device, i can manipulate it as i will. This is not a newspaper, i control it, not the vendor. i will do what i want with it. the business owner need to give me a an incentive.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by mrkurt on Saturday March 06, 2010 @09:57PM (#1172782)
I almost agree with you about the speculative nature of CPM based ads, but there's value in running branding campaigns, particularly for the kinds of companies that advertise on our site (I work for Ars).

It's awfully hard to measure that value in any kind of meaningful way, but brand awareness is worth spending money on in many cases.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by Tichy on Sunday March 07, 2010 @04:15AM (#1173124)
I was surprised that Ars is payed by impressions, I thought it is all pay per click these days.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by mrkurt on Sunday March 07, 2010 @12:59PM (#1173702)
It depends where the ads are running. Ads you see on big content sites are almost always on a CPM model. Fixed price ads (like you see on TechCrunch or TheDeck) are generally based on a CPM rate.

Pay per click ads aren't generally worth enough money to sustain sites that produce content. Aggregators, search engines, social networks, etc, have a much, much lower cost per pageview, and can do pretty well. On Ars, we'd need to average about 50,000 pageviews per normal post to pay the writer for it with something like Google AdSense. And that's assuming that the campaigns AdSense picks are pretty good.

There are whitepaper links and stuff you can get much better CPC rates for, but those generally only work if you're sneaky about them and embed them in content, or make them look like site resources.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by bobbyi on Saturday March 06, 2010 @09:20PM (#1172746)
Am I screwing PBS if I watch one of their programs and don't give a donation?
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by philk on Sunday March 07, 2010 @07:05AM (#1173262)
I'm not sure it's a particularly new development. People have been acting in their own self-interest for time immemorial.

(And indeed economic models which work on the basis of enlightened self interest have been the most successful and delivered the most good to their adherents).

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by scott_s on Saturday March 06, 2010 @05:43PM (#1172349)
My reaction, which I think has similar meaning to what you said but doesn't contain the same subtly of your comment, is: This is not sustainable.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by kscaldef on Saturday March 06, 2010 @05:57PM (#1172383)
My feeling is exactly the opposite. Sustainable is coming up with business models where you provide something of value that people are willing to pay for. OTOH, steadily cranking up the quantity of advertising (already at the point where many newspapers and magazines are over 50% ads, TV is 1/3 ads, and many movies are little more than a continuous string of product placements) is _not_ sustainable.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by scott_s on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:09PM (#1172417)
I suppose "this" is ambiguous, but I was thinking about the whole situation.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by jrockway on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:04PM (#1172404)
Your argument, while emotional, leads nowhere. So not viewing ads hurts society; why should I care whether or not I hurt society? Now we are right back where we started.
Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by kevinh on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:17PM (#1172437)
If people don't view the ads, the site shuts down. Maybe you don't like that site all that much, so it's fine. However, more and more sites would shut down due to lack of funding. Or, perhaps, they find different manners of obtaining money. Maybe they enforce pay walls, maybe they have product placement in their articles.

The fact is, most advertising is not obtrusive. Despite the problems that Google Ads has, it is not visually obtrusive. Hell, half of the time I don't even notice them. Does it hurt me? No. Does it help the site sustain itself? Yes. Would I notice a pay wall or product placement? Yes. Would it obstruct my enjoyment of the website? Yes.

To directly answer your question: you should care if you hurt society. If people stop being altruistic altogether, politeness and civility go out the window. An Ayn Rand style system pops up, with people being concerned how to give themselves the most power and goods while screwing others over the most. Maybe you're fine with that; I'm not.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by el_dot on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:35PM (#1172568)
While I am in agreement with the sentiment, these "its good for society" arguments don't really move anybody. Just look at the music industry and it's pleas against piracy. Most people don't view their actions at such a global level; they do what's best for them and those close to them. If ads disturb them, then guess what? Ars technica will be releasing a few more staff. And most people won't care either, they'll just move on to the next thing. Thats just nature my friend. A taste of natural selection: adapt or die.

It would be much more practical to create things that boost advertising's strengths, but mute the weaknesses, rather than trying to convince people that current ads are good/tolerable. Like you pointed out, Google Ads are a step in the right direction, but obviously still lacking. The market always points you in the right direction, better to listen than to fight it.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by njharman on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:10PM (#1172529)
Realize that that idea is capitalism* or at least the inevitable side-effect of capitalism. And that the altrusim idea is socialism.

* as practiced in real life not some wanker's theoretical definition.

PS it was probably selfishness and greed (combined with tribal "us vs them" so that (generally) you'll steal from the fuckers in next valley over but not your children) that helped our species destroy and/or exceed our competition.

Re:Advertising is devastating to my well-being by jwhite on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:46PM (#1172699)
I highly recommend "The Red Queen" by Matt Ridley for a really interesting look at what might have caused our species to develop this way. It is not as simple as one might think.