Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by wesleytodd on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @04:32PM
(#11725655)
Any good streaming solution needs to transcode multiple bitrates and formats. You either need to do that on the source machine or across the network somehow.
Doing it on the source machine is technically easier, but much more heavy weight on machine. Doing it on the network means that the transcode is happening multiple times, which can result in playback issues if you get a source segment from two different transcodes.
I have thought about doing something like this because I work for a streaming company, but have always come to some roadblock like the one above for a "real" application of this technique. I wonder how they have solved this.
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by Veratyr on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @08:55PM
(#11727196)
> Doing it on the network means that the transcode is happening multiple times, which can result in playback issues if you get a source segment from two different transcodes.
Not necessarily. H.264 Annex G specifies a way to encode lower quality subset bitstreams in a higher quality bitstream. Drop some packets and bam, you've got a lower quality stream.
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by elif on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @06:32PM
(#11726559)
If you control the client, multiple formats are unnecessary. As we transition to gigabit the need for multiple bitrates becomes diminished, but even now I would argue you could get by just fine with just 2. Most TV shows and movies you torrent today are uploaded with 2-3 quality tiers anyway.
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by nflx on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @06:02PM
(#11726356)
This is really good for the sports streaming community.
The current landscape is either a paid site — which is really only http://hehestreams.xyz right now (but it's awesome) — an AceStream link (quality suffers), one of the really janky sports streaming sites where you get blasted with ads, or a YouTube link which likely gets taken down before you can sit down and enjoy it.
AceStream, while good, doesn't have the backing of someone like BitTorrent.
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @04:01PM
(#11725380)
Historically, 5-10 years ago, it'd be between 30-40% of total internet traffic. Its come down close to ~7% in the last few years with Netflix, Hulu, and other over the top services being available.
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by aznpwnzor on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @06:34PM
(#11726571)
Why isn't this a licensing deal to established content deliverers? It seems to only alleviate provider cost. If this actually does solve a problem, why wouldn't they just work on getting Netflix to buy into it?
Re:BitTorrent unveils new live-streaming platform
by erikpukinskis on Wednesday May 18, 2016 @06:48PM
(#11726648)
Cost has totally different determinants at different scales. At the smallest scales, fixed costs overwhelm variable costs. As you scale up and architectural needs change, there are steps in the cost function. Just because something is cost effective at one scale doesn't mean it's cost effective at all scales.
Personally, I think peer to peer streaming is most interesting for open source projects. You can host static code for free and then use something like this to do streaming. The developer pays nothing, and bandwidth fees are born entirely by the user.
Doing it on the source machine is technically easier, but much more heavy weight on machine. Doing it on the network means that the transcode is happening multiple times, which can result in playback issues if you get a source segment from two different transcodes.
I have thought about doing something like this because I work for a streaming company, but have always come to some roadblock like the one above for a "real" application of this technique. I wonder how they have solved this.
And now I care about this much less...
source: http://blog.bittorrent.com/2016/05/17/bittorrent-live-multic...
Looking through their Wikipedia page, it seems like a list of flops or freeware. Are they actually profitable?
Not necessarily. H.264 Annex G specifies a way to encode lower quality subset bitstreams in a higher quality bitstream. Drop some packets and bam, you've got a lower quality stream.
AAC specifies something similar for audio.
Wikipedia has a lot of information and some links that may be useful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalable_Video_Coding
The current landscape is either a paid site — which is really only http://hehestreams.xyz right now (but it's awesome) — an AceStream link (quality suffers), one of the really janky sports streaming sites where you get blasted with ads, or a YouTube link which likely gets taken down before you can sit down and enjoy it.
AceStream, while good, doesn't have the backing of someone like BitTorrent.
Interesting read: http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-fascinating-local-c...
Personally, I think peer to peer streaming is most interesting for open source projects. You can host static code for free and then use something like this to do streaming. The developer pays nothing, and bandwidth fees are born entirely by the user.