Coincidentally I've driven Feynman's van. In fact it's the quality of Feynman's highly accessible writing that has me so disappointed in half-assed articles such as this one.
A young, knowledge-hungry, enthusiastic crowd such as HN deserves BETTER input, not junk like this. Surely we can retain the positivity while culling the crap.
If tpacek downvotes a crypto post it probably shouldn't sit on the homepage all day. But that's not the structure here.
Better would be a post that explains what's wrong with the post, or a better submission.
I, for example, haven't driven Feynman's van and my math is quite rusty, but I sure enjoyed the post and the following discussion.
Last week's idiotic neural net post involved data compression. It's now a top Google result atop research papers from the people who actually figured it out 30 years ago. I'm eager to see next week's thriller... see ya in the comments. If I get in early enough I'll fix it with love; if I get in late again I may or may not take the time to question why we keep doing things this way. And if I do a half-assed job with either, I'll certainly appreciate people telling me so. Might not work for everyone, but seems to open doors for me--including driver's side on the van.
Even assuming you're 100% right, hauling in barrels of garbage and dumping them in the commons is not a good reaction.
To me, the risk to Hacker News is that comments inconsistent with HN's ethos of civility, dissuade people from the vulnerability that comes when one posts original work. And I'd prefer people put a bit more effort into writing thoughtful and reflective comments.