Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:29PM
(#11714942)
> That's why there is no jury in all countries that I know of except America.
The UK uses juries in much the same way as the US does, as do many other countries whose legal systems derives from that of the UK (which are a fair number, because colonialism.)
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by piptastic on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:08PM
(#11714764)
What do other countries do?
Is the decision made by one person that has these same fallacies? At least the risk is spread out some in the jury situation.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by burkaman on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:22PM
(#11714881)
Other countries definitely use juries, just not as universally as the US. They more often just have a judge or a panel of judges, or sometimes a sort of jury that includes judges.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by antris on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:29PM
(#11714950)
Proper training alleviates these fallacies. I trust a judge much better than a jury of random people.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by yompers888 on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:51PM
(#11715143)
On the other hand, the random jury doesn't have the same perverse incentives and web of relationships that support conviction.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by r00fus on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @12:55PM
(#11715174)
Would you still trust that judge that was elected to office with lobbyist money?
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by burkaman on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @01:07PM
(#11715271)
I think electing judges might also be a uniquely American thing, and less than half the country does it. It's a much weirder practice than using juries. Obviously you can still say a judge was appointed by people elected with lobbyist money, but it's not that direct.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by lucb1e on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @01:09PM
(#11715297)
Might be my lack of knowledge in the subject, but I've never heard of electing judges. Isn't it just a study and a background check or so, at least in western Europe?
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by burkaman on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @01:12PM
(#11715322)
Not only do some states have elections, but they have partisan elections, which is just obviously a dumb idea. I have no idea how it works in other countries, but in most US states judges are either elected by the legislature or appointed by the governor.
Re:Stanford quantifies the privacy-stripping power of metadata
by antris on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @06:34PM
(#11718138)
Judges are not elected in my country, so can't comment on that.
I'm not sure if a jury is a bad idea, when I first learned of it, I kinda liked the idea, but I'm worried about this kind of reasoning...