HN Rant: Come and Go Voting
Must have ticked somebody off, I guess.
I upvote a few of the better comments and move on.
Then I go and read about the new Chrome HN extensions. Nice job!
Now I can upvote and downvote.
I go back to the healthcare essay. Still no ability to downvote.
Does anybody here besides the coders of HN want to support the idea that the user can have abilities come and go on a whim and this is going to make for a enjoyable user experience? HN keeps getting more and more nuanced about who can do what when, and, quite frankly, all it seems to do is intermittently piss me off. If it's making things better I can't see it. And even if it is, you don't screw around with system behavior without notifying your user of what's going on.
I'm sure somebody will point me to some thread somewhere or another where pg explains that for condition X we're not allowing users to downvote. And also frankly, that's part of the problem. Understanding the system shouldn't require extreme devotion to every little thing said about it over a period of years on every thread related to HN. A system should be simple to use and understand. HN is still simple to use, but beats me if I can understand it any more.
So am I out here all alone in this feeling, or is it bothering other HNer's as well?
Lines 1095-1098 control whether the downvote arrow is displayed or not.
So, to answer your question, yes, it bothers me that there's very rarely a clear enumeration or description of features.
On the other hand, it's been a wonderful opportunity to learn Arc.
(I'm only half joking - Arc was actually my first stab at functional programming and I probably wouldn't have tried it if pg had bothered to document HN's features)
Since hacker news has managed to keep a relatively similiar experience despite a large increase in users, its pretty clear(subjectively) that some of these measures are working.
You should probably worry about it less.
Worry is not part of this conversation.
the way hn is developed is very open, and I dont imagine becoming the most easily understandable news site on the web is a particular goal for this place, so speaking in truisms like "dont modify users behaviour" doesnt mean much.
Nobody is saying pg can't experiment. Nobody is saying that the site isn't great, open, wonderful, etc.
Just pointing out that inconsistencies in experience -- even to people who like the app and enjoy the benefits -- piss off the users.
You can care about that or not. Fair game. You can "worry" about how the system works or not. Still ticks people off, and people are still going to point it out.
Telling the user that their feedback isn't as important as the overall purpose of the site may also be true, but that's also not the point.
As with other measures PG takes to try to prevent abuse of the system, and occasional abuse by people of people on the system, it may be that there is a mechanism by which he can disable downvoting on a given item.
In this instance it wouldn't surprise me. Completely guessing here, but healthcare is one of the topics that can provoke intense reactions, and people can get very heated, and downvoting can pile on, even when it's not really justified. Replies and comments can get unpleasant, so disabling downvoting may be a defence.
I'm not defending the way the system works, and I occasionally wish it were more open, but this site is still working reasonably well despite its popularity. I think that is mostly because of the occasional draconian and obscure measure.
I've given up worrying about wrinkles like this. They still annoy me on occasion, but I shrug and move on. The site continues to decline, but less quickly than others I've been on. I accept that I won't know everything about the way the site works, and part of the reason for that enables it to continue to do so.
I was pretty sure that downvoting is disabled as soon as a comment is one day old. Check out the "bestcomments" list and you'll see that you can only downvote the ones that are less than 24 hours old.
I can currently downvote several of the <1-day comments on the healthcare story. But maybe I'm seeing something different from you, or it has changed since this post was made.
I'm a hacker. I like knowing how things work. If I have a little up and down arrow, I want to click it and watch the little number get bigger or smaller. It's not too much to ask, is it?
It's already impossible to determine how the system sorts -- but I think that bit of obscurity works for everybody. Having buttons appear or disappear randomly sounds like a way to annoy people.
There's also the issue of the buttons not actually changing the score -- another pain for some users.
I thought it was important to write down what I was thinking at the time, not only in terms of HN but also for other people writing web apps.
Interesting that it got the attention that it did.
Voting helps to create a useful structure for the content but it's not why I’m here. It’s not what’s fun about HN.
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Polls_are_evil
In fact, thinking about it just gave me an idea for a feature request: I might be better off if commenting was disabled for me for good. Overall I am mostly embarrassed that I wrote so many comments, and commenting wastes a lot more time than just voting.
I like to read people's comments on subjects, often there is useful additional information. Not sure what I actually gain from commenting myself, other than the "someone is wrong on the internet" effect.
Thanks in advance (and please don't shoot me -- I tried to find it, really).
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1168065
or the direct link:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=avRF...
News.ycomb could get rid of all comment moderation and it would probably be at least as good. Maybe better. Suddenly what "Karma" means would become clear. It isn't some mixture of popularity poll and story contributor, it's just a measure of how popular the stories you've contributed would be.
My karma is over 2000, and it's almost all from comments. Maybe 100 of this karma is from stories. I consider it to be very artificial and meaningless, because most comment voting is basically "I AGREE!" or "I DISAGREE!". I wish I had karma from contributing stories that people wanted to share.
- It gives me direct feedback on whether other users found my comments insightful. I find it encouraging when I put some effort into explaining something and I get a bunch of points for it. I'd much rather get upvotes than a bunch of meaningless replies like "I agree", "good post", or "x2". (Getting substantive replies is even better, but not always warranted.)
- It gives me an easy way to find comments others have found insightful, even if they're nested deep in a thread where they don't get auto-sorted to the top. I was actually planning to ask for highlighting on highly-rated comments -- something unobtrusive like bolding the number.
- It gives me a way to reward/encourage those whose comments I found educational or insightful.
Downvoting can also provide an injection of dumbness or ill will into a conversation. But I would take the dumbness of downvotes over the dumbness of people saying "you're an idiot" any day.
But in case PG doesn't look at scores, I second this.
If someone says something you like and agree with: congratulations, you have found a kindred soul, enjoy this moment of warmth in an otherwise dark and unforgiving universe. If someone says something you dislike or disagree with: if it's not worth posting a rationally and carefully written rebuttal to the post in question then it's probably not worth your time or effort, the internet is full of people who are wrong.
In general that tiny number next to posts is more an indication of things other than the quality of the ideas expressed in posts. In fact, I'd say they're not well coupled. Usually, it's more correlated with political alignments or writing quality.
People like voting. They like scoring systems. As much as folks might say "who cares?" study after study has shown that if you provide a numerical feedback/points system, it's going to motivate users. So I'd leave the points in.
There is a second question: what should be at the top of my display? This doesn't have to be tied so closely to the scoring. It's probably much more related to the type of material as well as the overall voting activity.
I think you've tightly linked these two concepts, voting and sorting -- lots of other boards do the same thing -- and the linkage is what is causing the mismatch.
With the app I'm currently writing, sorting happens based on a Bayesian system of matching up tags from what you've liked in the past. The tag-for-sort seems to work a lot better than the vote-for-sort.