I think there is value in having our population exposed to a diverse range of textbooks. I can't prove it, but I suspect that a homogenous education system would be detrimental to our economy. One of our national strengths is innovation, which comes partly from having a number of people looking at the same problem in different ways.
For high school level Math, not really. The downside I can see is that you stifle any innovation in teaching methodology.
A yet better way would be to have these books as open-source and anyone is able to print them at their homes/public livrary/etc.
This already happens in most primary schools because buying new copies every year is prohibitively expensive.
If you assume that a student uses ~10 books a year and that they last 10 years, with $200 books you get grade schools spending about $200 per student per year on books. If it's 20 books and 5 years, it's $800 per student per year.
So while there is probably an obvious opportunity for grade schools to save money on cheaper books, it's also pretty obvious that it isn't the main component of educational spending at that level (the high price scenario puts it at less than 10%).
I think things have gotten worse, but I probably only spent $1500 on books in college (and ~$40,000 on in state tuition). So that's a noticeable fraction, but it wasn't in any way something to worry much over compared to the total costs.
Which is who the government wastes so much money outsourcing in the first place. It's all defused pain for personal gain.
Until the federal government starts pushing a religious agenda. Then everyone here would want textbooks from, say, California.
This gives the WHOLE Sotry .. How Bill Gates pulled off the swift Common Core revolution
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/how-bill-gates-pulle...
Depends on if you trust the federal government to do a better job selecting a textbook than the state you currently live in.
It can merely create a few options (from the best professionals it can find on the entire federation), and make them available for the federated entities.
If we weren't a federal system, the national government would be dictating much more about education than it currently is.
I think you meant massive anti-federalism.
If we had a federal procurement system for math and english textbooks, after being put out for a nationwide bid, the per-unit cost would be about 10% over the cost of paper and printing. (the 10% premium is the bid adjustment for a women or minority owned business)
Now $8 textbooks wouldn't save a lot of money compared to the national education budget, but it would be a good start. And do we really need regional variations in math textbooks?