Can you explain why not?
Unless there's some explicit prior agreement, I have no obligation to use my resources to render something in some specific manner, or at all.
Online ads fall into the same technological mismatch as online music. It's the application of solid-to-the-touch thinking to a fluid digital medium.
Web pages are not print. Don't base your business model on a different medium. (Ask the RIAA how well that works out.)
My browser requests some HTML; what it does with it on my end is up to me. If I don't want to waste time and resources making additional requests for other content, that's my business. If I don't want to render everything specified in the HTML, that's my choice. If I want to skip elements, apply custom CSS, block scripts, all are my choices.
And you better go tell Google their business model doesn't work before we're all left without a search engine!
Absolutely! It's my choice what I will render on my machine, and it's the server's choice what it will send me when I make a particular request. If they are capable of detecting when I've blocked ads and choose to deny my request for the content, that's well within their rights.
Then again, Ars is one of the few sites that will actively ban your account if you use ad blocking. But so far, I think they've only removed accounts for comments/forums, not the whole shebang.
Split test it first of course if you are reading this Ken!
OK, but the assertion was that it was unethical, not that it was unreasonable.
I agree that there's a downside and I may end up spiting myself, but it's not unethical for me to do so.
2) When an ad annoys you, enable your ad blocker for that site.
3) If you actually enjoy the content the site provides, you should let them know why you're blocking their ads so they can fix the problem. Otherwise, if everyone does what you do, the site will cease to exist.
3) You surely know that, that is a waste of time, 1. they already know, 2. they won't respond or do anything
"Right-click on a banner and choose “Adblock” from the context menu — the banner won’t be downloaded again. Maybe even replace parts of the banner address with star symbols to block similar banners as well."
The AdBlockPlus documentation explains how to limit specific rules to certain sites. (EDIT: http://adblockplus.org/en/filters#elemhide_domains) If you get filters from someone else, you're probably blocking ads that don't bother you on sites you enjoy, which sounds counterproductive to me.
(I'm actually surprised more sites haven't started responding by proxying ad content through their own servers to make it harder to block.)
The Ars thread touches on this, where Kurt mentions that Doubleclick's ad deployment isn't smart enough to detect flash-blockers and serve a static ad, and Ars isn't permitted to replace Doubleclick's deployment code.
Also your effectively blocking a particular ad supplier not a domain that has a poor ad policy.